Churches of Christ need to lead the way in calling for days of fasting and prayer for the economic crisis now facing our nation and the world. Let us drop everything we are doing and call the people of God and the nations of the world to a time of serious prayer and spiritual reflection.
"The field is wasted, the land mourneth; for the corn is wasted: the new wine is dried up, the oil languisheth. Be ye ashamed, O ye husbandmen; howl, O ye vinedressers, for the wheat and for the barley; because the harvest of the field is perished. The vine is dried up, and the fig tree languisheth; the pomegranate tree, the palm tree also, and the apple tree, even all the trees of the field, are withered: because joy is withered away from the sons of men. Gird yourselves, and lament, ye priests: howl, ye ministers of the altar: come, lie all night in sackcloth, ye ministers of my God: for the meat offering and the drink offering is withholden from the house of your God. Sanctify ye a fast, call a solemn assembly, gather the elders and all the inhabitants of the land into the house of the LORD your God, and cry unto the LORD." (Joel 1: 10-14 KJV)
"Although the fig tree shall not blossom, neither shall fruit be in the vines; the labour of the olive shall fail, and the fields shall yield no meat; the flock shall be cut off from the fold, and there shall be no herd in the stalls: Yet I will rejoice in the LORD, I will joy in the God of my salvation. The LORD God is my strength, and he will make my feet like hinds' feet, and he will make me to walk upon mine high places. To the chief singer on my stringed instruments." (Habakkuk 3: 17-19 KJV)
ACTS 17:11-"...IN THAT THEY RECEIVED THE WORD WITH ALL READINESS OF MIND, AND SEARCHED THE SCRIPTURES DAILY, WHETHER THOSE THINGS WERE SO."
Oct 8, 2008
Chpt. 83 - Hardshell Proof Texts V
"All that the Father giveth me shall come to me; and him that cometh to me I will in no wise cast out...No man can come to me, except the Father which hath sent me draw him: and I will raise him up at the last day. It is written in the prophets, And they shall be all taught of God. Every man therefore that hath heard, and hath learned of the Father, cometh unto me. Not that any man hath seen the Father, save he which is of God, he hath seen the Father. Verily, verily, I say unto you, He that believeth on me hath everlasting life...And he said, Therefore said I unto you, that no man can come unto me, except it were given unto him of my Father. " (John 6: 37, 44-47, 65 KJV)
There are really two versions of Hyperism that need to be corrected, as pertaining to the above verses, and whether or not they teach the "born again before faith" or "regenerated without faith" view.
The general Hardshell version correctly identifies the "coming to Christ" as = regeneration, salvation, or the new birth. They do not generally view the "drawing" as itself "regeneration."
It is the modern "Reformed" version that makes the "drawing" = "regeneration," thus disallowing that "coming" to Christ = regeneration.
The "Reformed" version says the "drawing" = "regeneration" or the "new birth," while the "coming" = "conversion" (and thus make it something separate and distinct from "regeneration").
The Hardshell view, though correctly making the "coming" = "regeneration," nevertheless errs in making this "coming to Christ" something apart from the gospel, and apart from cognitive faith, and apart from a conscious experience, or from conversion.
The questions to be addressed in this chapter, therefore, will be the following.
1. Is a man "regenerated" who has not "come to Christ"?
2. What does it mean to "come to Christ"?
3. Is the reception of "life" before or after the "coming"?
4. Can a man be said to have been effectually "drawn" who has not "come"?
5. How does God "draw" the sinner to Christ?
6. What is meant by "unless it be given to him of my Father" (vs. 65)?
Archibald Alexander wrote:
"Sometimes regeneration is considered distinctly from the acts and exercises of the mind which proceed from it, but in the Holy Scriptures the cause and effect are included; and we shall therefore treat the subject in this practical and popular form."
http://members.aol.com/RSICHURCH/view1.html
The "Reformed" view does not define "regeneration" as do the scriptures, if Alexander is correct, for the neo "Reformed" view says that "regeneration" is defined by cause alone; That is, "regeneration" is strictly an act of God. It is not, strictly speaking, and according to the neo "Reformed" view, defined by the effect, by what the sinner actually experiences or does as a result of the divine causation. By this definition, "regeneration" or the "new birth" is not something one experiences, but simply the cause of that experience.
The Arminian, of course, believes the "drawing" to be a pre regeneration work, and so does the Hardshell, the difference being that the Arminian does not believe the "drawing" is, in any sense, irresistable, nor what occurs apart from gospel means, whereas the Hardshells believe both.
The teaching of Christ in John 5 & 6 clearly shows this order: Drawing (or calling) by the Spirit and word of God, coming to Christ (or faith), reception of spiritual life.
"And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life." (John 5: 40 KJV)
It is clear. Life is the result of having come to Christ, of having "received him" and "believed on his name." (John 1: 12 KJV)
So the equation is simple - Drawing, coming, life. Or, drawing + coming = life. Cause + effect = regeneration. The Hardshell and neo Reformed "ordo salutis" both have a different equation, one that reads like this - Drawing, Life, Coming. Thus, Jesus' words should have been stated differently, as - "you will not have life that you might come unto me," rather than as it is.
Notice how the "drawing" of the Father, that which effects the sinner's coming to Christ for life and salvation, involves the Father "teaching" and the sinner "hearing" (paying attention to, or heeding) it. It also includes "learning" truth from the Father.
No man can come to Christ who has not been first taught who is Christ. This is in keeping with what Paul wrote, when he said:
"How then shall they call on him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? and how shall they hear without a preacher? So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God." (Romans 10: 14, 17 KJV)
To come to Christ, one must be "drawn" by the teaching of the Father, that teaching done through his Spirit and word.
One should not define "regeneration" or the "new birth" as being restricted to the cause alone, but should include the instantaneous effect; likewise, one should also define the experience not only in terms of "passivity," but also in terms of "activity." The dead coming to life is that which the dead does or experiences, although it be of God's causation. God does not come to life. The child being born is not inactive.
What do we mean when we affirm that the sinner is "passive" in regeneration? Likewise, what do we mean when we affirm, or deny, that the sinner is "active" in new birth?
What it means to "come to Christ" has already been dealt with in a previous separate chapter (19), wherein it was shown how "coming to Christ" meant "believing on Christ." Thus, it cannot be something done apart from knowledge or cognition, or without the means of truth knowledge.
I will discuss some of these inconsistencies in greater depth in that upcoming series titled "Paradigm Problems." I will also address the historic debate among Baptists as respects whether salvation is "unconditional" or "conditional," and what is denoted by those words.
The verse about the Father drawing is simply intended to show that this work must be initiated by God himself. God must take the proverbial first step in the matter. Jesus' intention in saying that one must be "drawn" before he can "come" is simply to connect cause with effect, as if he said - "no man can be resurrected unless the Father call him forth from death."
But, the calling forth in itself is not resurrection, for the calling is what God experiences, while the effect of the calling is what the sinner experiences. The "Reformed" view, then, that makes the "drawing" to equal "regeneration," makes "regeneration" to be what God experiences, not what the sinner experiences.
The "Reformed" view, which is probably shared by some Hardshells, which equates "drawing" with the new birth, also interprets the "giving" of verse 65 as being "regenerated." But, this is nonsense. Of course, all Calvinists agree, that no sinner can come to Christ unless the Father first draw and give power and grace. But, this act of God, which brings about the resulting experience in the sinner, is not, in itself, nor by itself alone, what is "regeneration."
The "coming" to Christ, and to "life," is what is regeneration or the new birth. The acts of the Father in drawing and giving are the causes of the experience, not the experience itself.
The "giving" of verse 65 is the giving of power to come, while the "giving" of verse 37 is of the elect themselves, in their persons. The elect are they who were "given" by the Father to Christ, and this prior to their being saved. The elect, in their being saved, begotten, or regenerated, are "given" power and grace that effects it all.
Thus, I see nothing in these verses to uphold Hardshellism, the idea that men are born again before and without believing in Christ, or coming to him in evangelic faith, nor do I see any validity to the neo "Reformed" claim that these verses teach that one must be born again before they can come to Christ. Such a view, as I have stated, errs in not making the coming itself to be the new birth. And, as I said, at least the Hardshells make the "coming," rather than the "drawing," to be "regeneration." Their error is to make the "coming to Christ" something other than what it clearly is, a conscious coming to Christ with the heart and mind, an embracing of him by faith.
There are really two versions of Hyperism that need to be corrected, as pertaining to the above verses, and whether or not they teach the "born again before faith" or "regenerated without faith" view.
The general Hardshell version correctly identifies the "coming to Christ" as = regeneration, salvation, or the new birth. They do not generally view the "drawing" as itself "regeneration."
It is the modern "Reformed" version that makes the "drawing" = "regeneration," thus disallowing that "coming" to Christ = regeneration.
The "Reformed" version says the "drawing" = "regeneration" or the "new birth," while the "coming" = "conversion" (and thus make it something separate and distinct from "regeneration").
The Hardshell view, though correctly making the "coming" = "regeneration," nevertheless errs in making this "coming to Christ" something apart from the gospel, and apart from cognitive faith, and apart from a conscious experience, or from conversion.
The questions to be addressed in this chapter, therefore, will be the following.
1. Is a man "regenerated" who has not "come to Christ"?
2. What does it mean to "come to Christ"?
3. Is the reception of "life" before or after the "coming"?
4. Can a man be said to have been effectually "drawn" who has not "come"?
5. How does God "draw" the sinner to Christ?
6. What is meant by "unless it be given to him of my Father" (vs. 65)?
Archibald Alexander wrote:
"Sometimes regeneration is considered distinctly from the acts and exercises of the mind which proceed from it, but in the Holy Scriptures the cause and effect are included; and we shall therefore treat the subject in this practical and popular form."
http://members.aol.com/RSICHURCH/view1.html
The "Reformed" view does not define "regeneration" as do the scriptures, if Alexander is correct, for the neo "Reformed" view says that "regeneration" is defined by cause alone; That is, "regeneration" is strictly an act of God. It is not, strictly speaking, and according to the neo "Reformed" view, defined by the effect, by what the sinner actually experiences or does as a result of the divine causation. By this definition, "regeneration" or the "new birth" is not something one experiences, but simply the cause of that experience.
The Arminian, of course, believes the "drawing" to be a pre regeneration work, and so does the Hardshell, the difference being that the Arminian does not believe the "drawing" is, in any sense, irresistable, nor what occurs apart from gospel means, whereas the Hardshells believe both.
The teaching of Christ in John 5 & 6 clearly shows this order: Drawing (or calling) by the Spirit and word of God, coming to Christ (or faith), reception of spiritual life.
"And ye will not come to me, that ye might have life." (John 5: 40 KJV)
It is clear. Life is the result of having come to Christ, of having "received him" and "believed on his name." (John 1: 12 KJV)
So the equation is simple - Drawing, coming, life. Or, drawing + coming = life. Cause + effect = regeneration. The Hardshell and neo Reformed "ordo salutis" both have a different equation, one that reads like this - Drawing, Life, Coming. Thus, Jesus' words should have been stated differently, as - "you will not have life that you might come unto me," rather than as it is.
Notice how the "drawing" of the Father, that which effects the sinner's coming to Christ for life and salvation, involves the Father "teaching" and the sinner "hearing" (paying attention to, or heeding) it. It also includes "learning" truth from the Father.
No man can come to Christ who has not been first taught who is Christ. This is in keeping with what Paul wrote, when he said:
"How then shall they call on him in whom they have not believed? and how shall they believe in him of whom they have not heard? and how shall they hear without a preacher? So then faith cometh by hearing, and hearing by the word of God." (Romans 10: 14, 17 KJV)
To come to Christ, one must be "drawn" by the teaching of the Father, that teaching done through his Spirit and word.
One should not define "regeneration" or the "new birth" as being restricted to the cause alone, but should include the instantaneous effect; likewise, one should also define the experience not only in terms of "passivity," but also in terms of "activity." The dead coming to life is that which the dead does or experiences, although it be of God's causation. God does not come to life. The child being born is not inactive.
What do we mean when we affirm that the sinner is "passive" in regeneration? Likewise, what do we mean when we affirm, or deny, that the sinner is "active" in new birth?
What it means to "come to Christ" has already been dealt with in a previous separate chapter (19), wherein it was shown how "coming to Christ" meant "believing on Christ." Thus, it cannot be something done apart from knowledge or cognition, or without the means of truth knowledge.
I will discuss some of these inconsistencies in greater depth in that upcoming series titled "Paradigm Problems." I will also address the historic debate among Baptists as respects whether salvation is "unconditional" or "conditional," and what is denoted by those words.
The verse about the Father drawing is simply intended to show that this work must be initiated by God himself. God must take the proverbial first step in the matter. Jesus' intention in saying that one must be "drawn" before he can "come" is simply to connect cause with effect, as if he said - "no man can be resurrected unless the Father call him forth from death."
But, the calling forth in itself is not resurrection, for the calling is what God experiences, while the effect of the calling is what the sinner experiences. The "Reformed" view, then, that makes the "drawing" to equal "regeneration," makes "regeneration" to be what God experiences, not what the sinner experiences.
The "Reformed" view, which is probably shared by some Hardshells, which equates "drawing" with the new birth, also interprets the "giving" of verse 65 as being "regenerated." But, this is nonsense. Of course, all Calvinists agree, that no sinner can come to Christ unless the Father first draw and give power and grace. But, this act of God, which brings about the resulting experience in the sinner, is not, in itself, nor by itself alone, what is "regeneration."
The "coming" to Christ, and to "life," is what is regeneration or the new birth. The acts of the Father in drawing and giving are the causes of the experience, not the experience itself.
The "giving" of verse 65 is the giving of power to come, while the "giving" of verse 37 is of the elect themselves, in their persons. The elect are they who were "given" by the Father to Christ, and this prior to their being saved. The elect, in their being saved, begotten, or regenerated, are "given" power and grace that effects it all.
Thus, I see nothing in these verses to uphold Hardshellism, the idea that men are born again before and without believing in Christ, or coming to him in evangelic faith, nor do I see any validity to the neo "Reformed" claim that these verses teach that one must be born again before they can come to Christ. Such a view, as I have stated, errs in not making the coming itself to be the new birth. And, as I said, at least the Hardshells make the "coming," rather than the "drawing," to be "regeneration." Their error is to make the "coming to Christ" something other than what it clearly is, a conscious coming to Christ with the heart and mind, an embracing of him by faith.
Oct 7, 2008
Singsong Preaching?
A reader wrote me an email with the following question:
"Stephen
Are you aware of old fashion Baptist preaching that makes a sucking sound as they preach? I was raised in middle Tennessee and remember preachers on radio doing this. It is a cadence sound with their breathing as they are drawing a breath. Is this a style or what?" (emphasis mine)
Here are some tidbits of info on this style of preaching.
"He was not a "Primitive" or "Old-School" Baptist, but, like some of them, would "sing out" his sermons, I have been told, after the approved fashion and popular and effective style of preaching, in many parts of the country, at that day. Dr. Broadus used to say that the "sing-song" habit of some of the dear old men was a by-product of out-of-door speaking, and being restful to the "overstrained vocal chords," was natural."
http://www.staceyhoffmann.com/showhistory.php?docID=3
"Woodmason shared with many other persons down to the present an annoyance with the peculiar manner in which the Separate preachers delivered their extemporaneous sermons, which they believed directly inspired. When preaching, they chanted their sermons in what Woodmason described as a 'squeaking, untuneable, unintelligible Jargon; Neither Verse or Prose, Singing or Speaking. And when one of them lately was reprimanded for this, and asked --Whether he sung, or spoke, He answered in this blasphemous Strain, It is not I that speak--but the Spirit of God that dwelleth in me." Many later Primitive Baptist preachers in South Georgia and Florida preached in this manner. Although the Separate Baptists considered some divine assistance necessary to preach acceptably." ("Primitive Baptists of the Wiregrass South" By John G. Crowley)
http://books.google.com/books?id=6TTtLEXwYCUC&pg=PA9&lpg=PA9&dq=old+hardshell+baptist+preaching+annoyed&source=web&ots=HrLATLsY-b&sig=WCom567f2aRzBfS2AflbxFnjuS4&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result#PPA10,M1
"Folk preaching draws on traditional oral composition techniques. The sermon normally begins in prose and then moves into metrical verse. Rhythm and timing are among the most significant aspects of a Black folk preacher's chanted sermon. Intonational chanting is widely used by Black preachers to indicate inspirational climax in their sermons. This chanting is usually interspersed with moans, hollers, grunts, and shouts. The talent of the Black folk preacher can be evaluated according to how he renders the metrical lines while still delivering the message."
http://www.louisianafolklife.org/LT/Virtual_Books/Fla_Parishes/book_florida_gospel.html
"As a professor of communication arts, Dorgan likewise extensively studied the preaching cant most commonly used by Old Regular Baptist ministers as well as others found within the Primitive Baptists, Regular Baptists of northwestern North Carolina, the mountain Free Will Baptists, and related groups. All show similarities to one another, and we have already seen from Morgan Edward's notes on the Separate Baptists as they existed within a year of Shubal Stearn's death that they are undoubtedly variations, developed over time and distance, of Stearn's own exposition of the New England Tone. Of course we cannot know exactly what this Ur-version of Appalachian preaching sounded like, but one is tempted to speculate that the common Old Regular mode, with its heavy dependence on singsong chant interspersed with elongated shouts and wails, appearing so similar to Edward's description of the style that Philip Mulkey must have successfully parrotted from Stearns, is the closet extant approximation. It is found among the other of Stearn's descendant groups but nowhere so uniformly as is found among the Old Regulars." ("The Roots of Appalachian Christianity" By Elder John Sparks)
http://books.google.com/books?id=cPC1psCW04cC&pg=PA260&lpg=PA260&dq=preaching+chant+hardshell+baptist&source=web&ots=dl7fumvmfF&sig=MHqgjt1qhEb_fcsE0JFv8yx2e1o&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result
Some of the old "singsong" preachers were very good at it, men like Elder John R. Daily, whom Elder Throgmorton mimicked in his debate with Daily.
Others preach in less a melodic manner, but nevertheless get themselves worked up in a preaching "frenzy" where they are speaking fast and loud, and where they must stop regularly for gulps of air, and give out the infamous "uhs" and "ers" in the gaps between the gulps and the words.
"Stephen
Are you aware of old fashion Baptist preaching that makes a sucking sound as they preach? I was raised in middle Tennessee and remember preachers on radio doing this. It is a cadence sound with their breathing as they are drawing a breath. Is this a style or what?" (emphasis mine)
Here are some tidbits of info on this style of preaching.
"He was not a "Primitive" or "Old-School" Baptist, but, like some of them, would "sing out" his sermons, I have been told, after the approved fashion and popular and effective style of preaching, in many parts of the country, at that day. Dr. Broadus used to say that the "sing-song" habit of some of the dear old men was a by-product of out-of-door speaking, and being restful to the "overstrained vocal chords," was natural."
http://www.staceyhoffmann.com/showhistory.php?docID=3
"Woodmason shared with many other persons down to the present an annoyance with the peculiar manner in which the Separate preachers delivered their extemporaneous sermons, which they believed directly inspired. When preaching, they chanted their sermons in what Woodmason described as a 'squeaking, untuneable, unintelligible Jargon; Neither Verse or Prose, Singing or Speaking. And when one of them lately was reprimanded for this, and asked --Whether he sung, or spoke, He answered in this blasphemous Strain, It is not I that speak--but the Spirit of God that dwelleth in me." Many later Primitive Baptist preachers in South Georgia and Florida preached in this manner. Although the Separate Baptists considered some divine assistance necessary to preach acceptably." ("Primitive Baptists of the Wiregrass South" By John G. Crowley)
http://books.google.com/books?id=6TTtLEXwYCUC&pg=PA9&lpg=PA9&dq=old+hardshell+baptist+preaching+annoyed&source=web&ots=HrLATLsY-b&sig=WCom567f2aRzBfS2AflbxFnjuS4&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result#PPA10,M1
"Folk preaching draws on traditional oral composition techniques. The sermon normally begins in prose and then moves into metrical verse. Rhythm and timing are among the most significant aspects of a Black folk preacher's chanted sermon. Intonational chanting is widely used by Black preachers to indicate inspirational climax in their sermons. This chanting is usually interspersed with moans, hollers, grunts, and shouts. The talent of the Black folk preacher can be evaluated according to how he renders the metrical lines while still delivering the message."
http://www.louisianafolklife.org/LT/Virtual_Books/Fla_Parishes/book_florida_gospel.html
"As a professor of communication arts, Dorgan likewise extensively studied the preaching cant most commonly used by Old Regular Baptist ministers as well as others found within the Primitive Baptists, Regular Baptists of northwestern North Carolina, the mountain Free Will Baptists, and related groups. All show similarities to one another, and we have already seen from Morgan Edward's notes on the Separate Baptists as they existed within a year of Shubal Stearn's death that they are undoubtedly variations, developed over time and distance, of Stearn's own exposition of the New England Tone. Of course we cannot know exactly what this Ur-version of Appalachian preaching sounded like, but one is tempted to speculate that the common Old Regular mode, with its heavy dependence on singsong chant interspersed with elongated shouts and wails, appearing so similar to Edward's description of the style that Philip Mulkey must have successfully parrotted from Stearns, is the closet extant approximation. It is found among the other of Stearn's descendant groups but nowhere so uniformly as is found among the Old Regulars." ("The Roots of Appalachian Christianity" By Elder John Sparks)
http://books.google.com/books?id=cPC1psCW04cC&pg=PA260&lpg=PA260&dq=preaching+chant+hardshell+baptist&source=web&ots=dl7fumvmfF&sig=MHqgjt1qhEb_fcsE0JFv8yx2e1o&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=2&ct=result
Some of the old "singsong" preachers were very good at it, men like Elder John R. Daily, whom Elder Throgmorton mimicked in his debate with Daily.
Others preach in less a melodic manner, but nevertheless get themselves worked up in a preaching "frenzy" where they are speaking fast and loud, and where they must stop regularly for gulps of air, and give out the infamous "uhs" and "ers" in the gaps between the gulps and the words.
Promoting Controversies?
"These promote controversies rather than God's work—which is by faith." (I Timothy 1: 4 NIV)
We ought rather to either
1. Avoid certain controversies.
2. Settle certain controversies.
Being a "Calvinist" ought not to be equated with being a lover of controversies.
We ought rather to either
1. Avoid certain controversies.
2. Settle certain controversies.
Being a "Calvinist" ought not to be equated with being a lover of controversies.
Oct 6, 2008
The Great Inconsistency
Those who promote and stress the erroneous idea that one must be born again before faith and repentance, before conversion, such as those today who call themselves "Reformed" (they are not really "reformed," but a neo hybrid "reformed" entity), will say that the preaching of the gospel is a "means" or "instrument" in the work of regeneration. This is a great inconsistency.
Those who are most honest, will "shell down the corn" and aver that, technically, strictly, or theologically speaking, the gospel is not a means. Others, who are not so honest and consistent, will continue to say the gospel IS a means to bring about regeneration but yet affirm that one must be regenerated before the means can be effective.
The inconsistency can easily be discovered. All one has to do is to ask these folks, men like Sproul, White, Piper, Duncan, Grudem, Mohler, Ascol (Bill or Tom), etc., one simple question, one I have asked in this forum before. I even put it into the form of a challenge. I did not hear one word from those who promote the "born again before faith" error, neither Hardshell nor Reformed, who would come forward and answer the question. Why did not White attempt an answer? Is it because the question is designed to reveal this inconsistency?
Here is the question. I am still waiting for the answer. James, will you give us your answer?
When the bible says that sinners are "begotten by the gospel," does this not mean by believing it? It is a simple question, is it not?
Those who are most honest, will "shell down the corn" and aver that, technically, strictly, or theologically speaking, the gospel is not a means. Others, who are not so honest and consistent, will continue to say the gospel IS a means to bring about regeneration but yet affirm that one must be regenerated before the means can be effective.
The inconsistency can easily be discovered. All one has to do is to ask these folks, men like Sproul, White, Piper, Duncan, Grudem, Mohler, Ascol (Bill or Tom), etc., one simple question, one I have asked in this forum before. I even put it into the form of a challenge. I did not hear one word from those who promote the "born again before faith" error, neither Hardshell nor Reformed, who would come forward and answer the question. Why did not White attempt an answer? Is it because the question is designed to reveal this inconsistency?
Here is the question. I am still waiting for the answer. James, will you give us your answer?
When the bible says that sinners are "begotten by the gospel," does this not mean by believing it? It is a simple question, is it not?
Jesse Mercer
"Jesse Mercer (1769-1841) was one of the most important Baptists in the American south in the years before the Southern Baptist Convention was formed in 1845. He was the son of Silas Mercer, a leading Baptist pastor in his own right. Mercer, along with Richard Furman of South Carolina, was a leading advocate for Christian higher education. He was also a tireless promoter of missions, a prolific hymn writer and compiler, a pioneer in religious journalism, and a denomination’s statesman. He was also recognized as a leader in secular circles: In 1798, though still a young minister, Mercer was named a delegate to Georgia’s Constitutional Convention, where he was asked to write the section in the state’s constitution guaranteeing religious liberty to all citizens of the state.
Throughout his career, Mercer was a avid proponent of missions. His missions advocacy took on two forms. First, Mercer argued for the legitimacy for missions over against the hyper-Calvinists of his day. During Mercer’s lifetime, many Baptists in the south were embracing such doctrines as eternal justification and refusing to preach the gospel “promiscuously” to all people, regardless of the presumed status of someone’s election. Most of the hyper-Calvinists, convinced they represented the apostolic faith, called themselves primitive Baptists. Mercer, though himself a strict Calvinist, argued against the extremes of hyper-Calvinism and argued for personal evangelism, church planting, and foreign missions. He was also a proponent of revival, having witnessed first-hand the Georgia manifestation of the Second Great Awakening in the 1820’s. He read widely the revival works of both Jonathan Edwards and Charles Finney, though he accepted the claims of neither without some criticism, particularly in the case of Finney. In a very real sense Mercer represented a healthy combination of the so-called “Charleston” and “Sandy Creek” traditions in pre-1845 southern Baptist history.
Mercer not only argued for the legitimacy of missions, but also for cooperation in missions. Primitives and other “anti-mission” Baptists argued against the legitimacy of mission boards, Sunday Schools, colleges, and other “innovations” they believed deviated from the New Testament pattern. The anti-mission Baptists were especially opposed to Luther Rice’s fundraising on behalf of the Triennial Convention. Mercer, like most other Baptists, argued for cooperation in missionary (and educational) endeavors. In fact, Mercer served four terms as a delegate to the Triennial Convention from 1817-1835. But besides his involvement in the Trienniel Convention, Mercer took the lead in establishing a means for Georgia Baptists to cooperate in missionary and educational enterprises. To that end, in 1822 Mercer helped found the Georgia Baptist Convention, which was the second Baptist state convention started in the south. Mercer served as the first president of the GBC, an office he held from 1822 until his death in 1841.
In 1833, Mercer became the editor of The Christian Index, now the official state paper of the Georgia Baptist Convention. The Index was first published in Washington, having been established there by Luther Rice in 1818 under than name The Latter-Day Luminary. Following several relocations and name changes, Mercer acquired the periodical and relocated it to Georgia, where it has remained ever since. The Christian Index, under its various names, is the oldest continuously-published religious periodical in America. Mercer used the pages of his paper to promote ministerial education and to contend for missions against the Primitive Baptists and other detractors.
http://nathanafinn.wordpress.com/2006/06/07/jesse-mercer-georgia-baptist-pioneer-in-missions-and-education/
"One of the most helpful features of Chute’s account is the way that he adeptly summarizes the dispute between Primitive Baptists and the Missionary Baptist party led by Jesse Mercer. Both Primitive and Missionary Baptists were Calvinists. Primitive Baptists opposed missionary efforts on the basis of their ecclesiology, arguing that cooperation between churches was unbiblical. Only individual churches should send out missionaries. So, for instance, John Leland, who is well known for his labors for religious liberty (see the recent volume edited by Thomas White, Jason G. Duesing, and Malcolm Yarnell, First Freedom) was “opposed to missions not because of a concern for Calvinistic theology being disregarded but out of [a] desire for simplicity and freedom in both government and religion” (134, Chute cites Tom Nettles, By His Grace and For His Glory, who has shown that Leland did not oppose missions because of his Calvinism). What’s more, Primitive Baptists thought that men such as Luther Rice, who handled the large sums of money gathered from cooperating churches, were corrupt and untrustworthy. Rice, who was friends with Mercer, did have financial troubles, and one committee concluded that he had acted “injudiciously” and wrote: “From various developments it appears that Mr. Rice is a very loose accountant and has imperfect talents for the disbursement of money” (165 n. 10).
Mercer was nothing less than tenacious in his support of missions. Anyone training for pastoral ministry should be required to read Chute’s fifth chapter, which details the way that Jesse Mercer led Baptists to cooperate together to reach the “heathen” with the gospel of Jesus Christ. Those who think that Calvinism is a threat to missions and evangelism should consider this chapter, for “Jesse Mercer steadfastly asserted his fidelity to the Calvinistic perspective of John Gill and still found scriptural warrant to justify his participation in the missionary movement” (158).
Mercer held firmly to his theological positions, and he sought earnestly to promote cooperation and agreement among his fellow Baptists. Seeking cooperation among Primitive and Missionary Baptists, Mercer opposed the decision of Primitive Baptists to require re-baptism of those who came to them from Missionary Baptist Churches (206). His goals were the glory of God, the good of the churches, and the propagation of the gospel." (Jim Hamilton)
http://jimhamilton.wordpress.com/category/history/page/2/
Throughout his career, Mercer was a avid proponent of missions. His missions advocacy took on two forms. First, Mercer argued for the legitimacy for missions over against the hyper-Calvinists of his day. During Mercer’s lifetime, many Baptists in the south were embracing such doctrines as eternal justification and refusing to preach the gospel “promiscuously” to all people, regardless of the presumed status of someone’s election. Most of the hyper-Calvinists, convinced they represented the apostolic faith, called themselves primitive Baptists. Mercer, though himself a strict Calvinist, argued against the extremes of hyper-Calvinism and argued for personal evangelism, church planting, and foreign missions. He was also a proponent of revival, having witnessed first-hand the Georgia manifestation of the Second Great Awakening in the 1820’s. He read widely the revival works of both Jonathan Edwards and Charles Finney, though he accepted the claims of neither without some criticism, particularly in the case of Finney. In a very real sense Mercer represented a healthy combination of the so-called “Charleston” and “Sandy Creek” traditions in pre-1845 southern Baptist history.
Mercer not only argued for the legitimacy of missions, but also for cooperation in missions. Primitives and other “anti-mission” Baptists argued against the legitimacy of mission boards, Sunday Schools, colleges, and other “innovations” they believed deviated from the New Testament pattern. The anti-mission Baptists were especially opposed to Luther Rice’s fundraising on behalf of the Triennial Convention. Mercer, like most other Baptists, argued for cooperation in missionary (and educational) endeavors. In fact, Mercer served four terms as a delegate to the Triennial Convention from 1817-1835. But besides his involvement in the Trienniel Convention, Mercer took the lead in establishing a means for Georgia Baptists to cooperate in missionary and educational enterprises. To that end, in 1822 Mercer helped found the Georgia Baptist Convention, which was the second Baptist state convention started in the south. Mercer served as the first president of the GBC, an office he held from 1822 until his death in 1841.
In 1833, Mercer became the editor of The Christian Index, now the official state paper of the Georgia Baptist Convention. The Index was first published in Washington, having been established there by Luther Rice in 1818 under than name The Latter-Day Luminary. Following several relocations and name changes, Mercer acquired the periodical and relocated it to Georgia, where it has remained ever since. The Christian Index, under its various names, is the oldest continuously-published religious periodical in America. Mercer used the pages of his paper to promote ministerial education and to contend for missions against the Primitive Baptists and other detractors.
http://nathanafinn.wordpress.com/2006/06/07/jesse-mercer-georgia-baptist-pioneer-in-missions-and-education/
"One of the most helpful features of Chute’s account is the way that he adeptly summarizes the dispute between Primitive Baptists and the Missionary Baptist party led by Jesse Mercer. Both Primitive and Missionary Baptists were Calvinists. Primitive Baptists opposed missionary efforts on the basis of their ecclesiology, arguing that cooperation between churches was unbiblical. Only individual churches should send out missionaries. So, for instance, John Leland, who is well known for his labors for religious liberty (see the recent volume edited by Thomas White, Jason G. Duesing, and Malcolm Yarnell, First Freedom) was “opposed to missions not because of a concern for Calvinistic theology being disregarded but out of [a] desire for simplicity and freedom in both government and religion” (134, Chute cites Tom Nettles, By His Grace and For His Glory, who has shown that Leland did not oppose missions because of his Calvinism). What’s more, Primitive Baptists thought that men such as Luther Rice, who handled the large sums of money gathered from cooperating churches, were corrupt and untrustworthy. Rice, who was friends with Mercer, did have financial troubles, and one committee concluded that he had acted “injudiciously” and wrote: “From various developments it appears that Mr. Rice is a very loose accountant and has imperfect talents for the disbursement of money” (165 n. 10).
Mercer was nothing less than tenacious in his support of missions. Anyone training for pastoral ministry should be required to read Chute’s fifth chapter, which details the way that Jesse Mercer led Baptists to cooperate together to reach the “heathen” with the gospel of Jesus Christ. Those who think that Calvinism is a threat to missions and evangelism should consider this chapter, for “Jesse Mercer steadfastly asserted his fidelity to the Calvinistic perspective of John Gill and still found scriptural warrant to justify his participation in the missionary movement” (158).
Mercer held firmly to his theological positions, and he sought earnestly to promote cooperation and agreement among his fellow Baptists. Seeking cooperation among Primitive and Missionary Baptists, Mercer opposed the decision of Primitive Baptists to require re-baptism of those who came to them from Missionary Baptist Churches (206). His goals were the glory of God, the good of the churches, and the propagation of the gospel." (Jim Hamilton)
http://jimhamilton.wordpress.com/category/history/page/2/
Birth Timeline?
"Spiritual Birthline: Understanding How We Experience the New Birth" By Stephen E. Smallman,is a book that was recently published by Crossway Books, Wheaton, Illinois, in 2006. According to reviews of the book, the writer presents a "three stage process" to the Christian experience of being "born again."
"Smallman’s thesis is that spiritual birth is like physical birth. Actual physical birth occurs nine months after conception, after physical life began. So too, he suggests, spiritual “birth,” or coming out, occurs some time after a spiritual life began. A chart on page 24 compares physical and spiritual birth. Conception in the physical realm corresponds to life beginning in the spiritual realm. Pregnancy corresponds to “effectual calling.” Delivery, a new baby crying, corresponds to conversion: faith and repentance. Physical growth of the baby corresponds to sanctification in the Christian life.
In the chart, the author suggests that “spiritual birth—regeneration” occurs over time between the beginning of spiritual life and the time of conversion.
But wouldn’t this make spiritual birth a process over time, and not something that occurs at a point in time? Yes: “The first thing to note from the birthline is the obvious fact that spiritual birth, just like physical birth, is fundamentally a process” (p. 25, italics his). “The process of coming to conscious faith, once the work of God has begun, is what could be thought of as spiritual pregnancy… In the older language of the Westminster Confession of Faith, the term for this is effectual calling, which simply means it works: when God calls, we come” (p. 27, italics his). “Spiritual pregnancy goes on as briefly or as long as it takes God to bring us to faith and repentance” (p. 27).
How long after spiritual life starts might conversion occur? The title of Chapter 2 gives the shocking answer: “The Birthline—A Sixty-five Year Pregnancy.” According to Smallman an Indian man in London came to faith in Christ sixty-five years after his spiritual life began (pp. 22-23)!
Frankly, this is very confusing. According to the author, spiritual life begins at a point in time. That starts a process called regeneration that lasts for years or decades. At the end of that time the process of regeneration has occurred.
While there is no condition of the new birth, according to the author, there are conditions for a person to “go public” (which Smallman also calls being converted). These include confessing Christ (pp. 16, 145), giving ourselves to Christ (p. 16), submitting one’s life to Christ (p. 78), confessing sin and receiving Christ as Lord and Savior (p. 80), trusting Christ as Lord and Savior (p. 16), repenting from sin and embracing Christ (p. 121), choosing to follow Christ (p. 126), and letting Jesus run our lives (pp. 147-49). What most Evangelicals would (wrongly) say are a variety of different ways to be born again, Smallman says are a variety of ways for a person who already possesses spiritual life to come out and finalize the process of regeneration.
Smallman repeatedly speaks of effectual calling (e.g., pp. 27, 77, 108, 130, 151). This calling is something which a person suspects, but can’t know with certainty (p. 149).
The most touching aspect of this book is that the author’s four children each give their own testimonies. These testimonies are well worth the price of the book. Each of the children look back over their lives and guess when they might have “gone public.” Since they believe that they were born again long before they went public, they clearly aren’t concerned about this coming out time. Listen to what Steve Smallman, Jr., himself a pastor, says: “Over the course of that summer God began to reveal to me, through a series of experiences, my profound spiritual bankruptcy and my real need for him to run my life. Was this my conversion? Possibly. But I have conscious recollection of my heart being warmed by sermons, songs, Christian fellowship, and the presence of God years before this time” (pp. 148-49).
Whenever we base our theology on our experience, or on the experience of others, we are in trouble. God has given us His Word, not experience, to show us the truth.
I strongly recommend this book to all discerning readers. It should be required reading for all soteriology classes." (Robert N. Wilkin - Editor - Journal of the Grace Evangelical Society, Irving, TX)
http://www.faithalone.org/journal/bookreviews/smallman.htm
"Smallman’s thesis is that spiritual birth is like physical birth. Actual physical birth occurs nine months after conception, after physical life began. So too, he suggests, spiritual “birth,” or coming out, occurs some time after a spiritual life began. A chart on page 24 compares physical and spiritual birth. Conception in the physical realm corresponds to life beginning in the spiritual realm. Pregnancy corresponds to “effectual calling.” Delivery, a new baby crying, corresponds to conversion: faith and repentance. Physical growth of the baby corresponds to sanctification in the Christian life.
In the chart, the author suggests that “spiritual birth—regeneration” occurs over time between the beginning of spiritual life and the time of conversion.
But wouldn’t this make spiritual birth a process over time, and not something that occurs at a point in time? Yes: “The first thing to note from the birthline is the obvious fact that spiritual birth, just like physical birth, is fundamentally a process” (p. 25, italics his). “The process of coming to conscious faith, once the work of God has begun, is what could be thought of as spiritual pregnancy… In the older language of the Westminster Confession of Faith, the term for this is effectual calling, which simply means it works: when God calls, we come” (p. 27, italics his). “Spiritual pregnancy goes on as briefly or as long as it takes God to bring us to faith and repentance” (p. 27).
How long after spiritual life starts might conversion occur? The title of Chapter 2 gives the shocking answer: “The Birthline—A Sixty-five Year Pregnancy.” According to Smallman an Indian man in London came to faith in Christ sixty-five years after his spiritual life began (pp. 22-23)!
Frankly, this is very confusing. According to the author, spiritual life begins at a point in time. That starts a process called regeneration that lasts for years or decades. At the end of that time the process of regeneration has occurred.
While there is no condition of the new birth, according to the author, there are conditions for a person to “go public” (which Smallman also calls being converted). These include confessing Christ (pp. 16, 145), giving ourselves to Christ (p. 16), submitting one’s life to Christ (p. 78), confessing sin and receiving Christ as Lord and Savior (p. 80), trusting Christ as Lord and Savior (p. 16), repenting from sin and embracing Christ (p. 121), choosing to follow Christ (p. 126), and letting Jesus run our lives (pp. 147-49). What most Evangelicals would (wrongly) say are a variety of different ways to be born again, Smallman says are a variety of ways for a person who already possesses spiritual life to come out and finalize the process of regeneration.
Smallman repeatedly speaks of effectual calling (e.g., pp. 27, 77, 108, 130, 151). This calling is something which a person suspects, but can’t know with certainty (p. 149).
The most touching aspect of this book is that the author’s four children each give their own testimonies. These testimonies are well worth the price of the book. Each of the children look back over their lives and guess when they might have “gone public.” Since they believe that they were born again long before they went public, they clearly aren’t concerned about this coming out time. Listen to what Steve Smallman, Jr., himself a pastor, says: “Over the course of that summer God began to reveal to me, through a series of experiences, my profound spiritual bankruptcy and my real need for him to run my life. Was this my conversion? Possibly. But I have conscious recollection of my heart being warmed by sermons, songs, Christian fellowship, and the presence of God years before this time” (pp. 148-49).
Whenever we base our theology on our experience, or on the experience of others, we are in trouble. God has given us His Word, not experience, to show us the truth.
I strongly recommend this book to all discerning readers. It should be required reading for all soteriology classes." (Robert N. Wilkin - Editor - Journal of the Grace Evangelical Society, Irving, TX)
http://www.faithalone.org/journal/bookreviews/smallman.htm
Various Birth Models
1. Begotten by the Spirit without the word (regeneration), which produces a "womb" experience (conviction), which finally produces, mediately through the word, a "birth" or "deliverance" (conversion).
2. Begotten by the word in conversion but born in water baptism.
3. Begotten in time in the experience of salvation but birthed in the resurrection.
4. Begotten and birthing ("bringing forth") are equated in scripture.
I believe #4 and believe this is the view of scripture and the predominant view of historic Baptists.
"William C. Long in April 1893, wrote in the Advocate: 'We are begotten of God; we are born of the Spirit. These two events do not occur at the same time. We are begotten at conversion; we are born at the resurrection.'"
"It should come as no surprise therefore, that the Church of God (Seventh Day) based at Salem, West Virginia, still teaches a future birth at the resurrection. Their general belief is birth in three stages: 1. the natural birth at the time we enter this world; 2. birth at the time of water baptism; 3. the third birth at the time of the resurrection (see their booklet The Three Births)."
http://www.giveshare.org/churchhistory/born%20again.htm
2. Begotten by the word in conversion but born in water baptism.
3. Begotten in time in the experience of salvation but birthed in the resurrection.
4. Begotten and birthing ("bringing forth") are equated in scripture.
I believe #4 and believe this is the view of scripture and the predominant view of historic Baptists.
"William C. Long in April 1893, wrote in the Advocate: 'We are begotten of God; we are born of the Spirit. These two events do not occur at the same time. We are begotten at conversion; we are born at the resurrection.'"
"It should come as no surprise therefore, that the Church of God (Seventh Day) based at Salem, West Virginia, still teaches a future birth at the resurrection. Their general belief is birth in three stages: 1. the natural birth at the time we enter this world; 2. birth at the time of water baptism; 3. the third birth at the time of the resurrection (see their booklet The Three Births)."
http://www.giveshare.org/churchhistory/born%20again.htm
Hodge on Special Atonement
"...it has in all ages been customary with Augustinians to say that Christ died "sufficienter pro omnibus, efficaciter tantum pro electis;" sufficiently for all, efficaciously only for the elect. There is a sense, therefore, in which He died for all, and there is a sense in which He died for the elect alone. The simple question is, Had the death of Christ a reference to the elect which it had not to other men? Did He come into the world to secure the salvation of those given to Him by the Father, so that the other effects of his work are merely incidental to what was done for the attainment of that object?"
CHARLES HODGE, SYSTEMATIC THEOLOGY, Vol. II, Page 546
CHARLES HODGE, SYSTEMATIC THEOLOGY, Vol. II, Page 546
Campbell on Parker
Wrote Alexander Campbell about Daniel Parker (one of the fathers of the anti-mission movement and of the "Primitive Baptist" (Hardshell) denomination):
"Particularism, under the auspices of my friend of Oakly and the new theological school, and the doctrine of the "Two Seeds," is rather looking up on the banks of the Licking. Elder Parker, of Illinois has been translated to Kentucky through the efficacy of his faith in the "two seeds."--He founds election on the natural birth, by a discovery which eluded the eagle eye of Calvin and Beza and all the Jansenists of Rome. He found that Cain was literally begotten by the Devil, and Seth by the Almighty, through the instrumentality of Adam. And so it has been ever since. The Devil is the literal father of all the non-elect, and the Almighty of the elect. Hence the sons of Seth were literally the sons of God, and the daughters of Cain were really the daughters of the Devil; and so each after death must necessarily return to their respective parents.
Friend Parker has reduced the "five points" to two. His first is, that "God never created a set of beings, neither directly nor indirectly, that he suffered to be taken from him and made the subjects of his eternal wrath and indignation." The wicked are therefore indirectly created by the Devil. Mr. Parker has literally taught this doctrine. This is the best argument against catechisms Illinois has yet produced. Mr. Parker cannot, dare not, ask any child, "Who made you?" for the good reason that neither he nor the child knows whether God or the Devil made it!!--Thus the friends of the creeds and catechisms are likely to help us much. His second point is, that "God, as God, in no case possesses more love and mercy than power and wisdom." This is sublimated fatalism. This new creed has great simplicity about it, though its inventor has made it so shameful in his different theories of generation and regeneration, that my nerves have never been strong enough to read it all through. There is a mystery in all cases of twins, which my friend Daniel Parker has not fully solved.--He admits, it is true, that the Devil begat Esau, and the Almighty begat Jacob, but fails very much in his exposition of the modus operandi. The struggling of the unborn infant comes in to his relief, but does not help him quite through. But his theory makes Jesus the Saviour no more the Son of God, than Jacob the brother of Esau.
I threw this pamphlet aside about a year ago, and never intended to open it again; but recent information that the Particulars in Kentucky were placing this modern Daniel along side of Silas and John, and about to have a theological school for teaching the marrow of modern divinity, in which one of the three was to act the Principal, I took it up to see if it had mellowed by time: but it smells as rancid as ever--and I cannot now read it all. JULY 6, 1829.
http://www.mun.ca/rels/restmov/texts/acampbell/tcb/TCB612.HTM#Essay7
The "Church Advocate," edited in Vincennes, by elder Daniel Parker, author of the two seeds, or modernized Manichean doctrine of two principles changed from the Persian to the American philosophy, is engaged in slandering me with his usual dexterity in the good work of defamation. He boasts of great intimacy with Dr. Noel, and says he found a cordial welcome into his pulpit in Frankfort. This pulpit, it is said, is consecrated after the manner of the sanctum sanctorum of the Jews.
Mr. Parker resolves every thing into his philosophic scheme of predestination, and he that denies his work of the Holy Spirit, or his call to the ministry, he represents in his last number as having committed the unpardonable sin. Reader, brace your nerves, and read what follows from his fourth number!
"If so be, that denying the office and work of the Spirit in experimental religion, and call to, and work of the ministry, should be that sin against the Holy Ghost, (which appears to me to be the fact,) then with awful sensation of feelings, we know the fate of those who are thus engaged. We need not pray for them; the Lord will not hear on their behalf; their doom is filled, and their conscience seared. You cannot bring conviction to their minds--and to say that we do not deny the office or work of the Spirit, and yet contend that the Spirit and Word are one, or that there is no spirit but what is in the Word, is making the matter worse. It is not only denying the work of God, as a Spirit, but also lying before God, for the purpose of covering a blasphemous sin."
Surely this is a wonderful age, an eventful time! We may expect to hear soon that the Earth is as flat as a trencher, and that the Sun is a ball of fire whirling round it; that language has any meaning, or that Revelation is any blessing to man, may soon be denied. Every one who opposes the dreams of Daniel Parker about his call to the ministry, is not to be prayed for!!! This is the fair meaning of the text and context. MARCH 1, 1830."
http://www.mun.ca/rels/restmov/texts/acampbell/tcb/TCB708.HTM#Essay6
"Particularism, under the auspices of my friend of Oakly and the new theological school, and the doctrine of the "Two Seeds," is rather looking up on the banks of the Licking. Elder Parker, of Illinois has been translated to Kentucky through the efficacy of his faith in the "two seeds."--He founds election on the natural birth, by a discovery which eluded the eagle eye of Calvin and Beza and all the Jansenists of Rome. He found that Cain was literally begotten by the Devil, and Seth by the Almighty, through the instrumentality of Adam. And so it has been ever since. The Devil is the literal father of all the non-elect, and the Almighty of the elect. Hence the sons of Seth were literally the sons of God, and the daughters of Cain were really the daughters of the Devil; and so each after death must necessarily return to their respective parents.
Friend Parker has reduced the "five points" to two. His first is, that "God never created a set of beings, neither directly nor indirectly, that he suffered to be taken from him and made the subjects of his eternal wrath and indignation." The wicked are therefore indirectly created by the Devil. Mr. Parker has literally taught this doctrine. This is the best argument against catechisms Illinois has yet produced. Mr. Parker cannot, dare not, ask any child, "Who made you?" for the good reason that neither he nor the child knows whether God or the Devil made it!!--Thus the friends of the creeds and catechisms are likely to help us much. His second point is, that "God, as God, in no case possesses more love and mercy than power and wisdom." This is sublimated fatalism. This new creed has great simplicity about it, though its inventor has made it so shameful in his different theories of generation and regeneration, that my nerves have never been strong enough to read it all through. There is a mystery in all cases of twins, which my friend Daniel Parker has not fully solved.--He admits, it is true, that the Devil begat Esau, and the Almighty begat Jacob, but fails very much in his exposition of the modus operandi. The struggling of the unborn infant comes in to his relief, but does not help him quite through. But his theory makes Jesus the Saviour no more the Son of God, than Jacob the brother of Esau.
I threw this pamphlet aside about a year ago, and never intended to open it again; but recent information that the Particulars in Kentucky were placing this modern Daniel along side of Silas and John, and about to have a theological school for teaching the marrow of modern divinity, in which one of the three was to act the Principal, I took it up to see if it had mellowed by time: but it smells as rancid as ever--and I cannot now read it all. JULY 6, 1829.
http://www.mun.ca/rels/restmov/texts/acampbell/tcb/TCB612.HTM#Essay7
The "Church Advocate," edited in Vincennes, by elder Daniel Parker, author of the two seeds, or modernized Manichean doctrine of two principles changed from the Persian to the American philosophy, is engaged in slandering me with his usual dexterity in the good work of defamation. He boasts of great intimacy with Dr. Noel, and says he found a cordial welcome into his pulpit in Frankfort. This pulpit, it is said, is consecrated after the manner of the sanctum sanctorum of the Jews.
Mr. Parker resolves every thing into his philosophic scheme of predestination, and he that denies his work of the Holy Spirit, or his call to the ministry, he represents in his last number as having committed the unpardonable sin. Reader, brace your nerves, and read what follows from his fourth number!
"If so be, that denying the office and work of the Spirit in experimental religion, and call to, and work of the ministry, should be that sin against the Holy Ghost, (which appears to me to be the fact,) then with awful sensation of feelings, we know the fate of those who are thus engaged. We need not pray for them; the Lord will not hear on their behalf; their doom is filled, and their conscience seared. You cannot bring conviction to their minds--and to say that we do not deny the office or work of the Spirit, and yet contend that the Spirit and Word are one, or that there is no spirit but what is in the Word, is making the matter worse. It is not only denying the work of God, as a Spirit, but also lying before God, for the purpose of covering a blasphemous sin."
Surely this is a wonderful age, an eventful time! We may expect to hear soon that the Earth is as flat as a trencher, and that the Sun is a ball of fire whirling round it; that language has any meaning, or that Revelation is any blessing to man, may soon be denied. Every one who opposes the dreams of Daniel Parker about his call to the ministry, is not to be prayed for!!! This is the fair meaning of the text and context. MARCH 1, 1830."
http://www.mun.ca/rels/restmov/texts/acampbell/tcb/TCB708.HTM#Essay6
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)