ACTS 17:11-"...IN THAT THEY RECEIVED THE WORD WITH ALL READINESS OF MIND, AND SEARCHED THE SCRIPTURES DAILY, WHETHER THOSE THINGS WERE SO."
Dec 8, 2007
Chapter 62 - Hardshells on Gill V
Neo-Hardshells today affirm the near universal salvation of the heathen, and in doing so, have had to "water down" the scriptural experience and meaning of regeneration and the new birth, making it a "hollow log" experience, a "bunch of nothing."
In 1785, when Elder Carey preached on the need of sending God's gospel to these lost heathen souls, it is reported that Elder John Ryland said to him - "SIT DOWN, young man; when God wants to convert the heathen, He'll do it without your help and mine."
That rebuke by Elder Ryland, if it occurred (I have had other historians to question its veracity), truly came from a Hyper-Calvinistic heart. It is contrary to the understanding of most Baptists, however, and certainly contrary to the first Baptist of Mississippi.
I cite now what I wrote earlier in this work (chapter eight) as pertinent again for this chapter in our series on Dr. Gill.
"Often the Hardshells speak of how "beautiful" this teaching of wholesale heathen salvation, without a conversion to Christianity, is to them. The only thing, according to Hardshell "theologians," that those non-Christian, yet "born again" people, get for their heathenish ways, is the loss of some joy in this life!
Also, Hardshells think that all this glorifies God, who they say, saves them "without any help from man." Or, "God has given the heathen to Christ," they say, and he did it "without Bibles, the Gospel, or a preacher."
How contrary all this is to what the really Old Baptists believed about the matter. For Griffin, in his "History," says that the first Baptists of Mississippi stated in a resolution that they should stir up themselves to "send the gospel to every human being, for it is God's method by which he will give to His Son the heathen for his inheritance, and the remotest parts of the earth for his possession" (page 100).
Also, the Hardshells never consider that the “arguments” they make on the heathen and about "regeneration" fall back into their faces when it comes to conversion. If it "takes away" from God's sovereignty and sole glory for him to use "human means" and "human agents" in "regeneration," then why does it not do the same when He "converts" by human means and agents?"
Would Dr. Gill have said "amen" to John Ryland's rebuke to Carey were he present to hear it? Would the first Baptists of Mississippi have done so?
In my series of chapters on "Addresses to the Lost," I ended with an avalanche of scripture that clearly proved that all the heathen are lost, and are as the apostle affirmed - "without God and without hope in the world." We will see that Dr. Gill also acquiesced in that view.
Recall also how Sarrels, in his Hardshell "Systematic Theology," taught that many heathen have a genuine hope of salvation, and "as good a one as any Christian." We will see that Dr. Gill repudiated that view.
So, I will now give the citations from Dr. Gill, from his "Body of Divinity," from the section on "the state and case of the heathens," and then make numerous observations and comments (with some comments made in between citations).
"Of The State and Case of the Heathens"
"In favor of the doctrines of absolute election and reprobation, particular redemption, and special grace in conversion, we observe, that, for many ages, God suffered the heathen world to walk in their own ways, leaving them without a revelation of his mind and will, without the gospel, and means of grace; and which has been, and still is, the case of multitudes to this day. This it cannot reasonably be thought he would have done, had it been according to the counsel of his will that all the individuals of mankind should be saved, and come to the knowledge of the truth; or had Christ died for and redeemed them all; or was it the will of God to bestow on all men sufficient grace, whereby they may be saved. Nor can it be thought that God deals more severely with men, according to the above doctrines, than he seems to have done with the heathen world in this respect: particularly, in favor of God’s decrees, it is observed, that if God conveys his gospel to, and bestows the means of grace on some people, and not on others, when the one are no more worthy of it than the other, and so must arise from his free grace, sovereign pleasure, and the counsel of his will; why may not the decree of the end of bestowing salvation on some, and not on others, as well as the decree of the means of sending the gospel to some, and not to others, be thought to be equally free, absolute, and sovereign? And seeing it is in fact certain, that the greatest part of mankind have been always left destitute of the means of grace, we need not wonder why that God, who freely communicates the knowledge of himself by the gospel to some nations, denying it to others, should hold the same method with individuals that he doth with whole bodies: for the rejecting of whole nations by the lump, for so many ages, is much more unaccountable than the selecting of a few to be infallibly conducted to salvation, and leaving others in that state of disability in which they shall inevitably fail of it."
Contrary to Elder Gowens, who denies any "means of grace" whatever, Dr. Gill affirmed them! According to Dr. Gill, the Lord "decreed the end as well as the means (gospel revelation)," so it is assured all the elect will hear the gospel. According to Dr. Gill, how does one come to "know God"?
Dr. Gill continues:
"Besides, though we know so little of the future state of heathens from the Scripture, yet we are not altogether at an uncertainty about either the measure or duration of their punishment; for as to the former, we are told (Matthew 11:21, 22) that it shall be more tolerable for Tyre and Sidon, for the inhabitants of these places, who had not the advantage of Christ’s ministry and miracles, at the day of judgment, than for the inhabitants of Chorazin and Bethsaida, who were favored with them; and it is reasonable to conclude, that this will hold good of all men, without a divine revelation; and as to the latter, it is certain, when our Lord shall descend from heaven, he will take vengeance on them that know not God, the Gentiles, and that obey not the gospel of our lord Jesus Christ; meaning such who have enjoyed, but have neglected and despised the means of grace; who, one as well as another, shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord, and the glory of his power (2 Thess. 1:8, 9). Moreover, whereas it is suggested, that Providence may put the heathens into a better state before their final doom, since God overlooked the times of their former ignorance (Acts 17:30), there being the like reason for his still overlooking them; it should be observed, that God’s overlooking the times of heathen ignorance, was not an instance of his kindness and goodness, but of his disregard unto them: the meaning is, that he looked over them, took no notice of them, made no revelation to them, but left them in their blindness and ignorance, without giving them any helps, or sending them any persons to instruct and teach them."
Two integral elements of modern Hardshellism are thus denied by Dr. Gill: 1) Some who reject the gospel are saved, and 2) some who die without revelation (heathen) are nevertheless saved.
How would Dr. Gill answer Daily's question on "necessity"? Does his view of the necessity of a divine revelation of gospel truth not do the thing that Daily says the Baptists, prior to the division with the "New School," did not do? i. e., - "damns all the heathen who have never heard"?
Dr. Gill continues:
"We also know of no such covenant made with, nor of any tender of it, nor of any publication of it to the heathen world; but rather, that all that are destitute of revelation, are strangers to the covenant of promise (Eph. 2:12), which passage likewise acquaints us, that such as are without the knowledge of Christ, and God in Christ, are without hope; and that such who live and die so, have no good ground of hope of eternal life and salvation; which plainly points out the state and case of the heathens, and leaves us at no great uncertainty about it..."
Where is there any intimation that Dr. Gill "changed his mind" on the means of the gospel and of its necessity in regeneration and salvation? How then can any Hardshell still affirm, as did Elder Potter in his closing speech with Elder Throgmorton, on the question - "Who Are The Primitive Baptists?" - that Dr. Gill was "our man"? It is ludicrous and made to fool the ignorant and unlearned. In the above words Dr. Gill clearly says that all who die without gospel revelation are lost eternally (Unless God uses some "secret method" of which the scriptures do not tell us).
Dr. Gill says further:
"...unless the law and light of nature, by which men may have some knowledge of a divine Being, though they know not who he is, and of the difference between good and evil, and unless the motives from providential goodness to serve and glorify God can be thought to be means of grace, the heathen must be without any, who are destitute of the gospel revelation; and then to be without a gospel revelation, and without any means of grace at all, must be the same thing; seeing the gospel revelation, the word, and ordinances, are the common and ordinary means of grace. It will not be denied, that God may make use of extraordinary means; send an angel from heaven to acquaint men with the way of salvation by Jesus Christ, or by some other secret method, unknown to us; yet from the possibility of things to the certainty of them, we cannot argue: and though we would be far from judging of and determining the final state of such who are destitute of revelation; yet, according to the Scripture account of them, we cannot but conclude, that as such, and while such, they are without the means of grace, being without Christ, aliens from the commonwealth of Israel, and strangers from the covenants of promise, having no hope, and without God in the world."
Again, Hardshellism is denied! I will address some of Gill's comments, in the above words, in my ending observations.
Dr. Gill continues:
"It is strange that this passage of Scripture should be a proof of heathens having the means of grace, or of their being capable of seeking and serving God acceptably, and of their having faith in God, even that faith which in verse 1 is said to be the substance of things hoped for, the evidence oaf things not seen; when the apostle is only speaking of such a faith, as is; founded upon the word of God, and of such persons only who were favored with a divine revelation; of the patriarchs before and after the flood, the forefathers of the Jews; various instances of whose faith he produces, partly to prove the above definition of faith, and partly for the imitation, example, and encouragement of the Hebrews, to whom he writes; men who also enjoyed the oracles of God, had plenty of the means of grace, and were blessed with a gospel revelation. Besides, let it be observed, that since to come to God, as this author explains it from the context, is to do that which is pleasing to him; and since it appears from the former part of this text, that without faith it is impossible, eujaresth~sai, to do that which is well-pleasing to God; and from the words themselves, that believing is absolutely requisite to coming to him; not only that he exists, but that he is, in Christ, a God gracious and merciful, and a rewarder, in a way of grace, of all them that diligently seek him in his Son, in whom only he is to be so found. And since heathens are without any knowledge of him or faith in him, as such; for, how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? And how shall they hear without a preacher? (Rom. 10:14). It follows, that this passage of Scripture proves the reverse of what it is brought for; namely, that it is impossible for heathens to come to God aright, to serve him acceptably; or to do what is well-pleasing to him, because they are destitute of faith; and whatsoever, is not of faith, is sin (Rom. 14:23). Moreover, there is no such thing as coming to God through Christ, he is the only way of access to God, for Jews and Gentiles; for through him we both (Eph. 2:18), Jew and Gentile, have an access by one Spirit unto the Father. But since the heathens, destitute of divine revelation are without Christ, and the knowledge of him, as the way to the Father, they must be without hope, and without God in the world (Eph. 2:12), and know not how to come to him, nor can they come to him aright; nor indeed, are they capable of seeking and finding him as the God of grace, or as a God gracious and merciful: since he is only to be sought and found as such in Christ Jesus our Lord. It is true, indeed, that they may and should, by the light of nature, seek after God; and they may find him, as the God of nature, and should glorify him as such, yea, they may do many things materially good, which, though they may not be thoroughly well-pleasing to God; the circumstances of a good work being wanting in them, and also being without a Mediator to render them acceptable to God; yet may be so far approved of by him, as to avert temporal judgments from them, and to lessen their future punishment; so that the heathen world, according to our sentiments of them, is not, as is suggested, exempted from all obligations to seek God, or deprived of any motive to do what appears, by the light of nature, to be the will of God. From the whole, it follows not that heathens may have that faith in God which is the substance of things hoped for, and the evidence of things not seen; for how should they who are strangers from the covenant of promise hope, look for, and expect those things of which they have no revelation, no promise, on which to ground their faith, hope, and expectations?"
Dr. Gill denies the Hardshell view of "faith." The "faith" that is connected with "regeneration," say the Hardshells, is a "germ" or "seed" that lies "dormant" in a person and does not become visible till "exercised" in a belief of the gospel revelation and a conscious embracing of Christ. But, according to Dr. Gill, the faith of Hebrews chapter eleven, the "faith of God's elect," is absolutely connected with a mental and conscious faith in the "record that God gave of his Son." He also says that "believing is absolutely requisite to coming to him." This absolutely refutes everything that Hardshells say about the so-called faith that heathens possess.
He also repeats the statement of Paul that says all heathen, who are without divine revelation of the gospel, are "without God" and "without hope." That is the Bible teaching on the state of the heathen, the teaching of Dr. Gill, and the teaching of the Baptist Church.
Dr. Gill continues:
"We also say, that those actions of the heathens which are materially good, are yet formally evil, because they are not done out of love to God as the principle, and to God’s glory as the end; and indeed how should they do any thing out of love to God, and with a view to his glory, when they know him not? For though they have means of knowing the being and perfections of God, yet they know not who the true God is; but being left to the mere light of nature, fix upon that which is not God, to be so; and consequently can have no true love to the only true God, nor true faith in him, nor a true regard to his glory. And we say the same of the works and actions of all men in a state of nature, before conversion, who are destitute of love to God, and faith in Christ..."
He states that the heathen do not "know God," and a man cannot be thought to be "regenerated" if he does not "know God."
Dr. Gill continues:
"It is urged, that "it cannot be consistent with divine equity and goodness, to make that a condition of any man’s happiness, which he cannot know to be his duty, or knowing, cannot do. Hence it is evident, that the knowledge of any revelation made to Jew or Christian, cannot be necessary to the happiness of heathens in general, much less the practice of any purely Christian duty; and therefore faith in Jesus Christ cannot be necessary to the salvation of as many of them as have never heard of him."
Well, well! What a proposition! - "the knowledge of any revelation cannot be necessary to the (eternal) happiness of heathens"! Who believed and advocated it? Was it Dr. Gill? No! He rebuts it, as we will see.
But, one must ask himself - "Is this not the proposition of the Hardshells?" And - "Is this not the argumentation of the leading Hardshell debaters and apologists?"
Listen to Dr. Gill's powerful rebuttal and denial of the proposition and argumentation.
"I answer; that the heathens will not be condemned and punished for their ignorance of that revelation which was never vouchsafed to them, (I disagree with this to some extant - SMG) nor for the non-performance of and purely Christian duty, such as baptism and the Lord’s supper; nor for not believing in Christ (I disagree with this too, for the reason I showed in a previous chapter, i.e., because even the heathen are obligated to seek out the gospel, all obligation not being on the gospel evangelist or missionary), of whom they have never heard, only for those sins which they have committed against the law and light of nature; but inasmuch as they are without any true knowledge of the way of atonement for sin, and without any revelation from God of the method of salvation from it, they must be considered as destitute of the means of grace, and as far from true happiness and felicity."
"When this author says, "This I think certain, that God will only judge men at the last for sinning against the means he hath vouchsafed them to know, and to perform their duty, and only by that law which he hath given them. Hence it must follow, that those heathens to whom the law of nature only hath been given, can be judged only for the violations of that law." This will be readily allowed as agreeable to what the apostle says, As many as have sinned without law, shall also perish without law (Rom. 2:12). But then, this observation is no proof of their having any means of grace; this leaves them without any, and discovers the equity and justice of God in their condemnation."
"What secret methods (of which the Hardshells have created many!) God may make use of to impart his grace to heathens, to afford them the aid that is requisite to perform their duty acceptably; to communicate his mercy to them, and apply the meritorious performances of Christ; are, indeed, secrets to us; and secret things belong to the Lord our God, but those things which are revealed, belong, to us and to our children (Deut. 29:29). It is only according to the revelation God has made we are able to judge of things, and beyond that we cannot go (which is what John Spilsbury, if you recall from a previous chapter, said to Blakewell, in his argumentation on the regeneration of infants - "we can only go by the Bible and cannot address hypotheticals or secret methods not revealed" - paraphrase); and according to that revelation, it appears that Christ is the way, the truth, and the life (John 14:6); the true way to eternal life; that no man can come to the Father but by him; that there is salvation is no other; that there is none other name under heaven given among men, Jews or Gentiles, whereby we must be saved (Acts 4:12); that the heathens, destitute of revelation, know not God (1 Thess. 4:5); are without Christ, strangers to the covenants of promise, without hope and God in the world (Eph. 2:12); and consequently, according to all the views of things we are capable of taking from hence, must be without any means of grace and salvation."
"It cannot well be thought that the actions of heathens, which want the circumstances of a good work, such as love to God, faith in him, a view to his glory, and which have only the appearance of goodness in them, should, upon any consideration whatever, be more acceptable to God, than the actions of Christians done by the assistance of grace, in faith, from pure love to God, and with a single eye to his glory, and which are attended with, and are presented before God, through the sweet incense of Christ’s mediation. There must be as much difference between these actions, in point of acceptance, as between the most fragrant flower in the garden, and the most stinking herb of the field. The words of our Lord (John 20:29), do not compare Christians and heathens together, but Christians and Christians, and commend such who believe on Christ, without the sight of his person and miracles, before such who believed on him upon the sight of them...but the heathens are strangers to the covenants, of promise (Eph. 2:12); they have no such promise, and are incapable of having any, without a revelation..." (Part 3 - Section 8)
So, here is more conclusive evidence that John Gill did not "change his mind," but remained steadfast in his views that faith was necessary to salvation and that faith comes by hearing the word of God.
"Elder John R. Daily in a debate with W. P. Throgmorton in 1912 said: Men in heathendom are regenerated by the Spirit of God without the Gospel (Daily-Throgmorton Debate, p. 273).
Elder S. T. Tolly, editor of the Christian Baptist in Atwood, Tenn., wrote in the June 1971 issue of his paper: "We believe that there will be millions of the elect saved in heaven who have never, nor will they ever, hear the gospel of the Son of God."
The Hardshells are at odds with both Scripture and with Dr. Gill and the real Old Baptists.
Well did Elder Milburn Cockrell say:
"The Hardshell Baptists teach that God gives faith without the preaching of the gospel. They have an elect people with a faith not begotten and grounded upon the words of the apostles of Jesus Christ. They repudiate the words of Christ in John 17:20: "Them also which shall believe on me through their word." They have God with some people for which Christ did not pray. "Their word," meaning the words of the apostles (oral or written) and do not allow for a lot of fancy twisting and turning by which some try to make the Word the living Word, Christ."
(http://www.bereabaptistchurch.org/banner/PDFs/June2007.pdf)
Elder Lee Hanks wrote:
"The Lord has never deputized Mr. Rice or any other man to save the heathen." ("The Church of God," page 118, Christian Baptist Publishing Co. Atwood, Tenn. 1982)
But, Hanks won't find that sentiment in either the scriptures, nor in the Old Baptist Confessions of faith, nor in the writings of the leading apologists of the Baptists, till the "rise of the Hardshells." He certainly is in oppostion to the words of Christ to Paul (and which I have already dealt with extensively):
"But rise, and stand upon thy feet: for I have appeared unto thee for this purpose, to make thee a minister (a tool or instrument) and a witness both of these things which thou hast seen, and of those things in the which I will appear unto thee; Delivering thee from the people, and from the Gentiles (heathen), unto whom now I send thee, To open their eyes, and to turn them from darkness to light, and to from the power of Satan unto God, that they may receive forgiveness of sins, and (may receive) inheritance among them which are sanctified by faith that is in me. " (Acts 26: 16-18)
In his "Debate on Foreign Missions (Chapter 2), with Elder Yates (Presbyterian), Elder Potter said:
"My opponent says in this question is involved the temporal and eternal destiny of millions of the human race now living, and no doubt, countless numbers of unborn generations. Now, that is one objection I have always had to this plea for Foreign Missions, that its advocates preach the universal damnation of all the people where there is no Bible. I object to that doctrine. It is contrary to God’s word. It is the plea that gets your half-dollar from your pocket in mission work, that the heathen are going to hell unless they get the Bible."
How strange that this highly esteemed "apologist" of Hardshellism would teach the salvation of the heathen and then claim, in his debate with Elder Throgmorton, at the close of his last speech, that Dr. Gill "was our man"!
Elder Potter continues in his debate with Elder Yates (Presbyterian):
"There are three classes called by the Spirit of God, and regenerated and saved by Christ—idiots, infants, and those who cannot be called by the ministry of the word.
If the Spirit of God reaches down and saves an infant without preaching to him, or his having knowledge of the Bible or gospel, it can reach to the idiot and save him in the same way; and I believe it will. If it does that, it reaches to the heathen in the same way; and I say it will..."
Again, as at other times, Elder Potter did not bring any scripture to prove any of his propositions, but only used his perverted use of human logic, arguing that if infants are regenerated without the truth being applied to their minds (a premise that itself was never proven), then so can and must many heathen. When will the Hardshells realize that they are against scripture, the Old Confessions, and Dr. Gill, and the Baptists almost universally prior to the 1800's and the "rise of the Hardshells"?
Potter's 4th Speech
"Let us hear what another missionary has to say. I now refer you to the circular letter of the Philadelphia Baptist Association, of 1806, page 426. They say:
“The following principles have given rise to Christian missions, and swayed the conduct of faithful missionaries. First, a deep conviction of the fallen state of the human race. Once, indeed, man was made in honor, but now he is in disgrace. Woe unto us that we have sinned. In our common father we have all sunk in the abyss of original defection, and are all actual offenders against the righteous God. Many have endeavored to extenuate the offenses of the heathen world. Idolaters have been represented as the untaught children of nature, whom the Supreme Being would rather pity than punish. But such are not the representations of the Holy Scriptures, the oracles of divine truth. That they who have sinned without the law will be judged without the law is admitted; but it is expressly declared that The wrath of God is revealed from heaven against all ungodliness and unrighteousness of men; that such as change the glory of the incorruptible God into an image are without excuse, and that the judgment of God is that they who commit such things are worthy of death. Who will dare to oppose his judgment to the judgment of infinite wisdom and righteousness? or who can be negative when he hears the Bible proclaim indignation and wrath, tribulation and anguish, upon every soul of man that doeth evil, to the Jew first, and also to the Gentile.”
"That is missionary doctrine. Now, notice these texts of Scripture are used to prove the damnation of the heathen. They would not accept the idea that God would rather pity the poor heathen than punish them. They say that is wrong, and quote these texts to prove it. I say that is the missionary doctrine. I want to say that it limits the salvation of God; it binds him up; it shuts him out from that portion of his elect that he said should bless all nations of the earth where the Bible is not. If none are to be saved in heathen lands only on the condition that they hear, believe, and obey the gospel, then about three-fourths of the sons and daughters of Adam are sent to hell, to suffer eternal vengeance for what they are no more to be blamed for than I am because I was not born in England two hundred years ago. It shuts salvation out from a large majority of this world."
It is interesting that Elder Potter is willing to admit that the Philadelphia Association, in 1806, was a missionary body! They believed what Dr. Gill wrote on the heathen question. How can Elder Potter claim to be "primitive" when the oldest association in America, by his own admission, is against him and Hardshellism?
Elder Potter affirms that a belief (proposition) that says the heathen are lost without the revelation of God goes contrary to what Hardshells believe and yet he boastfully says "Dr. Gill was our man"! Sadly, others have repeated Elder Potter's and Elder Daily's falsehoods and distortions and have been too lazy to discover otherwise or else have been too dishonest to acknowledge their errors.
Elder Potter says that Dr. Gill's position, and the position of the Old Baptists of the Philadelphia Association, by their belief that the Lord used human means in saving sinners, "limits the salvation of God." But, he did not prove that was so! The scriptures too are against his reasoning, as I have already shown in earlier chapters on "Hardshell Logic." But, I will deal with it again in the next two concluding chapters on Dr. Gill and wherein I bring up some other Hardshell writers on the point that is now being heavily debated once again among the Hardshells, "will all the elect hear the gospel?"
Elder Potter's 5th Speech
"I have no fear that the Lord will not carry out his purpose in the salvation of his people without my assistance. I am not afraid of that. I am not uneasy about that. God is going to do that. He calls upon me to do my duty, and tells me what it is. He never called upon me to carry salvation or eternal life to anybody, that I know of. If he said so in the commission, I do not remember it."
Again, I suppose that Elder Potter, like Elder Hanks, should have been honest with what is taught in Acts 26: 16-18!
He said further on this point:
"Did he say, Go ye into all the world, and carry eternal life? Did he say, Go ye into all the world, and carry the Saviour? Did he say, Go ye into all the world, and carry the Spirit? Did he say, Go ye into all the world, and carry the God of heaven?"
Well, I guess again our great "apologist" forgot some of his scriptures!
"This only would I learn of you, Received ye the Spirit by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith? Are ye so foolish? having begun in the Spirit, are ye now made perfect by the flesh? Have ye suffered so many things in vain? if it be yet in vain. He therefore that ministereth to you the Spirit, and worketh miracles among you, doeth he it by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith?" (Galatians 3: 2-5)
That answers his question about "carrying (or "bringing") the Spirit"! The gospel minister brings "glad tidings" of the way of salvation through Christ, the "means of grace," as Dr. Gill and our Baptist forefathers called the gospel, and therefore, to those who receive the gospel minister and the glad tidings he brings, they receive Christ and his Spirit. Did not Jesus say - "whoever receives you receives me" and "whoever rejects you and the gospel you preach, rejects me"? Jesus repeated this message often.
"And whosoever shall not receive you, nor hear your words, when ye depart out of that house or city, shake off the dust of your feet. Verily I say unto you, It shall be more tolerable for the land of Sodom and Gomorrha in the day of judgment, than for that city...He that receiveth you receiveth me, and he that receiveth me receiveth him that sent me." (Matthew 10: 14, 15, 40)
I think these scriptures, along with a host of others that could be offered (and have to some degree in previous chapters), show that Elder Potter was opposing Christ and his way of salvation, preaching a message that does harm to sinners, putting stumblingblocks in the way of their coming to Christ.
Elder Potter stated further:
"And by his Spirit he can, and I will say he will, and does, quicken the benighted soul of the heathen and prepare him for heaven and glory. If that is not true, what mean all the Scriptures I have quoted here to you?"
Yes, he may say it! Modern Hardshells may also say it. But, the Bible does not say it! Dr. Gill does not say it! The Old Baptists of the 17th and 18th century also did not say it! The Old Confessions do not say it (again, as I have shown in previous chapters, citing the London Confession that says the heathen are lost without the gospel), nor do most of the leading founders (1st generation) of Hardshells say it. But, what scripture did the great "apologist" bring forth to prove the Bible taught that many heathen are "regenerated" and "know God," and "know Christ," and have had the "laws of the new covenant written upon their hearts"?
Elder Potter says:
"Now, I want to make an argument upon the sheep. John x. 14—16 is the language of Jesus: “I am the good shepherd, and know my sheep, and am known of mine. As the Father knoweth me, even so know I the Father: and I lay down my life for the sheep. And other sheep I have, which are not of this fold: them also I must bring, and they shall hear my voice; and there shall be one fold, and one shepherd.” Now notice, he says “other sheep I have.” Hence when he speaks of the sheep, he does not mean his people among the Jews exclusively, but he speaks of those among the Gentiles—among the heathen. He says, I have them, they are mine, I must bring them—that is what I am here for, that is my mission in the world, and I must bring them. According to the covenant, I am under obligation to bring them; they shall hear my voice, and there shall be one fold. Isaiah lvi. 8: “The Lord God which gathereth the outcasts of Israel saith, Yet will I gather others to him, besides those that are gathered unto him.” It is evident from these passages that the Lord has sheep among the heathen."
“My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me: and I give unto them eternal life; and they shall never perish, neither shall any man pluck them out of my hand. My Father, which gave them me, is greater than all; and no man is able to pluck them out of my Father’s hand.” That is what Jesus said concerning his sheep, at the same time claiming that he had sheep among the heathen.”
Elder Potter shows himself to not be worthy of being noted among the great Bible commentators with such argumentation and analysis of the sheep passage in John 10! I dealt with the passage at length in at least two earlier chapters and it completely overthrows Hardshellism.
First, Dr. Gill believed that the "voice" of Christ was heard in the gospel! He taught this in both his Commentary and in his "Body of Divinity." Yet, according to Elder Potter, "Dr. Gill is our man"!
The very idea that heathen, who worship idols, and are ignorant of the one true God, and ignorant of the Lord Jesus Christ, should be thought to have "heard" and "known" and "followed" this "voice"! I tell you friends, it is a form of blindness to believe things that are so blatantly against plain scripture!
It contradicts Romans 10! "How shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? how shall they hear without a preacher?"
Besides, why does he deviate from Elder Watson (who preceded him in time) on this matter of "bringing" in those "other sheep" that are scattered among the heathen?
All throughout Elder Watson's book, "The Old Baptist Test," published in 1866, Dr. Watson kept harping on how many of the Hardshells, especially those of the "ultraist" and "Antinomian" faction, failed to see that the gospel was the Lord's ordained means for "bringing in" these "unbrought sheep" into the fold of salvation! He spoke too of how these "ultraist" brethren "showed very little concern about the unbrought sheep"!
As a former Hardshell, I can certainly appreciate the very "difficult spot" that Elder Potter found himself, when in debate on this point (and others too since his day), in finding scripture that clearly asserts their many unbiblical man-made propositions.
He must have been "hard pressed" to try to prove his Hardshell views from John 10 and from the words that Jesus said, about having "sheep" among the heathen, even when as yet the gospel had not been preached to them. This argument, I am sure, most Hardshells today will not accept. In fact, I have not heard it used since in debate. Apparently the Hardshells since Potter's day rejected his argumentation or else it would have been repeated often.
I intend to write a series of chapters on "Hardshell Proof Texts" wherein I will deal more fully with this type of argumentation and another text that Elder Potter used in his debate with Elder Yates. But, the argument made by Elder Potter is wrong because he equates the term "sheep" with "regenerated soul." But, this it absolutely cannot mean, and most Hardshells will acknowledge this is so. Rather, the term "sheep" is equated with the term "elect." People are elect before they are regenerated, and Hardshells admit this.
Besides, by the reasoning of Potter, the "bringing" of the sheep is not their regeneration! They were sheep before they were brought! So, if "sheep" is equated with being "regenerated," then one is "regenerated" even before he is brought!
Also, if this "bringing" of the "sheep" is not "regeneration," then what is the "bringing"? Is it conversion, that which, by Hardshell "logic," follows "regeneration"? Then how do they deal with the fact that Jesus said that he "must bring" all the sheep? Is Potter saying that all the sheep will be converted then?
"Then spake the Lord to Paul in the night by a vision, Be not afraid, but speak, and hold not thy peace: For I am with thee, and no man shall set on thee to hurt thee: for I have much people in this city. And he continued there a year and six months, teaching the word of God among them." (Acts 18: 9-11)
This verse is sometimes used by Hardshell apologists to show that the Corinthians were regenerated before the Lord sent Paul to preach the gospel unto them, for Jesus says he already has his people in the city, people who need to hear the gospel, however.
Does this mean that they were "his people" by regeneration or by election? Obviously, by election, so the argument from John 10 and from the above passage turns out to be no argument at all. Certainly God has elect among the untaught heathen. What Hardshells need to show, from the scriptures, is where one person was born again or regenerated who did not have faith in the true God, and trusted not in his Messiah, and who were ignorant of his word. This they cannot do, however.
Potter's argumentation not only forces him to make the "bringing" of the sheep something other than regeneration, but also to say that the "hearing" of the voice of Christ is also not regeneration! Are they not "sheep" even before he calls them by name? Potter has sinners regenerated even before they hear the voice of the Shepherd and before they follow him! Unbelievable! And this is one of the "great" apologists of the Primitive Baptist denomination?
Elder Potter's 7th Speech
"Here is question two: “If the heathen are in an unfortunate condition, as you claim in your speech, how can this be consistent with that part of them who are God’s elect from eternity?” Now, as far as my speech yesterday was concerned, I quoted from missionary authors to show their plea for missions. I quoted from the Minutes of the Philadelphia Association and Circular Letter, in which they tell us the very grounds for the Christian Missions. In that letter they go on tell us of the deplorable condition of the heathen, and preach their universal damnation.
"I did not say, every thing that was necessary so far as the eternal salvation of God’s people is concerned. I believe that depends upon the work of Jesus Christ, and not upon the work of any human being in the world, that is now, or ever was, or ever will be."
I dealt with this absurd notion in earlier chapters on Hardshell logic. I completely overthrew this unscriptural man-made propostion, one that is anti-Christian and anti gospel and anti Bible. According to this "logic," the crucifiction was not necessary to eternal salvation because it was human hands, yea even "wicked hands," human means, that put the Lord to death! But, I do hope to deal with this point further in an upcoming chapter when I deal with Elder David Pyle's article, on the internet, wherein he argues similarly to Elder Potter, saying that creatures cannot be a means in anything that God has "predestined," or has "made certain," for that would make it uncertain! Glorious Hardshell logic! According to Pyle's thinking, no acts of creatures are predestined by God! He believes he has no right to pray for anything that God has predestined! Stay tuned to the next two concluding chapters on Dr. Gill and the Hardshells!
I also plan, as requested by a Hardshell, to deal with Samuel Richardson's views on justification and its relation to faith; many Hardshells erroneously thinking that Richardson was upholding Hardshellism when he wrote on justification by faith. Is that so? or, are the Hardshells misreading Richardson as they do Dr. Gill?
Also, some Hardshells will cite from Dr. Gill on "Justification by Faith" and contend that he also upheld their views about faith and its relation to salvation. Is this also so? or do they again misinterpret Gill on justification and faith?
I have already given citations from Richardson showing that he believed in gospel means. He also signed the first London Confession of Faith, a confession that clearly upholds that position. The men with whom he was in close fellowship also held this same view.
So then why do the Hardshells come forth and try to make him (like Dr. Gill) into a believer in Hardshellism? Where is that concern about speaking reverently and accurately about the dead about which Elder Crouse warned the Missionary Baptists?
When I deal with these issues, and with Elder David Pyle's article on "The Extent of the Gospel," I will also deal with what Dr. Gill called "secret methods," ones of which the scriptures give us no revelation or knowledge.
Some of these inconsistencies and contradictions, within the Hardshell paradigm of the new birth and system of salvation, I will deal with also more fully in that series of chapters (upcoming) on "Paradigm Problems" (following the series on "The Great Commission" and on "Hardshell Proof Texts").
Dec 1, 2007
Chapter Index December 07
Chapter 1 - The Primitive Baptist Church
Chapter 2 - Personal Experiences
Chapter 3 - The Hardshell Cult
Chapter 4 - Hardshell History
Chapter 5 - Hardshell Extremism
Chapter 6 - Hardshell Hypocrisy & Peculiarities
Chapter 7 - Time Salvation - A Novel Idea
Chapter 8 - The Spirit Alone Theory of Regeneration
Chapter 9 - Hardshell Logic on Regeneration
Chapter 10 - Hardshellism & The Infant & Idiot
Chapter 11 - Saved By Money?
Chapter 12 - Hardshells on Faith (A Primer)
Chapter 13 - Hardshells On Faith (Conclusion)
Chapter 14 - Hard-Shell Busters (First Cracking)
Chapter 15 - Hardshells On Repentance (Primer)
Chapter 16 - Hardshells On Repentance (Conclusion)
Chapter 17 - Hard-Shell Busters (Second Cracking)
Chapter 18 - Hardshells on Conversion
Chapter 19 - Coming To Christ
Chapter 20 - Direct Voice Speaking (Historical)
Chapter 21 - Direct Voice Speaking (Doctrinal)
Chapter 22 - More On The Voice Of Christ
Chapter 23 - I Peter 1:23
Chapter 24 - James 1:18
Chapter 25 - I Cor. 4:15
Chapter 26 - Hot Shots Returned (1st Volley)
Chapter 27 - Hot Shots Returned (2nd Volley)
Chapter 28 - Hot Shots Returned (3rd Volley)
Chapter 29 - Hot Shots Returned (4th Volley)
Chapter 30 - Hot Shots Returned (5th Volley)
Chapter 31 - Hot Shots Returned (6th Volley)
Chapter 32 - Hot Shots Returned (7th Volley)
Chapter 33 - Romans 10 & Gospel Means
Chapter 34 - Romans 10 (cont.)
Chapter 35 - Parable of the Sower & Seed
Chapter 36 - Pray for the Salvation of your Children?
Chapter 37 - Eternal Children Doctrine
Chapter 38 - Eternal Children Doctrine II
Chapter 39 - Hollow Log Doctrine
Chapter 40 - Biblical Regeneration
Chapter 41 - Infant Regeneration
Chapter 42 - Addresses To The Lost I
Chapter 43 - Addresses To The Lost II
Chapter 44 - Addresses To The Lost III
Chapter 45 - Addresses To The Lost IV
Chapter 46 - Addresses To The Lost V
Chapter 47 - Addresses To The Lost VI
Chapter 48 - Addresses To The Lost VII
Chapter 49 - Elder Leland's Preaching
Chapter 50 - From Law to Grace?
Chapter 51 - Regenerated AND Converted?
Chapter 52 - Beebe-Trott Model
Chapter 53 - Evidence of Regeneration?
Chapter 54 - On Conviction I
Chapter 55 - On Conviction II
Chapter 56 - On Conviction III
Chapter 57 - The Original Paradigm
Chapter 58 - Hardshells on Gill I
Chapter 59 - Hardshells on Gill II
Chapter 60 - Hardshells on Gill III
Chapter 61 - Hardshells on Gill IV
Chapter 62 - Hardshells on Gill V
Chapter 63 - Hardshells on Gill VI
Chapter 64 - Hardshells on Gill VII
Chapter 65 - Hardshells on Gill VIII
Upcoming Planned Chapters (Through January)
(Chapters 66 & 67 are Reserved for "Gill & Hyperistic Tendencies")
Chapter 68 - The Great Commission I
Chapter 69 - The Great Commission II
Chapter 70 - The Great Commission III
Chapter 71 - The Great Commission IV
Chapter 72 - The Great Commission V
Chapter 73 - The Great Commission VI
Chapter 74 - The Great Commission VII
Upcoming Planned Chapters (Through February)
Chapter 75 - Hardshell Proof Texts I
Chapter 76 - Hardshell Proof Texts II
Chapter 77 - Hardshell Proof Texts III
Chapter 78 - Hardshell Proof Texts IV
Chapter 79 - Hardshell Proof Texts V
Chapter 80 - Hardshell Proof Texts VI
Chapter 81 - Hardshell Proof Texts VII
Chapter 82 - Paradigm Problems I
Chapter 83 - Paradigm Problems II
Chapter 84 - Paradigm Problems III
Chapter 85 - Paradigm Problems IV
Chapter 86 - Paradigm Problems V
Chapter 87 - Paradigm Problems VI
Chapter 88 - Paradigm Problems VII
Planned Series for the remainder of 2008
1. Hardshell Founding Fathers
2. Hardshells & The Baptist Confessions
3. Hardshells & Predestination
4. Hardshells & Perseverence
5. Rise of the Hardshells
6. Black Rockism
7. Evolution in Doctrine
8. Hardshell Hermeneutics
9. Hardshell Methodism
10. Hardshell Landmarkism
11. Hardshell Histories
12. Summation & Appeal
Nov 29, 2007
Chapter 61 - Hardshells on Gill IV
From the "Cause of God and Truth"
Dr. Gill on "Drawing" men to Christ )
"And I, if I be lifted from the earth, will draw all men unto me"
"The sense of these words pretty much depends on the meaning of the word draw: which...designs...rather of the gathering of the people to him, through the ministry of the apostles; and so of their being enabled, through the power of divine grace, to come unto him, and believe on him for eternal life and salvation; for all those whom God has loved with an everlasting love, and Christ has died for, are, sooner or later, with loving-kindness drawn unto him; in this sense Christ uses the word in this Gospel; no man can come unto me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him (John 6:44)." (Part 1 Section 31—John 12:32)
Here clearly Dr. Gill says that men are drawn by the Father through the ministry of gospel preachers and that "drawing" is equated with believing on Christ, believing the truth respecting Christ. This "believing on him" is also, according to Gill, necessary to "eternal salvation."
Dr. Gill on Titus 2: 11,12
"For the grace of God that bringeth salvation hath appeared to all men, teaching us, that denying all ungodliness and worldly lusts we should live soberly, righteously, and godly, in this present world."
"This doctrine of the grace of God bringeth salvation: it brings the news of it to the ears of men, in the external ministration of it, and brings that itself to the hearts of men, under the powerful influences and application of the Spirit of God; and so may be rightly called saving grace, as being the power of God unto salvation to all them that believe; though it is not, nor was it designed to be so, to all to whom it is externally preached..." (Part 1 Section 47—Titus 2:11, 12)
Again, this is a flat denial of Hardshellism. It is the "doctrine of the gospel," says Dr. Gill, that "brings salvation into the hearts under the powerful influences of the Spirit of God." This "doctrine of the gospel" is"rightly called saving grace," says the Doctor. He also says that this "doctrine of the gospel" is "the power of God unto salvation." Who can then say that Dr. Gill denied gospel means in his "Cause of God and Truth," and so "changing his mind"?
Dr. Gill on Ephesians 1: 19, 20 and "Efficacious Grace"
"And what is the exceeding greatness of his power to us-ward who believe, according to the working of his mighty power, which he wrought in Christ, when he raised him from the dead."
"Since the apostle, in these words, plainly intimates, that the work of grace upon the hearts of believers is to be ascribed not only to the power of God, but to the greatness, yea, the exceeding greatness of his power, and which is represented as equal to that which was put forth in raising Christ from the dead; we think we have good reason to conclude, that this work is a work of almighty, irresistible and insuperable power, and in which men, in the first production of it, are purely passive."
"It is said, that "this power is not consistent with the persuasions and exhortations used in Scripture to move men to repent, and turn themselves from their iniquity." I reply that the exhortations to repent and turn from iniquity do not regard the first work of conversion, or the inward work of grace upon the soul, which is here designed, but an outward reformation of life. Besides, supposing the exhortations referred to respect the internal work of faith and conversion, they may be attended with that power from God, who makes use of them, so as to produce such principles of life and grace, in which men are purely passive; by virtue of which they may become active, and be enabled to answer to such exhortations; even as the command of Christ to Lazarus to come forth was attended with such a divine power as produced a principle of life in him, in which he was purely passive; though by virtue of it he became active, came forth, and answered the word of command."
"It is urged that if this was the case, "it could not properly be said that they turned, but only that they were turned, to the Lord." To which may be replied, that when the Scriptures speak of the internal work of conversion upon the heart, it is expressed in passive form, they were turned, see Jeremiah 31:18, 1 Peter 2:25. And when they speak of external reformation, or of such a turning to the Lord as is the fruit of faith, then it is expressed in the active form, they turned to him, see Acts 11:21." (Part 2 - Chapter 4 - Section 1)
I will be dealing with the idea of whether regeneration or the new birth is strictly an experience where the sinner is entirely passive, or whether it includes his activity, in a separate chapter, and with its related topic, whether salvation is strictly unconditional, in an upcoming series of chapters.
The above citations are included here because they show that Dr. Gill did not disallow the Spirit's use of the word, and use of persuasive appeals, and use of exhortations to believe and repent, in the regeneration of his elect.
Dr. Gill on John 6: 44
"No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day." (John 6: 44 - Section 8)
"This passage of Scripture is no inconsiderate proof of the doctrine of the powerful and efficacious grace of God in the work of faith and conversion. To come to Christ, is to believe in him."
This is Dr. Gill's standard position in all his writings, being the same position of all Baptists in his day and since the days of the formation of the first Particular Baptist Churches in the early 17th century; to "come to Christ" is all the same as to "believe on him" through the gospel. It is the position of the Confessions and the truly Old Baptists.
Dr. Gill continues:
"The Capernaites had heard the doctrine of Christ, which was taught with authority, and had seen his miracles, which were full proofs of his being the Messiah; and yet believed not, but continued murmuring at his person and parentage. This gave occasion to Christ to observe to them, that something more than these was necessary to their coming to him, or savingly believing in him, even the powerful and efficacious grace of the Father in drawing." (Again, he repeats the equivalency of coming = believing)
"God, in drawing of unwilling, makes willing in the day of his power; he enlightens the understanding, bends the will, gives a heart of flesh, sweetly allures by the power of his grace, and engages the soul to come to Christ, and give up itself unto him; he draws with the cords of a wan, with the bands of love (Hosea 11:4)."
"...an internal influence of the grace of God upon the soul, which, though opposed, cannot be resisted so as to be overcome, and rendered in effectual, we affirm, agreeable to these word of Christ, that without this no man can come to him; yet, notwithstanding this, persons may be blame-worthy, as the Jews were, for not believing on him as the Messiah; though without this powerful attraction they could not come to him, and believe in him to the saving of their souls. Besides, though the ability of coming to Christ in a spiritual manner is owing to the powerful grace of God in drawing; yet the disability of coming to Christ does not arise from a defect, or want of that powerful attraction, but from the corruption and vitiosity of nature, which being blame-worthy, what springs from it must be so likewise. Moreover, we readily know, that it is not praise-worthy in men to come to Christ, and believe in him, but that all the praise is due to God, and to his efficacious grace, by which they are what they are in conversion; since faith is the gift of God, and of his sole operation: nor could any come to Christ, unless it were given unto him of the Father; and therefore he ought to have all the praise and glory."
"The bare external revelation of the promise, though confirmed by miracles, will not do it. Instructions by the ministry of the word are not sufficient, unless accompanied with the demonstration of the Spirit, and of power. The following words are not a proof of it, It is written in the prophets, And they shall be all taught of God; every man therefore that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father, cometh unto me (John 6:45): which do intend mere external instructions, or objective teachings, for multitudes are in that way instructed who never come to Christ; but special teachings, such as are attended with the energy of divine grace, with the laws and doctrines of Christ put into the inward part, and written on the heart. Add to all this, our Lord himself explains what he means by the Father’s drawing (v. 65), where he says, No man can come unto me, except it were given unto him of my Father; which is more than affording means and motives, it is giving faith itself."
Dr. Gill constantly contended for the general equation of Spirit + Word = New Birth. He denied the "word alone" view of those like the "Campbellites" and would deny the "Spirit alone" view of the Hardshells. He, in the above citation, clearly taught how the Spirit used means in the work of regeneration.
In some of the above citations given, though it is clear that Dr. Gill retained his belief in gospel means, yet he did show Hyper Calvinistic tendencies in his doting old age. But, more on that in upcoming chapters.
Dr. Gill on Acts 11:18 with Ephesians 2:8
"Then hath God also to the Gentiles granted repentance unto life."
"These scriptures prove that faith and repentance are the gifts of God, and owing to the powerful operation of his grace. Now
1. To confront this, it is said, "What God commands we must do; and therefore must be active in it: but God commands all men every where to repent (Acts 17:30), and to believe in the name of Christ (1 John 3:23), therefore we must be active in the works of faith and repentance." To which I reply, that though what God commands is the rule of man’s duty, yet not the measure of his strength. It is no good arguing from God’s commands, to man’s power in his present state. God requires men to keep the whole law; it does not follow from thence, that they are able to do it. So, though it is his commandment, that we should believe in his Son Jesus Christ, and repent; yet it is certain, that faith is not of ourselves, it is a gift of grace, and of the operation of God; and the same may be said of repentance."
"But though the Gentiles repented, and believed in Christ, upon Peter’s preaching peace and pardon to them through him; yet it was not through the strength of their natural faculties, or barely through means and motives, exciting their faculties to the performance of these actions, but through the power of the Holy Ghost; for while Peter yet spake these words, the Holy Ghost fell on all them that heard the word (Acts 10:44); who produced in them these graces of faith and repentance, and assisted them in the exercise of them on their proper objects." (Section 9)
Dr. Gill on Acts 16:14
"Whose heart the Lord opened, that she attended unto the things that were spoken of Paul." (Section 10)
"The heart of man is naturally shut up against God and Christ, and every thing that is spiritually good; and nothing less than divine power can open it, nor any other but he that have the key of the house of David, that openeth, and no man shutteth; and shutteth, and no man openeth (Rev. 3:7); which proves that conversion is God’s work, and wrought by the power of his grace."
"...both the opening of the ear and of the heart are God’s acts, and not man’s: and, though God sometimes does these things by afflictions, and by the preaching of the word, as moral instruments, yet neither the one nor the other will ever produce them, without the mighty power of his Spirit and grace accompanying them: and, whereas it is said, that such who have their hearts affected with the word, and inclined by it to that which is good, may be said to have their hearts opened by it. But who, or what is it that gives and produces this affection and inclination? All that hear it are not affected with it, and inclined by it: to what else can this be ascribed, but to the powerful and efficacious grace of God?"
"And, if such an act of God’s grace and power, as the opening of the heart, is necessary, to a proper, profitable, and useful attention to the word, and to a serious consideration of the blessings of it; how much more necessary must it be to the work of conversion, to true saving faith in Christ?"
I will be dealing with the case of Lydia in an upcoming chapter on "Conversions in Acts." I have already mentioned it in earlier chapters, especially on the chaper on "Bible Regeneration," wherein I cited the words of Dr. Boyce, on the case of Lydia, and promised to address it further. The citation above from Dr. Gill I am sure would not be acceptable to neo-Hardshells. He clearly affirms that the word is used in the opening of the heart.
Dr. Gill on Jeremiah 31:18 with Deuteronomy 30:6
"Turn thou me, and I shall be turned; for thou art the Lord my God."
"...we conclude, that the circumcision and conversion of the heart are the works of God in us, in which we are passive; that they are wrought by his powerful grace, without which all means are insufficient to produce them."
Dr. Gill affirms that means are sufficient when they are "wrought by powerful grace."
He continues:
"...nothing is more certain, than that God does both require of us to do, and he himself promises to do, the whole work of conversion..."
"It is observed, that "the same God, who promiseth to circumcise the hearts of his people, requires them to circumcise their own hearts (Deut. 10:16; Jer. 4:5). And it is suggested, that the promise is conditional, namely, if they would call to mind the blessings and curses he had pronounced (v. 1), and turn to the Lord (v. 2), and that it is made to all their seed, to nations, and not particular persons." I reply, that the passages referred to have been considered in the former part of this performance; and as to the conditions mentioned, if they are conditions, they are not conditions of the circumcision of the hearts of God’s people, but of turning their captivity. And though this promise is made to their seed, as well as to themselves, yet not to all their seed, much less to nations. Besides, it particularly regards the time of the Jews’ conversion, when all the elect of God among them shall be saved...Though admitting internal conversion is meant, God’s requiring it does not suppose man’s ability to perform it, but his need of it; and is done with a view to bring him to a sense of his state, and that he may apply to God for it..." (Section 11)
Again, I will be dealing with this extremely important issue of the conditionality of salvation in upcoming chapters.
"Of Efficacious grace"
"Nor is it true, that God calls all those to faith and repentance, and conversion, who have a knowledge of the divine will, a sense of sin, a dread of punishment, and some hopes of pardon: for the devils have all these but the last, whom he never calls to faith and repentance, and the latter, as well as the former, some men may have, and yet be never called by the grace of God; indeed, all those to whom God, by his Spirit and word, gives a spiritual knowledge of his will, a real thorough sense of the evil nature of sin, as well as of the punishment that comes by it, and a good hope through grace, of pardon through the blood of Christ, he not only calls seriously and in earnest to faith and repentance, but he bestows these gifts of his grace upon them. But I proceed to the consideration of the arguments which, it is said, evidently seem to confute the doctrine of irresistible and unfrustrable grace in conversion."
Again, he upholds the formula of "by his Spirit and word."
He continues:
"If such a divine unfrustrable operation is necessary to the conversion of a sinner, then the word read or preached can be no instrument of their conversion, without this divine and unfrustrable impulse, because that only acts by moral suasion." I answer: it is very true that the word read or preached is not, nor can it be an instrument of conversion, without the powerful and efficacious grace of God; and it is abundantly evident, that it is read and preached to multitudes on whom it has no effect, and to whom it is of no use and service. Some persons are, indeed, begotten with the word of truth, and through the gospel; and are born again of incorruptible seed by the word of God (Jam. 1:18; 1 Cor. 4:15; 1 Pet. 1:28); but then all this is by and through it, not as it comes in word only, or as it acts by moral suasion, or as it is a mere moral instrument, but as it comes in power and in the Holy Ghost, or with the demonstration of the Spirit and of power (1 Thess. 1:5; 1 Cor. 2:4). The Spirit of God is the efficient cause of regeneration and conversion, the word is only a means which he makes use of when he pleases; for though he, generally speaking, works upon men by and under the means, yet not always; the work of grace upon the soul is not such an effect as doth entirely depend upon these two causes, so that, without the concurrence of them both, it will not be produced..."
This is so very clear! He affirms the exact same thing here in his "Cause of God and Truth" as in his Commentaries and in his "Body of Divinity." He says men are "indeed begotten with the word of truth" and "by the gospel"!
He continues:
"For though the word, unattended with the Spirit and power of God, may be resisted, so as to I be of no effect, yet neither the operations of the Spirit, nor the word, as attended with them, can be resisted, so as either of them should be ineffectual. And though the work of grace is wrought by an irresistible and unfrustrable operation, and the word without it is insufficient to produce it, yet it is not unnecessary; for it pleases God, by the foolishness of preaching, to save them that believe (1 Cor. 1:21); whereby he confounds the wisdom of the world; and, by making use of weak means, he magnifies his own grace and power; he puts the treasure of the gospel in earthen vessels, that the excellency of the power (2 Cor. 4:7) in conversion may appear to be of God, of his operation, and not of man’s moral suasion." (Part 3 - Section 4)
Is he not again most clear here? Why then the assertion by the Hardshells that "Gill changed his mind"? Were they ignorant OR dishonest?
The Disputed Passages in the "Cause of God and Truth" Examined
"...the Scriptures, which speak of men's considering and turning from their evil ways, regard that consideration which is requisite to an outward reformation of life, the fruit of regeneration, and internal conversion, and so not preparatory to it; and, indeed, there is want of spiritual consideration and attention in every man, until God opens his heart, by his powerful grace, as he did Lydia's, to attend to the things which are spoken, or which regard his spiritual and eternal welfare. The parable of the seed sown, instanced in, shows, that the hearts of unregenerate men are unfit and unprepared to receive the word, and therefore it becomes unfruitful to them; and that it is only fruitful where it is received in an honest and good heart, made so by the Spirit and grace of God in regeneration; whence it follows, that regeneration is rather a preparation for the right hearing of the word than the hearing of the word is a preparation for regeneration."
Here again is where Elder Daily and most Hardshells abruptly end their citation. But, let us finish it and see why they perhaps cut off the citation where they did and do.
"Faith, indeed, often comes by hearing, and hearing by the word of God, when that is attended with the Spirit and power; and therefore it is no wonder, that the Devil comes and endeavours to take away the words out of men's hearts, their minds and memories, by diverting them to other objects, lest they should believe and be saved; since he knows not who will believe and be saved, nor to whom the word will be made effectual, and to whom it will not; nay, even where it is attended with an unfrustrable assistance, he will endeavour to hinder men's believing to salvation, though he knows his attempts are in vain; which at once discovers both his folly and his malice."
Also, here is a statement that immediately precedes the citation most given (but omitted) by the Hardshells.
"There are some things which sometimes precede conversion, and which the Spirit of God makes use of for that purpose, such as reading, hearing the word, etc., but then he does not always make use of these for conversion, nor does it always follow upon them." ("OF EFFICACIOUS GRACE" from Part III, Chapter IV)So, what seems on the surface as a denial of what he had taught in his earlier works, especially when the citation is not given in its completeness, is really no denial at all but an affirmation! Besides, in the remark about the sower and the seed, Dr. Gill is not saying that one can go to heaven or be born again without having seed planted in his honest and good heart, "made so by regeneration"; And here he is obviously not using the word "regeneration" in its broad scriptural signification, but in its narrow theological definitinon, as equivalent to "the first principles of grace implanted in the soul."
Let us see what else Dr. Gill said in this same lengthy section from whence the Hardshell citation is taken.
"That the wisdom of God is most glorified by that opinion which supposeth he acts with man in all his precepts, exhortations, invitations, promises and threats, suitably to those faculties he has given." I reply, according to our opinion God does not act unsuitably, to the rational powers and faculties he has given, when he clothes his word with omnipotence, makes it the power of God unto salvation, and attends it with an unfrustrable operation upon the understanding, will, and affections; since no coactive force or violence is offered to them, the understanding is wonderfully enlightened, the will is sweetly drawn, and the affections delightfully engaged and moved, without any injury, yea with an advantage, to these natural faculties; and therefore can be no imputation upon the divine wisdom; nor does our opinion suppose, that God "uses and appoints means for the recovery of mankind, which he knows cannot in the least degree be serviceable to that end;" but on the contrary, that whatever means he uses and appoints, he makes them powerful and effectual to the ends and purposes, for which he appoints and uses them, and does not leave them to the uncertain, precarious, and impotent will of man, so that our opinion is so far from impeaching and depreciating the wisdom of God that it magnifies and exalts it; nor, according to our hypothesis, as is suggested, might he as well send ministers to preach to stones, and persuade them to be converted into men, because his omnipotency can produce such a change in them. There is no doubt, but that God could convert stones into men, and make them his children; but he has no where signified that he would do this upon men’s preaching to them; whereas he has not only signified as his will, that the gospel should be preached to every creature, but that it shall be the power of God in the conversion of many souls, both among Jews and Gentiles; wherefore there is not the same reason for sending his ministers, and for their preaching to the one as to the other, though equal power is necessary for the conversion of the one as of the other. Not that unregenerate men are altogether like stocks and stones; for though they cannot contribute anything to their regeneration or new birth, yet they are capable subjects of having the grace of God implanted in them, which stocks and stones are not; but nevertheless, if God did not make bare his holy arm, and exert his mighty power in the conversion of sinners, ministers would preach with as much success to stones as to men; and consequently the wisdom of God, according to our scheme, is greatly displayed, in accompanying the word preached with a divine energy, and an unfrustrable operation; so that all his gracious designs towards his people are effectually answered, and not leaving it to the bare force of moral suasion."
"...regeneration describes the persons who have received the power to become the sons of God (John 1:12, 13), and though these are distinct things, yet they are closely connected together; where the one is, the other is also, as to enjoyment and experience; and they bear a similarity to each other. Regeneration may be considered either more largely, and then it includes with it effectual calling, conversion, and sanctification: or more strictly, and then it designs the first principle of grace infused into the soul; which makes it a fit object of the effectual calling, a proper subject of conversion, and is the source and spring of that holiness which is gradually carried on in sanctification, and perfected in heaven."
Did Daily read the rest of these writings and know that Gill did not "change his mind" as he affirmed? Was he trying to just "win an argument" against an opponent whom he knew was not as well informed as he on Dr. Gill? Was Daily not dishonest?
John Daily said - "The voice of the preacher will never he heard by the dead in sins, in a spiritual sense. The voice of Jesus by the Divine Spirit must give life before such can hear the preaching of the gospel. Even the voice of Jesus himself, in preaching his gospel, was not heard by those who were dead." (Daily-Throgmorton Debate)
John Gill said - "God the Son has also a concern in regeneration...he quickens whom he will, as the Father does; and it is through his powerful voice in the gospel, that the dead in sin hear and live..." ("Of Regeneration" - "Body of Divinity")
Nov 22, 2007
Chapter 60 - Hardshells On Gill III
In the next chapter I will address the citations from Dr. Gill's book "Cause of God and Truth" from which Hardshells also attempt to prove that Dr. Gill "changed his mind" on the "means question," and then in the concluding chapter, I will address some of the things that do seem to indicate that Dr. Gill was in fact leaning towards Hyper Calvinism (although to a far lessor degree than the Hardshells affirm), in his doting old age. I will also show how Dr. Gill's views on conviction of sin are unlike those of today's Hardshells.
The Disputed Passages in the "Body of Divinity" Examined
"Fourthly, The instrumental cause of regeneration, if it may be so called, are the word of God, and the ministers of it; hence regenerate persons are said to be "born again by the word of God, which liveth and abideth for ever" (1 Pet. 1:23), and again, "of his own will begat he us with the word of truth" (James 1:18), unless by the Word in these passages should be meant the Eternal Logos, or essential Word of God, Christ Jesus, since logoV is used in both places; though ministers of the gospel are not only represented as ministers and instruments by whom others believe, but as spiritual fathers; "though you have ten thousand instructors in Christ", says the apostle to the Corinthians (1 Cor. 4:15), "yet have ye not many fathers, for in Christ Jesus I have begotten you through the gospel"; so he speaks of his son Onesimus, whom he had "begotten in his bonds" (Philemon 1:10) yet this instrumentality of the word in regeneration seems not so agreeable to the principle of grace implanted in the soul in regeneration, and to be understood with respect to that; since that is done by immediate infusion, and is represented as a creation; and now as God made no use of any instrument in the first and old creation, so neither does it seem so agreeable that he should use any in the new creation: wherefore this is rather to be understood of the exertion of the principle of grace, and the drawing it forth into act and exercise; which is excited and encouraged by the ministry of the word, by which it appears that a man is born again; so the three thousand first converts, and the jailor, were first regenerated, or had the principle of grace wrought in their souls by the Spirit of God, and then were directed and encouraged by the ministry of the apostles to repent and believe in Christ: whereby it became manifest that they were born again..."
This is where most citations from the Hardshells end on this "infamous passage" from Dr. Gill's "Body of Divinity."
Hardshells are infamous for quoting historical written texts wherein they stop just short of citing what would destroy the "twist" they are giving to the citation. It is the proverbial "taking out of context" the words of another.
I believe that the Hardshells were so intent on "finding" something in Gill's writings that they could say proved that he had "changed his mind," that they became dishonest or at least blind to what he really said and what he actually meant. But, it is dishonest to cite men or documents in this fashion.
Now, let me cite the rest of this "infamous citation" and see if there is anything in it that would cause the Hardshells, like Daily and Crouse, to choose to stop where they traditionally do, when they cite this portion from the great Doctor.
"Though after all it seems plain, that the ministry of the word is the vehicle in which the Spirit of God conveys himself and his grace into the hearts of men; which is done when the word comes not in word only, but in power, and in the Holy Ghost; and works effectually, and is the power of God unto salvation; then faith comes by hearing, and ministers are instruments by whom, at least, men are encouraged to believe: "received ye the Spirit", says the apostle, "by the works of the law, or by the hearing of faith": (Gal. 3:2), that is, by the preaching of the law, or by the preaching of the gospel? by the latter, no doubt."
The first thing I want to say in my rebuttal to the Hardshells (before addressing the particulars of the remaining citation above), respecting their "interpretation" of this passage from Gill's "Body of Divinity," and from his section titled "Of Regeneration," is to say that the above words of Dr. Gill do not contradict what he says, IN THE SAME CHAPTER! In this same chapter, he says clearly that men are "regenerated by the gospel."
I gave, at the outset, "clear cut" statements from this very chapter that expresses it clearly, and in the same language that we find in his Commentaries! So, the Hardshells must either repent of their misinterpetation of the Gill citation above, or else say that Gill contradicted himself even in this very section of his "Body of Divinity"!
Secondly, I want to call attention to the fact that Dr. Gill was careful to speak of the "strict" or "technical" or "theological" definition of the word "regenerate," versus its "broader" and more "scriptural" definition.
In the very first paragraph of this section on "Regeneration," Dr. Gill said:
"Regeneration may be considered either more largely, and then it includes with it effectual calling, conversion, and sanctification: or more strictly, and then it designs the first principle of grace infused into the soul; which makes it a fit object of the effectual calling, a proper subject of conversion, and is the source and spring of that holiness which is gradually carried on in sanctification, and perfected in heaven."
This is similar to other statements in his various writings, wherein he said things about these various ways of defining the word "regeneration"; Dr. Gill would often
1) take either definition and reason upon it, and/or
2) end his commentary generally with the caution that these stricter definitions were not the way the New Testament writers defined the experience, acknowledging that they used it in the broader sense, and/or
3) used words like "seem" or "suppose" and speak in a manner where it was clear he was merely "speculating" or speaking hypothetically, even perhaps being guilty himself of theological "hair-splitting."
Do the Hardshells not understand what the word "though" means in the above citation from Dr. Gill? What does he mean when he says - "though after all"? This is the word that starts the infamous "omission," the remainder of the citation that few, if any, Hardshells care to cite.
"Though after all it seems plain, that the ministry of the word is the vehicle in which the Spirit of God conveys himself and his grace into the hearts of men; which is done when the word comes not in word only, but in power, and in the Holy Ghost; and works effectually, and is the power of God unto salvation..."
The word "though" means "although" or "however" or "in spite of that." John Gill speculated; he applied "human logic" (as the Hardshells) to the new birth, looking at it metaphysically, but when he was all done doing so, he would say, "though after all I have said, speculating about what seems to be the case with things through human logic, it is clear from the Scriptures that men are regenerated contrary to this logic and contrary to the way of human science, in a supernatural way, the Lord regenerating through the preaching of the gospel by human agents."
From whence did this clearness of truth come? Was it not from the Scriptures? Is it clear to human logic that the "Spirit of God is conveyed" to the heart of the sinner through the "vehicle" of the "word," as Dr. Gill affirmed, or is it clear from the Scriptures?
Any honest Hardshell can see what Dr. Gill was clearly affirming and it is dishonest to think Dr. Gill "contradicted himself" in this passage from his "Body of Divinity."
If we define the word "regeneration" as meaning all the same as the "first initial move of the Spirit of God upon the soul of a man," or as the "first principle of grace infused into the soul," then of course "regeneration" would precede faith and repentance, yea, and every other grace! But, do the Scriptures or Dr. Gill affirm it that way? No!
But, it seems, Dr. Gill did in fact follow other theologians, for argument's sake, in their meanderings, and often took their "technical" definitions and reasoned therefrom.
Dr. Gill believed that the scriptures upheld the broader definition of regeneration as including effectual calling, conversion, and initial sanctification. Dr. Gill did not believe one could go to Heaven without being effectually called and converted and sanctified! One must, according to Dr. Gill, be regenerated in the broader scriptural meaning of the term, in order to go to Heaven.
Notice the words that preceded Dr. Gill's side-tracked speculation that began with the words "seems not so agreeable"
"...hence regenerate persons are said to be "born again by the word of God, which liveth and abideth for ever" (1 Pet. 1:23), and again, "of his own will begat he us with the word of truth" (James 1:18), unless by the Word in these passages should be meant the Eternal Logos, or essential Word of God, Christ Jesus, since logoV is used in both places; though ministers of the gospel are not only represented as ministers and instruments by whom others believe, but as spiritual fathers; "though you have ten thousand instructors in Christ", says the apostle to the Corinthians (1 Cor. 4:15), "yet have ye not many fathers, for in Christ Jesus I have begotten you through the gospel"; so he speaks of his son Onesimus, whom he had "begotten in his bonds" (Philemon 1:10) yet this instrumentality of the word in regeneration seems not so agreeable..."
Notice that Dr. Gill did not say that he thought that the "logos" in those two passages referred to Christ! He possibly is reflecting the view of John Brine and some of the younger more extreme Calvinists, who were gathering around his feet, or a view that had been recently "thrown out" there for consideration, and Dr. Gill is being friendly.
It is clear however that he does not believe this view for he, in the same section, as I have already cited, refers to those two passages as proofs that men are regenerated through the gospel! It is equivalent to him saying - "UNLESS the Hardshells are correct and the logos is Jesus himself." One can say that without affirming that they are in fact correct.
Notice the second use of the word "though" in this citation from Dr. Gill. "Though (however) ministers of the gospel ARE represented (in the scriptures) as spiritual fathers..."
So, says Dr. Gill, paraphrasing - "some may think that the 'word' in I Peter 1: 23 and James 1: 18 refers to Christ, yet (though) it is clear that other passages do in fact teach the instrumentality of the word in regeneration, so nothing is really gained in such a discussion."
Now, do you see, my fellow Hardshell friend? Do you not see how Elder John R. Daily, with many others, in your denomination, have twisted and misinterpreted Dr. Gill, in this passage, in their misguided zeal to find someone, prior to the 1800's, who agreed with them?
Elder Throgmorton may not have been as well versed in his reading of Dr. Gill, especially the sections that Daily cites from his "Body of Divinity" and his "Cause of God and Truth," to have responded to Daily's faulty citation methods and his misinterpreting what the good Doctor wrote, but others are not.
Had Throgmorton sent the avalanche of citations down upon Daily, in that debate, as I gave in the preceding chapter, then it probably would not have gotten reported, as it has now for almost 100 years, that Dr. Gill had "changed his mind" in his old age, in his "Body of Divinity" and "Cause of God and Truth."
Obviously, Hardshells did not "check out" Daily on what he was saying, swallowing what he said about Dr. Gill and repeating it to others, in the same manner they have swallowed, "hook, line and sinker," what Elder Hassell and other of their "historians" have put forth.