Sep 26, 2008

J. M. Pendleton on Means

"The instrumentality employed is the gospel — the truth of God. This a controverted point. Some (Hardshells and Hyperists - SG) argue that God renews the soul without the intervention of means. I think differently. Observe the following passages: "In Christ Jesus have I begotten you through the gospel." "Of his own will begat he us with the word of truth." "Being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, by the Word of God, which liveth and abideth forever." "The sword of the Spirit, which is the Word of God." It seems to me that the first three of these Scriptures prove positively the instrumentality of divine truth in regeneration, and the last passage indirectly establishes the same point; for if the Word of God is the instrument which the Spirit employs, why does he not employ it in regeneration?

[p. 167] Can any one assign a good reason? There is a sense in which we are born of the Spirit of God, and also a sense in which we are born of the Word of God. The agency of the Spirit and the instrumentality of the Word, are indicated by the two forms of expression. God uses means in the natural world, and why should He act on a different principle in the moral? He does not. The gift of the Bible, and the institution of the gospel ministry, prove that he does not. I sup­pose the Spirit of God, in regenerating the heart, makes use of truth previously lodged in the understanding. The Word of God presents the motives which the same Agent employs in influ­encing the heart. The Spirit alone can render the means effectual. What can means do with­out an agent to use them?"

[From J. M. Pendleton, Short Sermons on Important Subjects, 1859. This book is from Southeastern Baptist Theological Seminary Library, Wake Forest, NC via ILL through Boone County Public Library, Burlington, KY. - Jim Duvall]

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/pendleton.sermons.18.html

Sep 25, 2008

Valley of Dry Bones

Hardshell "patriarch," Elder R. W. Thompson, says this about the Hardshell "interpretation" of Ezekiel and the valley of dry bones.

"These bones . . . were an evidence of a former life, and are far from representing unregenerate sinners, who are dead in trespasses and sins . . . If these dry bones represent any who have not been quickened by the Spirit, then there might be a reason for calling upon dead sinners to hear, believe and obey. As they do not, but do represent . . . Christians . . . If it should be claimed that Ezekiel was an instrument in the hand of God, to the accomplishing of this change, then I would say, He would only be such to those who were dead to their privileges and enjoyments; but were not dead to the fact, that they were God's chosen people highly favored . . ." (pages 1, 4 of THE HARDSHELL BAPTIST, 3/85).

If this statement from Thompson doesn't demonstrate the determination of the Hardshells to believe their theory no matter what the scriptures show to the contrary, then it cannot be so demonstrated.

The Hardshells know that the vision of the dry bones destroys their arguments against human means! So, what do they do? They affirm that those dry and dead bones represent living, regenerated children of God, or Christians!

If you can make "dead" to mean "alive," then you can make the Bible mean anything! Thompson also confesses that if the death of the bones is emblematic of the death of the sinner, then there "might be" a reason for calling upon dead sinners to hear, believe, and obey!" He is going to hold on to his theory no matter what!

Dad printed this article in his paper and called Thompson's interpretation "the correct interpretation!"

Elder Mitchell, another Hardshell, wrote the following on Ezekiel's valley of dry bones:

"This vision of the valley of dry bones has frequently been applied, both in preaching and writing, to represent the unconverted sinner while dead in trespasses and in sins; and the prophesying of the prophet upon these dry bones is said to represent the preaching of the gospel to the unconverted and dead sinner, who is alienated from the life of God through the blindness of his heart, and this preaching to him, it is said, becomes the means by which God gives him life from the dead."

"Now, as we have neither time nor inclination to argue this question, it may suffice to say at present, that neither this narrative of the valley of dry bones, nor any other text, will justify such an application of the subject as we have stated above. "The preaching of the gospel is to them that perish foolishness." To them it is the "savor of death unto death," but to the church and people of God who are born of God, it is the "savor of life unto life," as Ezekiel's prophesy was unto the "whole house of Israel" as represented by the dry bones of the valley. The Lord saith unto the prophet, "These bones are the whole house of Israel." And not only this, but he also saith that they are "my people;" therefore, or for that reason, "prophesy unto them." "Thus saith the Lord, Behold, O my people, I will open your graves and cause you to come up out of your graves, and bring you into the land of Israel.""

"With regard to the valley of dry bones, they are said to be not only dry, but very dry. And though dry and very dry, they are designed of God to represent "The whole house of Israel," who, in their low and degenerate state of worship, were as helpless, and had no more power to revive themselves, or bring themselves back to their former state of peace, joy and prosperity in the land of Israel, than a valley full of dry bones had to clothe themselves with sinews, flesh and skin, and stand up an exceeding great army of living men and women before the Lord. No; Israel was helpless, and nothing but the Almighty and life-giving power of God could again revive them, or bring them back to the simplicity and purity of the worship of God from which they had departed. But there is nothing too hard for the Lord which he has promised or proposed to do. And as he designed to send his prophet to this rebellious, hard-hearted and helpless people, that prophet must have an experience which would adapt him to the work, and enable him to go forth in the Lord's name, speaking with faith and confidence that the word of the Lord should not return unto him void, but that it should accomplish what, the Lord would have it do, and prosper in the very things to which God should send it, even though it should seem as impossible to human reason as it would be for dry bones to rise up into an army of living men. But before the prophet could understand all this, and go forth with confidence, he must first know his own weakness, and be made to feel that he was as passive and helpless in the hands of God as a dry lump of clay would be in the hands of the potter."

"They (God's messengers or ministers) become concerned, not so much about "saving souls" from an eternal hell, as they do for the purity of the church of God in doctrine and in order."

"The prophet thus had an experience of the sovereign and omnipotent power of God in his own case. This experience greatly prepared him to speak even to dry bones in the name of the Lord, with confidence that God was able to make them live." ("The Valley of Dry Bones -- Ezk. 37" - by W.M. Mitchell - THE GOSPEL MESSENGER -- December 1888)

www.primitivebaptist.info/mambo//content/view/375/36/

These two 19th century Hardshell apologists demonstrate their theological stubbornness to what the scriptures teach regarding regeneration by means of the gospel being applied and believed. The story of Ezekiel and the Valley of Dry Bones was one passage that helped to deliver me from Hardshellism. I simply refused to be as stubborn and dishonest with the plain teachings of the word of God. Yes, these dry bones represented the "whole house of Israel," but surely the Hardshells will not overtly say that this means they were all regenerated! This is what they are saying, consequentially speaking.

Jesus identified the imagery of "dead bones" with inner depravity, with an unrenewed nature. (See Matthew 23: 27) Yet, the Hardshells see these "dry dead bones" as a picture of regenerated Christians! Yet, such Christians as are "dead" in their worship! According to these Hardshells the Lord can get credit for resurrecting living regenerated children of God from dead worship, even though he does it through Ezekiel and preaching the gospel, but they will not allow that resurrection to spiritual life, or regeneration itself, if likewise accomplished through means, is all the work of God. They will charge those who believe that the story of Ezekiel shows how God raises the spiritually dead through the preaching of the prophet with denying that God does the work, or that it is all of God. What contradictions! What nonsense!

Sep 24, 2008

A. A. Hodge on Regeneration

"Regeneration (from Lat. re-, again + generare, beget) is a theological term used to express the initial stage of the change experienced by one who enters upon the Christian life."

"The Reformers separated justification by itself as something wrought on, not in, the sinner, and employed regeneration to express the whole process of inner renovation in all its stages. In the development of Protestant theology the term has been still further narrowed: first, to express the opening stage of this subjective work as distinguished from its continuance in sanctification; and then, since the seventeenth century, to express the initial divine act in this opening stage itself, as distinguished from the broader term conversion, which includes, along with the act of God, revivifying man, also the act of man in turning to God."

("Regeneration" by A.A. Hodge; revised by B.B. Warfield)

http://homepage.mac.com/shanerosenthal/reformationink/aabbregen.htm


Who holds then the orginal "Reformed" view, men like Sproul and White or men like Brother Ross and myself?

Berkouwer & Reformed Ordo

"Abraham Kuyper once noted a difference between older and newer terminology in the subject of faith and grace. The Belgic Confession uses the older terminology in Article 24, where we read: "We believe that this true faith, being wrought in man by the hearing of the Word of God and the operation of the Holy Spirit, regenerates him and makes him a new man, causing him to live a new life, and freeing him from the bondage of sin." The relation between faith and regeneration as found here is suggestive of Calvin's statement "that we are regenerated by faith." The newer terminology is that used by later theologians, who limit regeneration in the ordo salutis to the beginning of the new life. Kuyper spoke of the older Reformation and confessional terminology as the result of an "unfinished conception," of which the later, more limited idea of regeneration was "the consistent development." Kuyper approved this development, but not simply out of love for systems. The refinement of terminology resulted, according to him, from a desire to protect the Reformed concept from misconception."

Of course I disagree with the above words highlighted in blue. The words highlighted in red are what I desire to be especially noted.

I certainly do agree with this statement of Berkouwer (and made by others and also by myself many times):

"...it is not possible to deduce a fixed ordo from the words of Scripture and their order." ("Faith and Justification" By G. C. Berkouwer, pages 29, 30)

Sep 23, 2008

Charismata Ceased in 1st Century?

Recently I published some thoughts on the "charismata," and how it is my belief that the "strict cessationist" view is incorrect. One of the integral elements of this view avows that the "charismata" came to an abrupt end "in the first century." This view is a derivative of the erroneous view that tries to make "that which is perfect is come," in I Corinthians 13, to be the completion of the bible, or the completion of the writing of the Book of Revelation, about A.D. 95, which it does not, of course, but rather refers to the coming of the "perfect day," or to the second coming of Christ.

If the "completed canon" of the bible is what is referred to in that passage, then the date is fixed. A.D. 95 marks the date when all the charismatic gifts in the church just suddenly "ceased." This is not only absurd, and unscriptural, but also against plain facts of history.

Recently I read a statement by Phil Johnson where he made the statement (at pyromaniacs) that the charismatic gifts ended "in the first century." I thought about leaving him a comment to correct him, but thought, "what's the use, seeing how I have been treated before at pyromaniacs by Frank and Dan?" Is it historically and literally true that the charismatic gifts suddenly "ceased" in A.D. 95?

Read the following historical information from my friend Billy on his blog yesterday.

"John MacArthur, like so many Dispensationalists, insists that there were only three periods in history when signs and wonders occurred. In his book The Charismatics, he wrote, "Essentially the numerous other Charismatics say that what happened during New Testament times should be the norm throughout the church's history. Many state that everything in the New Testament that was miraculous, remarkable, and characterized by supernatural manifestation should be normative for all of the church age, including today."

I can use MacArthur's views on this subject since he has not wavered from his position since the time he wrote that book. Perhaps some Charismatics have made comments that the miraculous should be the "norm" throughout the Church age, but "norm" does not accurately describe the miraculous. What Charismatics and Pentecostals mean by "norm" is that those signs and wonders did not pass away with the first century Church.


MacArthur continued, "According to Scripture, miracles occurred in three major periods: the days of Moses and Joshua, the time of Elijah and Elisha, and the time of Christ and the apostles. Each of these periods lasted something less than one hundred years, but in each period there was a proliferation of miracles. Miracles were the norm."

Is that so? In his book 2000 Years of Charismatic Christianity, Eddie Hyatt has investigated these claims and found that signs and wonders did not cease with the first century apostles. What do men like MacArthur do with such evidence of the early Church fathers which clearly contradicts what he is propagating?


Justin Martyr, in his Dialogue With Trypho, claimed, "For the prophetical gifts remain with us even to the present time . . . [and that] Now it is possible to see among us women and men who possess gifts of the Spirit of God." In The Second Apology of Justin, he writes, "For numberless demoniacs throughout the whole world, and in your city, many of our Christian men exorcising them in the name of Jesus Christ, who was crucified under Pontius Pilate, have healed and do heal, rendering helpless and driving the possessing devils out of the men."

What do we do with this? Justin Martyr lived A.D. 100-165, well after the death of the last apostle! But the miraculous does not stop there.


Irenaeus (A.D. 125-200) wrote, "For some do certainly and truly drive out devils, so that those who have been thus cleansed from evil spirits frequently both believe, and join themselves to the Church. Other have foreknowledge of things to come: they see visions and utter prophetic expressions. Others still heal the sick by laying their hands upon them, and they are made whole."

He also noted that "the dead even have been raised up, and remained among us for many years. And what shall I more say? It is not possible to name the number of gifts which the Church throughout the whole world has received from God in the name of Jesus Christ." Is this some residual left over from the age of the apostles, or was the Holy Spirit still manifesting His sovereign works even into the second century? We believe the latter.


If all we had were the witnesses of Justin Martyr and Irenaeus, MacArthur's claim would still be contradicted by history. But there is so much more! For the sake of brevity, I will only quote five other men from church history.

Tertullian wrote, "Let Marcion then exhibit, as gifts of his god, some prophets such as have not spoken by human sense, but with the Spirit of God, such as have predicted things to come and have made manifest the secrets of the heart; let him produce a psalm, a vision, a prayer ~ only let it be by the spirit, in an ecstasy, that is, in a rapture, whenever an interpretation of tongues has occurred to him. Now all these signs are forthcoming from my side without any difficulty."


It is true that when Constantine wed the Church with the culture, and unregenerate people were forced to become Christians, there was a waning of spiritual manifestations. John Chrysostom (A.D. 347-407) noted, "If anyone is trying or intending to corrupt a woman, there is no place, I suppose, that seems to him more suitable than the Church. And if anything is to be sold or bought, the Church appears more convenient than the market. Or if any wish to say or hear any scandal, you will find that this to be had here more than the forum without."


But we find evidence of the Spirit's work whenever and wherever the people were serving Christ Jesus with purity of heart. Though the Church had become corrupt, there were pockets of miracles in the midst of faithful believers. When Pope Innocent IV had informed Thomas Aquinas, "You see that the Church is no longer in an age in which she can say, 'Silver and gold have I none'" [Acts 3.6a], Aquinas responded, "It is true, nor can she say to the lame man, 'Rise up and walk'" [Acts 3.6b]. But note that the reason for this was not due to a withdrawal of the Holy Spirit's power (because He was done with His miraculous works in the Church); the Church had corrupted her ways, and He was not willing to work in the midst of corruption.


Bernard of Clairvaux (A.D. 1090-1153) was reported to have performed healings by the power of the Holy Spirit. "From all quarters sick persons were conveyed to him by the friends who sought from him a cure."
Martin Luther (A.D.1483-1546), when his colleague, Frederick Myconius, laid sick, said, "I command thee in the Name of God to live because I still have need of thee in the work of reforming the Church. The Lord will never let me hear that thou art dead but permit thee to survive me. For this I am praying, this is my will, and may my will be done because I seek only to glorify the Name of God." (He outlived Luther by two months.)
John Wesley (A.D. 1703-1791) recorded, "As it can be proved by abundance of witnesses that these cures were frequently (indeed almost always) the instantaneous consequences of prayer, your inference is just. I cannot, dare not, affirm that they were purely natural. I believe they were not. I believe many of them were wrought by the supernatural power of God." He also noted, "I do not recollect any Scripture wherein we are taught that miracles were to be confined within the limits either of the apostolic age or the Cyprian age, or of any period of time, longer or shorter, even till the restitution of all things."


And finally, George Whitefield (A.D. 1714-1770) records the following for our edification. Though these are not miracles, they represent expressions or reactions to the work of the Holy Spirit which one might find in a modern Pentecostal/Charismatic church during the revivals in his own day.

He wrote, "There were some instances of persons lying in a sort of trance, remaining perhaps for a whole twenty-four hours motionless, and with their senses locked up; but in the mean time under strong imaginations, as though they went to heaven and had there visions of glorious and delightful objects."

Hopefully, my friends, enough Church history has been recorded here in this one short post to convince you that miracles, signs, wonders, and other manifestations of the Holy Spirit have not passed away. Such things the Spirit of God is willing to do for the glory of the Lord Jesus Christ, by the drawing of sinners to the Gospel, and the building up of God's children.

Let's develop this further tomorrow, singling out the gifts of healings. I have commentary waiting in the wings by John Piper, Wayne Grudem, and Howard Ervin."

http://classicalarminianism.blogspot.com/2008/09/if-age-of-signs-wonders-ceased-someone.html


So, did the charismatic gifts "cease in the first century"? NO!

Daily on Regeneration

Hardshell apologist John R. Daily wrote:

"In this work God is alone, using no means or instrumentalities. It is sometimes urged that he is able to produce this change either by the use of means or without them. The question is not as to what God is able to do, but as to what he does do. There is not a passage in all the bible that teaches that means are employed in the work of regeneration. In taking away the stony heart, and giving a heart of flesh, the Lord works a change in the disposition of the sinner that renders him susceptible of being affected by the gospel." ("The New Heart" - Zion's Advocate, December 1898, Vol. 37, No. 12)

http://www.carthage.lib.il.us/community/churches/primbap/DailyEditorials8.html

This is what one of the leading apologists of the Hardshell denomination wrote over a hundred years ago.

I have two comments.

First, Daily must have closed his eyes when he was reading the Bible, for there are numerous verses that prove that regeneration is accomplished by the Spirit's use of gospel truth. The early part of my ongoing book, "The Hardshell Baptist Cult," covers many verses ("hot shot" verses) that destroy the anti-means view of Daily and the Hardshells, and of today's "neo-Reformed" crowd.

Second, Daily's Hardshell view on this matter is not any different from what we hear coming from the "Reformed" crowd, those who also affirm that initial regeneration is accomplished without means; And, yet, they seem to get upset when we call them "Hardshells" and "Hyper Calvinists"!

If one agrees with Daily, then he is a Hyperist.

Sep 22, 2008

Monergism's Hall of Fame?

"Hall of Contemporary Reformers"

This is the title of a section on monergism.com's web site. What does one have to do to get in this "Hall" of "Reformed" fame? Apparently, one has to be a Hyper Calvinist and accept the proposition that the new birth occurs and is completed before and apart from faith. Well, I don't ever expect to be "voted into" that "Hall."

Who is on the list? Here are the names on the list.

"John Piper, R. C. Sproul, James White, Tim Keller, Sinclair Ferguson, John MacArthur, Al Mohler, C. J. Mahaney, Michael Horton, D. A. Carson, Mark Dever, John Frame, James M. Boice, J. Ligon Duncan III, Iain H. Murray, J. L. Packer, Arturo Azurdia III."

Now, I am sure that there are some on this list who may deny that they should ever be included. But, nevertheless, Hendryx thinks they "qualify."

Sad, however, that names like Calvin, Spurgeon, Edwards, Booth, etc., cannot be put on the list! Cannot become members of this great "Hall" of Reformed fame!

http://www.monergism.com/thethreshold/articles/bio/contempreform.html

Bought All Men

Spurgeon said it well in a sermon entitled “Good Cheer for Many that Fear”:

“We believe that by His atoning sacrifice, Christ bought some good things for all men and all good things for some men. And that when He died He had a definite purpose in dying and that His purpose will certainly be effected.”

http://www.spurgeongems.org/vols49-51/chs2815.pdf

This is my view also.

Use the Old Preachers!

"In 1868 Elder Vaughan fell and crushed his hip. Being in his eighty-fourth year he was permanently disabled, but he had preached constantly up to that time. His remarkable activity at that great age, and his powerful preaching for the twenty-five years preceding, proves that the fad of "laying on the shelf" all preachers at the age of sixty is superlative nonsense. A preacher is really not at his best until he reaches fifty, and for twenty years after that he should do, and generally does, his best work. After the age of seventy we may look for a decline, but many [p. 69] remain effective and strong to eighty or ninety years of age. For instance, there is the subject of this sketch and Dr. A. D. Sears, who in his ninety-sixth year preached every Sunday acceptably for the church in Clarksville, Tenn.; and there is S. H. Ford, who at the age of eighty-one preaches with great power. J. M. Pendleton did the best year's work of his life, judging from the results, when he was seventy-one years old. It was his last year at Up­land, Penn. The author calls attention to this be­cause of the pernicious idea that our old men should step aside just when they are strongest mentally and spiritually and give place to young men with but little to commend them besides their energy. The author is himself a young man, just thirty-one years old, but he hereby enters a protest against the mis­chievous practice of pushing out of the ministry our strongest and most experienced preachers.

During the last years of his life he lived with his son, Eld. T. M. Vaughan. He was a student to the last, and occasionally preached a sermon while he sat in his easy arm-chair, being unable to stand. On February 25, 1877, at the advanced age of ninety-three years, he preached his last sermon in the church house at Danville, Ky. On the 31st day of March, a few days over a month thereafter, he fell asleep in Jesus, and was laid to rest in the Bloomfield (Ky.) cemetery, near the pulpit where he had preached for over thirty years."
("Elder William Vaughan" By Ben M. Bogard)

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/vaughan.william.by.bogard.html

Sep 21, 2008

Campbell debates Ford & Vaughan?

It is a difficult, if not impossible task, to find any written records of debates that Alexander Campbell had with the Baptists. I have written before about some of the dialogue that occurred between Campbell and Elders Andrew Broaddus and Bishop Semple. I have also written about the famous Campbell-Peck debate which never occurred. J.M. Peck was working with Campbell on debating the topic of whether the word alone, or whether a power of the Spirit in addition to the word, was that which effected regeneration. While in this process, it was discovered by both that there was no substantial disagreement, and so there was no debate.

One can easily find Campbell's famous debates with McCalla, Purcell, Rice, Owen, etc. But, where are the debates with the Baptists? He apparently had them. But, they did not get published, it seems. I have run across information about a debate that Campbell had with two Baptists, with Samuel Ford and with William Vaughan.

Dr. Samuel Ford

"Dr. Ford has received the honorary degree of L.L.D. He preaches without manuscript, is earnest and eloquent, and many hundreds have been converted under his ministry. He is a firm Baptist, and he has had discussions with Alexander Campbell, Bishop Spaulding, of the Catholic church, and Dr. N. L. Rice. Dr. Ford is a Hebrew and Syriac scholar; he is well read in general literature, and is specially familiar with the Romish controversy. In his theology he is a Calvinist."

[From The Baptist Encyclopedia, William Cathcart, editor, 1881; rpt. 1988, pp. 404-405. jrd]

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/ford.samuel.h.html

Does anyone have any information about this debate?

William Vaughan

"He was licensed to preach February, 1811, by Friendship Church, Ky. He made some dismal failures at the beginning, but he increased in power as he continued to try, and no other man in Ken­tucky ever became so great a preacher as he. Tes­timonies from various sources could be quoted, but suffice it to say that all accord to Wm. Vaughan the first place as a great preacher of all who lived dur­ing the first half of the nineteenth century. Others have risen up who have perhaps been as great, but none equaled him in his day.

He was at various times pastor of a number of country and village churches, and traveled exten­sively as missionary and evangelist, and thousands were converted and baptized under his ministry. He labored untiringly, and braved the cold and the heat, and went under all circumstances "everywhere preaching the word." The greatest work of his life, however, was his fight with Campbellism. He met the leaders of the Campbellite movement in debate and always admin­istered a crushing defeat to his opponent. Besides this he confirmed the churches and the ministry. [p. 68] Had it not been for his powerful preaching whole churches and associations, that are now among the strongest in Kentucky, would have gone with Alex­ander Campbell. Such men as Wm. Warder and Jeremiah Vardeman, and several other lesser lights, were saved from the errors of Campbell by his influ­ence."


http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/vaughan.william.by.bogard.html

"The Baptists will never know until eternity reveals the facts how much they owe to Wm. Vaughan. Among the mighty defenders of the faith stands as a pillar of strength this remarkable man. He gave a son to the ministry who made a strong, useful preacher. He gave solidity to Kentucky Baptists, and they have ever since been noted for their orthodoxy.

His greatest debate was with Alexander Campbell. In this debate "he dissected Mr. Campbell's system with a masterly hand, drew the line between it and the doctrine of the Baptists, and made open war on the new theory."
(Spencer's History Ky. Baptists, page 226)

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/vaughan.william.by.bogard.html

Vaughan also, like Campbell, debated the Presbyterian McCalla. There is also this reference to Vaughan and his debate with Campbell.

"In 1827 he removed to Ohio, where he remained one year, and returned to Kentucky. He was now brought into conflict with the disciples of Campbell, who were making many proselytes. Being the only minister in Kentucky at that time who was able to grapple successfully with the adherents of the new doctrine, he was encouraged by the churches to defend their principles against the assaults of Mr. Campbell, and devoted himself with great energy and extraordinary ability to this work." (The Baptist Encyclopedia, 1881)

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/vaughan.william.bio.tbe.html

Again, anyone know of any information on these debates?