The following are some excerpts from Berhouwer on "Divine Election" that I felt worth saying "amen" by publishing them here in the "Baptist Gadfly."
"God's election is sovereign and gracious, and hence not based on any human quality. It can therefore never lead to self exaltation. That is why there is an unfathomable abyss between an arrogated election and the election of God (cf. Rom. 8:33)."
"Both in the fellowship and in the individual life, election rules out all pretentiousness, all self-exaltation, and all self-election (Gal. 3:28)."
"Israel interpreted election apart from faith and thus drew illicit conclusions from it."
http://books.google.com/books?id=n6BlVz5QP9kC&pg=PA321&lpg=PA321&dq=election+to+salvation&source=web&ots=LqPEXrPo1f&sig=UX3ah9P4dKKoZ0u0DvOd1MH7atU&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=6&ct=result#PPA331,M1
ACTS 17:11-"...IN THAT THEY RECEIVED THE WORD WITH ALL READINESS OF MIND, AND SEARCHED THE SCRIPTURES DAILY, WHETHER THOSE THINGS WERE SO."
Oct 5, 2008
Spurgeon on Election
"But there are some who say, "It is hard for God to choose some and leave others." Now, I will ask you one question. Is there any of you here this morning who wishes to be holy, who wishes to be regenerate, to leave off sin and walk in holiness? "Yes, there is," says someone, "I do." Then God has elected you. But another says, "No. I don't want to be holy. I don't want to give up my lusts and my vices." Why should you grumble, then, that God has not elected you?"
"If you love religion, He has chosen you to it. If you desire it, He has chosen you to it. If you do not, what right have you to say that God ought to have given you what you do not wish for?"
"If you believe them to be good and desire them, they are there for you. God gives liberally to all those who desire--but first of all He makes them desire--otherwise they never would."
"Then the decree of election could not have been formed upon good works. "But," say others, "God elected them on the foresight of their faith." Now, God gives faith, therefore He could not have elected them on account of faith which He foresaw. There shall be twenty beggards in the street and I determine to give one of them a shilling. Will anyone say that I determined to give that one a shilling—that I elected him to have the shilling—because I foresaw that he would have it? That would be talking nonsense."
"In like manner to say that God elected men because He foresaw they would have faith—which is salvation in the germ—would be too absurd for us to listen to for a moment. Faith is the gift of God. Every virtue comes from Him. Therefore it cannot have caused Him to elect men, because it is His gift. Election, we are sure, is absolute and altogether apart from the virtues which the saints have afterwards."
"I never knew a saint yet of any denomination who thought that God saved him because He foresaw that he would have these virtues and merits."
"I tell you there have been thousands of men who have been ruined by misunderstanding election—who have said, “God has elected me to Heaven and to eternal life”—but they have forgotten that it is written, God has elected them “through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the Truth.” This is God’s election—election to sanctification and to faith. God chooses His people to be holy and to be believers." (UNCONDITIONAL ELECTION - NO. 41-42)
"If you love religion, He has chosen you to it. If you desire it, He has chosen you to it. If you do not, what right have you to say that God ought to have given you what you do not wish for?"
"If you believe them to be good and desire them, they are there for you. God gives liberally to all those who desire--but first of all He makes them desire--otherwise they never would."
"Then the decree of election could not have been formed upon good works. "But," say others, "God elected them on the foresight of their faith." Now, God gives faith, therefore He could not have elected them on account of faith which He foresaw. There shall be twenty beggards in the street and I determine to give one of them a shilling. Will anyone say that I determined to give that one a shilling—that I elected him to have the shilling—because I foresaw that he would have it? That would be talking nonsense."
"In like manner to say that God elected men because He foresaw they would have faith—which is salvation in the germ—would be too absurd for us to listen to for a moment. Faith is the gift of God. Every virtue comes from Him. Therefore it cannot have caused Him to elect men, because it is His gift. Election, we are sure, is absolute and altogether apart from the virtues which the saints have afterwards."
"I never knew a saint yet of any denomination who thought that God saved him because He foresaw that he would have these virtues and merits."
"I tell you there have been thousands of men who have been ruined by misunderstanding election—who have said, “God has elected me to Heaven and to eternal life”—but they have forgotten that it is written, God has elected them “through sanctification of the Spirit and belief of the Truth.” This is God’s election—election to sanctification and to faith. God chooses His people to be holy and to be believers." (UNCONDITIONAL ELECTION - NO. 41-42)
Gowens on Faith
Hardshell Elder and pastor (Lexington Primitive Baptist Church), Michael L. Gowens, wrote:
"I do believe that all who are regenerated will and do have faith, but deny that the "faith" -- that is, the believing response to God -- is in all cases "cognitive" or "informed" faith -- for cognitive faith necessarily depends on hearing the rational proclamation of the gospel; rather, I do not hesitate to affirm that it is, in all cases, below the level of consciousness -- Lazarus-like, the sinner responds believingly to Christ in response to His Divine fiat in regeneration, being made willing in the day of His power, believing according to the working of His mighty power, and coming to Christ in "vital" relationship (Ps. 110:3; Eph. 2:8; Eph. 1:19; Jno. 6:37, 44). Cognitive faith is indeed present in some, but the gift of faith is present in all of God's children; hence, I concur that no one goes to heaven without faith, but deny that no one goes to heaven without rational knowledge of the truth."
Is this not a bunch of nonsense and wholly against scripture? Where is there any semblance of scriptural authority for saying that "faith" may be non cognitive and subconscious? Where, in the bible, is faith disconnected with knowledge? How can one believe in Christ without knowledge? Without the gospel? Without cognition? Without the mind and thoughts? Without information?
How can one be "made willing" without cognition? Without the mind? Unconsciously?
How can one "believe" without thought? Unconsciously?
Besides, notice how Gowens contradicts himself. How so? All Hardshells will argue, on the one hand, that "infants" and "idiots" are "not capable of having faith," and then say, on the other hand, that all the regenerated have faith! What is his avenue of attempted escape from his dilemma?
He so waters down the words "faith" and "believe" and "willing" so as to make them mean absolutely nothing concrete or specific, or anything akin to what the words actually and obviously mean, and puts in their place metaphysical, nonsensible, abnormal, and meaningless "definitions" to those words. The bible can be made to mean anything if one can give such strange abnormal meanings to words!
Did you see any scripture cited by Gowens to prove his definitions?
He writes further:
"A teaching does indeed take place in the new birth, for God teaches the heart directly and immediately to know Him (Jno. 6:65). Cognitive faith, however, must necessarily come after this initial work of grace in the soul, for it depends on the instrumentality of the preached word."
If I were to debate Gowens, or one like him, I would "hold his feet to the fire" on the above statement! I would also show how all that Gowens says is simply "doubletalk." Does a man have to have faith to be saved? What is Gowen's position? Yes, in one sense, no in another!
Where is the scripture that distinguishes between cognitive and non cognitive faith? I know it speaks of genuine versus false faith, of living versus dead faith, but where does it speak of conscious versus unconscious faith? A faith that requires knowledge, and a faith that does not?
What is it that the regenerated soul is "taught" by God? How can a man be "taught" without his cognition? Without knowledge?
This is laughable! Makes me ashamed to have been associated with such ignorance.
He says further:
"Obviously, if such cognitive (or evangelical) faith is necessary to eternal salvation, then every infant who dies in infancy and every individual without average mental capacities would miss salvation. But my position -- i.e. the position that defines "saving faith" (if I must use the term) as that faith that is given to the soul in the work of regeneration -- is adequate to include every potential case in which a person is in need of salvation."
Notice the "doubletalk" of Gowens! The infant can't have faith, but then he must have faith, and can have faith, but only if we "water down" the meaning of "faith" so that it means some nondescript, mystical, and indefineable thing. Again, where is the scripture that says "faith" and "willing" can be "defined" in such a manner?
He writes further:
"By the same token, I do believe that the ultimate evidence that a person possesses salvation is an evangelical faith in the Lord Jesus Christ -- a faith that expresses itself in voluntary obedience to Christ. Where such faith in the Lord Jesus Christ is present, a person gives indisputable evidence of salvation."
Will Gowens give us some scripture that defines "faith" in a non evangelical, in a non cognitive, in a non conscious, way?
He writes further:
"Does Scripture, in fact, apply truth experientially? Yes, indeed. Consider, for instance, the publican in Luke 18— a passage in which the Lord Jesus, Himself, defined the doctrine of “justification by faith”. Did the publican go to the temple to pray in a state of spiritual death and return a regenerate man? No, he went a burdened sinner who needed assurance, and he went home “justified by faith”, that is, with peace in his conscience that God had propitiated and pardoned his sins by His free and amazing grace (Lk. 18:9-14). Indeed, the very purpose of the gospel is to deliver such burdened souls from the pain of a guilty conscience." ("Temporal Salvation A Bogus or Biblical Concept?")
http://www.pbpage.org/TimeSalvation.pdf
Notice how Gowens, like all Hardshells, do not understand "justification by faith." In fact, I will show in a future series on "Hardshells and Justification," how they see justification only as what is experienced outside of time, in eternity, and thus make the experience of being justified by faith to be unconnected with eternal salvation.
No, the publican was not born again, saved, nor justified before he went into the temple to pray, to find forgiveness through God's propitiatory sacrifice. Gowens sees Jesus' statement - "he left justified" as having nothing to do with the publican's eternal salvation. Absurd.
"I do believe that all who are regenerated will and do have faith, but deny that the "faith" -- that is, the believing response to God -- is in all cases "cognitive" or "informed" faith -- for cognitive faith necessarily depends on hearing the rational proclamation of the gospel; rather, I do not hesitate to affirm that it is, in all cases, below the level of consciousness -- Lazarus-like, the sinner responds believingly to Christ in response to His Divine fiat in regeneration, being made willing in the day of His power, believing according to the working of His mighty power, and coming to Christ in "vital" relationship (Ps. 110:3; Eph. 2:8; Eph. 1:19; Jno. 6:37, 44). Cognitive faith is indeed present in some, but the gift of faith is present in all of God's children; hence, I concur that no one goes to heaven without faith, but deny that no one goes to heaven without rational knowledge of the truth."
Is this not a bunch of nonsense and wholly against scripture? Where is there any semblance of scriptural authority for saying that "faith" may be non cognitive and subconscious? Where, in the bible, is faith disconnected with knowledge? How can one believe in Christ without knowledge? Without the gospel? Without cognition? Without the mind and thoughts? Without information?
How can one be "made willing" without cognition? Without the mind? Unconsciously?
How can one "believe" without thought? Unconsciously?
Besides, notice how Gowens contradicts himself. How so? All Hardshells will argue, on the one hand, that "infants" and "idiots" are "not capable of having faith," and then say, on the other hand, that all the regenerated have faith! What is his avenue of attempted escape from his dilemma?
He so waters down the words "faith" and "believe" and "willing" so as to make them mean absolutely nothing concrete or specific, or anything akin to what the words actually and obviously mean, and puts in their place metaphysical, nonsensible, abnormal, and meaningless "definitions" to those words. The bible can be made to mean anything if one can give such strange abnormal meanings to words!
Did you see any scripture cited by Gowens to prove his definitions?
He writes further:
"A teaching does indeed take place in the new birth, for God teaches the heart directly and immediately to know Him (Jno. 6:65). Cognitive faith, however, must necessarily come after this initial work of grace in the soul, for it depends on the instrumentality of the preached word."
If I were to debate Gowens, or one like him, I would "hold his feet to the fire" on the above statement! I would also show how all that Gowens says is simply "doubletalk." Does a man have to have faith to be saved? What is Gowen's position? Yes, in one sense, no in another!
Where is the scripture that distinguishes between cognitive and non cognitive faith? I know it speaks of genuine versus false faith, of living versus dead faith, but where does it speak of conscious versus unconscious faith? A faith that requires knowledge, and a faith that does not?
What is it that the regenerated soul is "taught" by God? How can a man be "taught" without his cognition? Without knowledge?
This is laughable! Makes me ashamed to have been associated with such ignorance.
He says further:
"Obviously, if such cognitive (or evangelical) faith is necessary to eternal salvation, then every infant who dies in infancy and every individual without average mental capacities would miss salvation. But my position -- i.e. the position that defines "saving faith" (if I must use the term) as that faith that is given to the soul in the work of regeneration -- is adequate to include every potential case in which a person is in need of salvation."
Notice the "doubletalk" of Gowens! The infant can't have faith, but then he must have faith, and can have faith, but only if we "water down" the meaning of "faith" so that it means some nondescript, mystical, and indefineable thing. Again, where is the scripture that says "faith" and "willing" can be "defined" in such a manner?
He writes further:
"By the same token, I do believe that the ultimate evidence that a person possesses salvation is an evangelical faith in the Lord Jesus Christ -- a faith that expresses itself in voluntary obedience to Christ. Where such faith in the Lord Jesus Christ is present, a person gives indisputable evidence of salvation."
Will Gowens give us some scripture that defines "faith" in a non evangelical, in a non cognitive, in a non conscious, way?
He writes further:
"Does Scripture, in fact, apply truth experientially? Yes, indeed. Consider, for instance, the publican in Luke 18— a passage in which the Lord Jesus, Himself, defined the doctrine of “justification by faith”. Did the publican go to the temple to pray in a state of spiritual death and return a regenerate man? No, he went a burdened sinner who needed assurance, and he went home “justified by faith”, that is, with peace in his conscience that God had propitiated and pardoned his sins by His free and amazing grace (Lk. 18:9-14). Indeed, the very purpose of the gospel is to deliver such burdened souls from the pain of a guilty conscience." ("Temporal Salvation A Bogus or Biblical Concept?")
http://www.pbpage.org/TimeSalvation.pdf
Notice how Gowens, like all Hardshells, do not understand "justification by faith." In fact, I will show in a future series on "Hardshells and Justification," how they see justification only as what is experienced outside of time, in eternity, and thus make the experience of being justified by faith to be unconnected with eternal salvation.
No, the publican was not born again, saved, nor justified before he went into the temple to pray, to find forgiveness through God's propitiatory sacrifice. Gowens sees Jesus' statement - "he left justified" as having nothing to do with the publican's eternal salvation. Absurd.
Dagg on Regeneration
"Faith is necessary to the Christian character; and must therefore precede regeneration, when this is understood in its widest sense. Even in the restricted sense, in which it denotes the beginning of the spiritual life, faith, in the sense in which James uses the term, may precede. But a faith which exists before the beginning of spiritual life, cannot be a living faith. Yet some have maintained that faith produces love. This opinion is of sufficient importance to demand a careful consideration." ("Manuel of Theology" _ Section IV - "Regeneration")
http://www.freegrace.net/library/dagg/bk7c3.html#sec4
I take Dagg to mean that when a man is born again he is at that moment possessed of a living faith, and that a man cannot be said to be regenerate who is still impenitent and unbelieving.
http://www.freegrace.net/library/dagg/bk7c3.html#sec4
I take Dagg to mean that when a man is born again he is at that moment possessed of a living faith, and that a man cannot be said to be regenerate who is still impenitent and unbelieving.
God Wants All Saved? (cont.)
"This is a faithful saying, and worthy of all acceptation, that Christ Jesus came into the world to save sinners; of whom I am chief...I exhort therefore, that, first of all, supplications, prayers, intercessions, and giving of thanks, be made for all men; For kings, and for all that are in authority; that we may lead a quiet and peaceable life in all godliness and honesty. For this is good and acceptable in the sight of God our Saviour; Who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth. For there is one God, and one mediator between God and men, the man Christ Jesus; Who gave himself a ransom for all, to be testified in due time." (I Timothy 1:15; 2: 1-6 KJV)
If you recall from my initial posting, Spurgeon said this on the above passage:
Spurgeon said:
"You must, most of you, be acquainted with the general method in which our older Calvinistic friends deal with this text. "All men," say they, - "that is, some men": as if the Holy Ghost could not have said "some men" if he had meant some men. "All men," say they; "that is, some of all sorts of men": as if the Lord could not have said "all sorts of men" if he had meant that. The Holy Ghost by the apostle has written "all men," and unquestionably he means all men. I know how to get rid of the force of the "alls" according to that critical method which some time ago was very current, but I do not see how it can be applied here with due regard to truth. I was reading just now the exposition of a very able doctor who explains the text so as to explain it away; he applies grammatical gunpowder to it, and explodes it by way of expounding it. I thought when I read his exposition that it would have been a very capital comment upon the text if it had read, "Who will not have all men to be saved, nor come to a knowledge of the truth." Had such been the inspired language every remark of the learned doctor would have been exactly in keeping, but as it happens to say, "who will have all men to be saved," his observations are more than a little out of place. My love of consistency with my own doctrinal views is not great enough to allow me knowingly to alter a single text of Scripture. I have great respect for orthodoxy, but my reverence for inspiration is far greater. I would sooner a hundred times over appear to be inconsistent with myself than be inconsistent with the Word of God. I never thought it to be any very great crime to seem to be inconsistent with myself, for whom am I that I should everlastingly be consistent? But I do think it a great crime to be so inconsistent with the Word of God that I should want to lop away a bough or even a twig from so much as a single tree of the forest of Scripture. God forbid that I should cut or shape, even in the least degree, any divine expression. So runs the text, and so we must read it, "God our Savior; who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth." (Metropolitan Tabernacle Pulpit, Vol. 26, Pilgrim Publications, p.50.)
I agree with Spurgeon. These words have respect to every man. The "all men" in chapter two is the same as in chapter one. If the gospel is "worthy of acceptation by all men," then it is the same all men for whom God has willed or desired salvation. If we say "all men" in chapter two means "all kinds" of men, that is, merely "some" men, then is the gospel worthy of acceptation by simply "all kinds" of men, by only some men?
We know that Spurgeon felt like the "all men" meant every sinner, at least in relation to God's willing that each come to salvation and to a belief of truth. We know that he did not favor the interpretation that made "all men" to mean, in the end, only "some" men. The big question, one he did not address in the sermon from which his words are cited, is however - "did he also believe it was wrong to interpret 'all men' in the words 'gave himself a ransom for all' as 'all sorts' or 'all kinds' of men?"
In other sermons of Spurgeon, on this particular verse, Spurgeon had no qualms about making "all men" to mean "all sorts" or "all kinds" of men, meaning, in effect, only believers, or only the elect, or only "some" men. Was he inconsistent? Am I?
When the apostle says that there is one meditor between God and "men," does he mean "all men"? Secondly, when he says "there IS" such a mediator and savior, does he mean that Christ is ACTUALLY the mediator and savior of all men? Equally so in every respect? Or, does he simply say that there is one mediator and savior named and appointed of God? One mediator provided?
Two "ends" are mentioned in the passage.
1. Salvation (being ransomed, being reconciled)
2. Belief of the truth.
Christ is seen as:
1. Savior
2. Mediator
3. Ransomer/Redeemer
"For therefore we both labour and suffer reproach, because we trust in the living God, who is the Saviour of all men, specially of those that believe." (II Timothy 4: 10 KJV)
This is a key verse that helps to understand how Christ can be the savior, lord, mediator, redeemer, etc., of all men, in one sense, and yet not so in another sense. He can be all these things narrowly for some, but more broadly so for others. That is, Christ is savior, lord, mediator, redeemer, etc., of all men, but specially, chiefly, or particularly, of believers, of the foreknown, chosen, and predestined. Thus too,
Christ is the "head of every man" (I Cor. 11: 3) but specially the "head" of those who believe, or of the elect, of the church. And,
Christ is the "lord" of every man (Phil. 2: 11), but specially of the elect. And,
Christ is the "mediator" and "savior" of every man, but specially of the elect.
We might add: He is the Lover, benefactor, maker, teacher, and caretaker of every man, but specially of the elect.
How could we possibly deny that it is the will of God for all men to believe the truth about Christ?
God desires that all be saved, but specially desires the elect to be saved. God wills for all to believe and obey the gospel, but specially desires the elect to believe and obey. God has generally provided Christ as a Savior, but particulary for the elect.
He "draws" all men ordinarily, but the elect he draws extraordinarily. He invites all, but specially invites the elect. He is gracious to all, but especially gracious to the elect.
We can see this "specialness" illustrated in the benevolence of Boaz towards the poor. For the poor in general he left, in his fields, "common portions," but for his specially loved, for Ruth, Boaz dispensed or provided a "worthy portion," a greater blessing and favor.
But, all this being said, how can Christ have given himself a "ransom for all"? How does this square with his words about giving his life "a ransom for many"? How can "all" mean "many"? How can "many" mean "all"?
Also, is there a sense in which Christ, even in a limited way, may be said to have been "given a ransom for" even the unbeliever?
Is there a sense in which Christ may be said to have redeemed the race, as a race, yet without intending that every single member of the race is redeemed?
Consider also the possibility that Christ could have actually ransomed every man from original sin merely, but for the elect, he included their personal sins. In such a case, we could well say - "he ransomed all, specially the elect."
Another way in which Christ may be said to ransom all men, in an inferior and limited manner, is in his being made "sufficient" for the redemption of all.
Besides, as Spurgeon and many other Calvinists have pointed out, the point in this, and similar passages, is to affirm that God has not "discriminated" in his provision of Christ, not restricting such provision to any particular class of men, nor basing it upon natural distinctions. It is not denying that God has especially willed the salvation of some, only that he has generally willed the salvation of the world. Even Arminians agree with this. Do they not say that Christ is especially the Savior, Redeemer, and Mediator of believers? Do they not believe that God wills and desires their salvation in a way he does not the unbeliever?
Did God provide the Passover lamb for every member of Israel? Yea, even for Egyptians? Did all make use of the provision by applying the blood to the doors of their houses and avoid being destroyed? Was the blood of the Passover lamb a "ransom" for all or not? Provisionally, yes, but effectively no.
Now let us take the word "purchase" and use it instead of the words "ransom" or "redeem."
"But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction." (II Peter 2:1 KJV)
On this verse John Gill wrote:
"...just as Moses aggravates the ingratitude of the Jews in De 32:6 from whence this phrase is borrowed, and to which it manifestly refers: "do ye thus requite the Lord, O foolish people and unwise! is not he thy Father that hath bought thee? hath he not made thee, and established thee?" nor is this the only place the apostle refers to in this chapter, see 2 Pe 2:12 compared with De 32:5 and it is to be observed, that the persons he writes to were Jews, who were called the people the Lord had redeemed and purchased, Ex 15:13 and so were the first false teachers that rose up among them; and therefore this phrase is very applicable to them." (Commentary)
He also wrote, in regard to whom is meant by the "Lord" that bought them:
"...not the Lord Jesus Christ, but God the Father; for the word kuriov is not here used, which always is where Christ is spoken of as the Lord, but despothv; and which is expressive of the power which masters have over their servants, and which God has over all mankind; and wherever this word is elsewhere used, it is spoken of God the Father, whenever applied to a divine person, as in Lu 2:29 and especially this appears to be the sense, from the parallel text in Jude 1:4 where the Lord God denied by those men is manifestly distinguished from our Lord Jesus Christ, and by whom these persons are said to be bought: the meaning is not that they were redeemed by the blood of Christ, for Christ is not intended; and besides, whenever redemption by Christ is spoken of, the price is usually mentioned, or some circumstance or another which fully determines the sense." (ibid)
So, this verse, though used by the universal atonement advocates, in an attempt to prove that Christ died equally for the reprobate as well as for the elect, does not even refer to the death of Christ or to his atonement. It rather is referring to the "purchase" of the Jews from Egyptian bondage. Every Jew was "purchased" and "owned" by Jehovah.
"For none of us liveth to himself, and no man dieth to himself. For whether we live, we live unto the Lord; and whether we die, we die unto the Lord: whether we live therefore, or die, we are the Lord's. For to this end Christ both died, and rose, and revived, that he might be LORD both of the dead and living." (Romans 14: 7-9 KJV)
This is a better verse to show that Christ, in some sense, bought or purchased all men. By his purchase of them, through his victorious death, he became "Lord" and "Christ," what he was not before, as respects his humanity.
Christ "bought" even the wicked, unbelieving, non elect. That is what these verses say. But, do we say that this "purchasing" of the non elect was in every way equal to the "purchasing" of believers, of the elect?
Is this "purchasing" in relation to salvation? Did Christ not purchase not only "all men" but "all things" by his victory?
"Therefore let all the house of Israel know assuredly, that God hath made the same Jesus, whom ye have crucified, both Lord and Christ." (Acts 2: 36 KJV)
"The word which God sent unto the children of Israel, preaching peace by Jesus Christ: (he is Lord of all)." (Acts 10: 36 KJV)
"I charge thee therefore before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall judge the quick and the dead at his appearing and his kingdom." (II Timothy 4: 1 KJV)
"For we do not preach ourselves, but Jesus Christ as Lord, and ourselves as your servants for Jesus' sake." (II Corinthians 4: 5 NIV)
"Therefore God exalted him to the highest place and gave him the name that is above every name, that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father." (Philippians 2: 9-11 NIV)
"So then, just as you received Christ Jesus as Lord, continue to live in him." (Colossians 2: 6 NIV)
All these verses demonstrate that Christ became "Lord," that is, he became the owner, possessor, ruler, judge, and disposer of all men and all things. All things, and all men, thus "belong" to the Mediator, to "the man Christ Jesus." They also demonstrate how Christ, as I said, can be the "Lord of all men, specially of those who believe."
"The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance." (II Peter 3: 9 KJV)
This is similar to the words of Paul in I Timothy 2.
In the words of Paul we have it positively stated - God desires the salvation of all men. Peter states the same thing, but in a negative form as well as the positive, saying not only that God is "willing" that all come to repentance, but that God is "not willing that any should perish."
And, both Paul's and Peter's words echo the words of God to Ezekiel.
"For I have no pleasure in the death of him that dieth, saith the Lord GOD: wherefore turn yourselves, and live ye." (Ezekiel 18: 32 KJV)
"Say unto them, As I live, saith the Lord GOD, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live: turn ye, turn ye from your evil ways; for why will ye die, O house of Israel?" (Ezekiel 33: 11 KJV)
All these verses are supposed to deny the bible doctrine of sovereign, gracious, and unconditional election of some to salvation. Do they? If they do not, how can they be shown to accord with the bible doctrine?
To speak as succinct as possible, the verses simply state that God is not an evil God who enjoys damning and destroying souls. Among the Pagan pantheon of "gods" and "goddesses," there were "evil" gods and goddesses, and "good" and benevolent ones, at least in their attitudes towards mankind. Some were so evil and malignant that they were unmerciful and without forgiveness.
Yes, Lord God does damn and destroy souls. The bible is clear about that. But, does he enjoy it? It is in accord with his benevolence? Does God delight in the death, destruction, and eternal damnation of the sinner, as an end in itself? Does the event itself please God? Does it make him rejoice? Absolutely not! However, this does not mean that God is not pleased, in any sense, with the sinner's destruction.
God wills the salvation of all men generally and commonly, or ordinarily, but especially wills the salvation of the elect.
Will means much the same thing as desire, pleasure, want, but also may mean purpose or intention; it may also denote what is hidden or what is private, or what is open and stated, or that which is ulterior, or unstated and unrevealed.
"Even as the Son of man came not to be ministered unto, but to minister, and to give his life a ransom for many." (Matthew 20: 28 & Mark 10: 45 KJV)
How do we reconcile "ransom for all" versus "ransom for many"?
Besides, "all men" means not all men absolutely, but simply all men "without distinction," or "without partiality" or "without discrimination" or without respect to ethnicity, nationality, race, or culture. If it meant all men absolutely, then Christ would be dying for Pharoah and Esau, men who had already died and gone to Hell, which would be a reductio ad absurdum.
Add to this consideration, applicable to Arminians, both to those who accept, and to those who deny, the doctrine of original sin.
If "all men" = "every single human being," then this must include the following peoples:
1. Infants
A. If we say that they were "ransomed" from sin by the death of Christ, then we are affirming that they are sinners.
B. If we say that they were ransomed and yet are not sinners, then we have a problem. Many Arminians will revise their definition of "all men" and make it to equal to, not every single human, but every sinner. But, is the whole world sinful? Not to those Arminians who believe in "infantile purity."
2. The damned in Hell at the time of Christ's death.
3. Judas, whom the Lord foreknew would betray him, commit suicide, and die lost.
4. Those who never had the means of salvation (the gospel or word of God).
Here are some deeper questions.
1. Is God conflicted in his will?
2. Was Christ in his human nature conflicted between his will as a man and his will as God?
3. Did Christ will for more to be saved than the Father willed?
4. Does God discriminate in salvation?
Besides, both Arminians and Calvinists both agree that "for all" means "for all who believe." It is "for all" potentially, but only "for believers" actually.
If you recall from my initial posting, Spurgeon said this on the above passage:
Spurgeon said:
"You must, most of you, be acquainted with the general method in which our older Calvinistic friends deal with this text. "All men," say they, - "that is, some men": as if the Holy Ghost could not have said "some men" if he had meant some men. "All men," say they; "that is, some of all sorts of men": as if the Lord could not have said "all sorts of men" if he had meant that. The Holy Ghost by the apostle has written "all men," and unquestionably he means all men. I know how to get rid of the force of the "alls" according to that critical method which some time ago was very current, but I do not see how it can be applied here with due regard to truth. I was reading just now the exposition of a very able doctor who explains the text so as to explain it away; he applies grammatical gunpowder to it, and explodes it by way of expounding it. I thought when I read his exposition that it would have been a very capital comment upon the text if it had read, "Who will not have all men to be saved, nor come to a knowledge of the truth." Had such been the inspired language every remark of the learned doctor would have been exactly in keeping, but as it happens to say, "who will have all men to be saved," his observations are more than a little out of place. My love of consistency with my own doctrinal views is not great enough to allow me knowingly to alter a single text of Scripture. I have great respect for orthodoxy, but my reverence for inspiration is far greater. I would sooner a hundred times over appear to be inconsistent with myself than be inconsistent with the Word of God. I never thought it to be any very great crime to seem to be inconsistent with myself, for whom am I that I should everlastingly be consistent? But I do think it a great crime to be so inconsistent with the Word of God that I should want to lop away a bough or even a twig from so much as a single tree of the forest of Scripture. God forbid that I should cut or shape, even in the least degree, any divine expression. So runs the text, and so we must read it, "God our Savior; who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth." (Metropolitan Tabernacle Pulpit, Vol. 26, Pilgrim Publications, p.50.)
I agree with Spurgeon. These words have respect to every man. The "all men" in chapter two is the same as in chapter one. If the gospel is "worthy of acceptation by all men," then it is the same all men for whom God has willed or desired salvation. If we say "all men" in chapter two means "all kinds" of men, that is, merely "some" men, then is the gospel worthy of acceptation by simply "all kinds" of men, by only some men?
We know that Spurgeon felt like the "all men" meant every sinner, at least in relation to God's willing that each come to salvation and to a belief of truth. We know that he did not favor the interpretation that made "all men" to mean, in the end, only "some" men. The big question, one he did not address in the sermon from which his words are cited, is however - "did he also believe it was wrong to interpret 'all men' in the words 'gave himself a ransom for all' as 'all sorts' or 'all kinds' of men?"
In other sermons of Spurgeon, on this particular verse, Spurgeon had no qualms about making "all men" to mean "all sorts" or "all kinds" of men, meaning, in effect, only believers, or only the elect, or only "some" men. Was he inconsistent? Am I?
When the apostle says that there is one meditor between God and "men," does he mean "all men"? Secondly, when he says "there IS" such a mediator and savior, does he mean that Christ is ACTUALLY the mediator and savior of all men? Equally so in every respect? Or, does he simply say that there is one mediator and savior named and appointed of God? One mediator provided?
Two "ends" are mentioned in the passage.
1. Salvation (being ransomed, being reconciled)
2. Belief of the truth.
Christ is seen as:
1. Savior
2. Mediator
3. Ransomer/Redeemer
"For therefore we both labour and suffer reproach, because we trust in the living God, who is the Saviour of all men, specially of those that believe." (II Timothy 4: 10 KJV)
This is a key verse that helps to understand how Christ can be the savior, lord, mediator, redeemer, etc., of all men, in one sense, and yet not so in another sense. He can be all these things narrowly for some, but more broadly so for others. That is, Christ is savior, lord, mediator, redeemer, etc., of all men, but specially, chiefly, or particularly, of believers, of the foreknown, chosen, and predestined. Thus too,
Christ is the "head of every man" (I Cor. 11: 3) but specially the "head" of those who believe, or of the elect, of the church. And,
Christ is the "lord" of every man (Phil. 2: 11), but specially of the elect. And,
Christ is the "mediator" and "savior" of every man, but specially of the elect.
We might add: He is the Lover, benefactor, maker, teacher, and caretaker of every man, but specially of the elect.
How could we possibly deny that it is the will of God for all men to believe the truth about Christ?
God desires that all be saved, but specially desires the elect to be saved. God wills for all to believe and obey the gospel, but specially desires the elect to believe and obey. God has generally provided Christ as a Savior, but particulary for the elect.
He "draws" all men ordinarily, but the elect he draws extraordinarily. He invites all, but specially invites the elect. He is gracious to all, but especially gracious to the elect.
We can see this "specialness" illustrated in the benevolence of Boaz towards the poor. For the poor in general he left, in his fields, "common portions," but for his specially loved, for Ruth, Boaz dispensed or provided a "worthy portion," a greater blessing and favor.
But, all this being said, how can Christ have given himself a "ransom for all"? How does this square with his words about giving his life "a ransom for many"? How can "all" mean "many"? How can "many" mean "all"?
Also, is there a sense in which Christ, even in a limited way, may be said to have been "given a ransom for" even the unbeliever?
Is there a sense in which Christ may be said to have redeemed the race, as a race, yet without intending that every single member of the race is redeemed?
Consider also the possibility that Christ could have actually ransomed every man from original sin merely, but for the elect, he included their personal sins. In such a case, we could well say - "he ransomed all, specially the elect."
Another way in which Christ may be said to ransom all men, in an inferior and limited manner, is in his being made "sufficient" for the redemption of all.
Besides, as Spurgeon and many other Calvinists have pointed out, the point in this, and similar passages, is to affirm that God has not "discriminated" in his provision of Christ, not restricting such provision to any particular class of men, nor basing it upon natural distinctions. It is not denying that God has especially willed the salvation of some, only that he has generally willed the salvation of the world. Even Arminians agree with this. Do they not say that Christ is especially the Savior, Redeemer, and Mediator of believers? Do they not believe that God wills and desires their salvation in a way he does not the unbeliever?
Did God provide the Passover lamb for every member of Israel? Yea, even for Egyptians? Did all make use of the provision by applying the blood to the doors of their houses and avoid being destroyed? Was the blood of the Passover lamb a "ransom" for all or not? Provisionally, yes, but effectively no.
Now let us take the word "purchase" and use it instead of the words "ransom" or "redeem."
"But there were false prophets also among the people, even as there shall be false teachers among you, who privily shall bring in damnable heresies, even denying the Lord that bought them, and bring upon themselves swift destruction." (II Peter 2:1 KJV)
On this verse John Gill wrote:
"...just as Moses aggravates the ingratitude of the Jews in De 32:6 from whence this phrase is borrowed, and to which it manifestly refers: "do ye thus requite the Lord, O foolish people and unwise! is not he thy Father that hath bought thee? hath he not made thee, and established thee?" nor is this the only place the apostle refers to in this chapter, see 2 Pe 2:12 compared with De 32:5 and it is to be observed, that the persons he writes to were Jews, who were called the people the Lord had redeemed and purchased, Ex 15:13 and so were the first false teachers that rose up among them; and therefore this phrase is very applicable to them." (Commentary)
He also wrote, in regard to whom is meant by the "Lord" that bought them:
"...not the Lord Jesus Christ, but God the Father; for the word kuriov is not here used, which always is where Christ is spoken of as the Lord, but despothv; and which is expressive of the power which masters have over their servants, and which God has over all mankind; and wherever this word is elsewhere used, it is spoken of God the Father, whenever applied to a divine person, as in Lu 2:29 and especially this appears to be the sense, from the parallel text in Jude 1:4 where the Lord God denied by those men is manifestly distinguished from our Lord Jesus Christ, and by whom these persons are said to be bought: the meaning is not that they were redeemed by the blood of Christ, for Christ is not intended; and besides, whenever redemption by Christ is spoken of, the price is usually mentioned, or some circumstance or another which fully determines the sense." (ibid)
So, this verse, though used by the universal atonement advocates, in an attempt to prove that Christ died equally for the reprobate as well as for the elect, does not even refer to the death of Christ or to his atonement. It rather is referring to the "purchase" of the Jews from Egyptian bondage. Every Jew was "purchased" and "owned" by Jehovah.
"For none of us liveth to himself, and no man dieth to himself. For whether we live, we live unto the Lord; and whether we die, we die unto the Lord: whether we live therefore, or die, we are the Lord's. For to this end Christ both died, and rose, and revived, that he might be LORD both of the dead and living." (Romans 14: 7-9 KJV)
This is a better verse to show that Christ, in some sense, bought or purchased all men. By his purchase of them, through his victorious death, he became "Lord" and "Christ," what he was not before, as respects his humanity.
Christ "bought" even the wicked, unbelieving, non elect. That is what these verses say. But, do we say that this "purchasing" of the non elect was in every way equal to the "purchasing" of believers, of the elect?
Is this "purchasing" in relation to salvation? Did Christ not purchase not only "all men" but "all things" by his victory?
"Therefore let all the house of Israel know assuredly, that God hath made the same Jesus, whom ye have crucified, both Lord and Christ." (Acts 2: 36 KJV)
"The word which God sent unto the children of Israel, preaching peace by Jesus Christ: (he is Lord of all)." (Acts 10: 36 KJV)
"I charge thee therefore before God, and the Lord Jesus Christ, who shall judge the quick and the dead at his appearing and his kingdom." (II Timothy 4: 1 KJV)
"For we do not preach ourselves, but Jesus Christ as Lord, and ourselves as your servants for Jesus' sake." (II Corinthians 4: 5 NIV)
"Therefore God exalted him to the highest place and gave him the name that is above every name, that at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth, and every tongue confess that Jesus Christ is Lord, to the glory of God the Father." (Philippians 2: 9-11 NIV)
"So then, just as you received Christ Jesus as Lord, continue to live in him." (Colossians 2: 6 NIV)
All these verses demonstrate that Christ became "Lord," that is, he became the owner, possessor, ruler, judge, and disposer of all men and all things. All things, and all men, thus "belong" to the Mediator, to "the man Christ Jesus." They also demonstrate how Christ, as I said, can be the "Lord of all men, specially of those who believe."
"The Lord is not slack concerning his promise, as some men count slackness; but is longsuffering to us-ward, not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance." (II Peter 3: 9 KJV)
This is similar to the words of Paul in I Timothy 2.
In the words of Paul we have it positively stated - God desires the salvation of all men. Peter states the same thing, but in a negative form as well as the positive, saying not only that God is "willing" that all come to repentance, but that God is "not willing that any should perish."
And, both Paul's and Peter's words echo the words of God to Ezekiel.
"For I have no pleasure in the death of him that dieth, saith the Lord GOD: wherefore turn yourselves, and live ye." (Ezekiel 18: 32 KJV)
"Say unto them, As I live, saith the Lord GOD, I have no pleasure in the death of the wicked; but that the wicked turn from his way and live: turn ye, turn ye from your evil ways; for why will ye die, O house of Israel?" (Ezekiel 33: 11 KJV)
All these verses are supposed to deny the bible doctrine of sovereign, gracious, and unconditional election of some to salvation. Do they? If they do not, how can they be shown to accord with the bible doctrine?
To speak as succinct as possible, the verses simply state that God is not an evil God who enjoys damning and destroying souls. Among the Pagan pantheon of "gods" and "goddesses," there were "evil" gods and goddesses, and "good" and benevolent ones, at least in their attitudes towards mankind. Some were so evil and malignant that they were unmerciful and without forgiveness.
Yes, Lord God does damn and destroy souls. The bible is clear about that. But, does he enjoy it? It is in accord with his benevolence? Does God delight in the death, destruction, and eternal damnation of the sinner, as an end in itself? Does the event itself please God? Does it make him rejoice? Absolutely not! However, this does not mean that God is not pleased, in any sense, with the sinner's destruction.
God wills the salvation of all men generally and commonly, or ordinarily, but especially wills the salvation of the elect.
Will means much the same thing as desire, pleasure, want, but also may mean purpose or intention; it may also denote what is hidden or what is private, or what is open and stated, or that which is ulterior, or unstated and unrevealed.
"Even as the Son of man came not to be ministered unto, but to minister, and to give his life a ransom for many." (Matthew 20: 28 & Mark 10: 45 KJV)
How do we reconcile "ransom for all" versus "ransom for many"?
Besides, "all men" means not all men absolutely, but simply all men "without distinction," or "without partiality" or "without discrimination" or without respect to ethnicity, nationality, race, or culture. If it meant all men absolutely, then Christ would be dying for Pharoah and Esau, men who had already died and gone to Hell, which would be a reductio ad absurdum.
Add to this consideration, applicable to Arminians, both to those who accept, and to those who deny, the doctrine of original sin.
If "all men" = "every single human being," then this must include the following peoples:
1. Infants
A. If we say that they were "ransomed" from sin by the death of Christ, then we are affirming that they are sinners.
B. If we say that they were ransomed and yet are not sinners, then we have a problem. Many Arminians will revise their definition of "all men" and make it to equal to, not every single human, but every sinner. But, is the whole world sinful? Not to those Arminians who believe in "infantile purity."
2. The damned in Hell at the time of Christ's death.
3. Judas, whom the Lord foreknew would betray him, commit suicide, and die lost.
4. Those who never had the means of salvation (the gospel or word of God).
Here are some deeper questions.
1. Is God conflicted in his will?
2. Was Christ in his human nature conflicted between his will as a man and his will as God?
3. Did Christ will for more to be saved than the Father willed?
4. Does God discriminate in salvation?
Besides, both Arminians and Calvinists both agree that "for all" means "for all who believe." It is "for all" potentially, but only "for believers" actually.
Oct 4, 2008
What Kind of Calvinists?
What kind of Calvinists do Baptists, Southern Baptists, need? What kind do they not need? I believe we need the Spurgeon kind.
The kind we do not need, is this kind:
1. The "wine and cheese" kind, as Adrian Rogers spoke about.
2. The arrogant kind.
3. The elitist kind.
4. The brainish kind.
5. The 'know it all' kind.
6. The intolerant kind.
7. The non-evangelistic kind.
8. The kind that thinks the gospel = Calvinism.
9. The kind that is combative and feisty.
10. The kind that emphasizes conferences over evangelistic meetings.
11. The kind that makes Calvinism into a "hobby horse."
12. The kind that decries hearty evangelistic appeals.
13. The kind that promotes the "born again before faith" error.
14. The kind that is close-minded.
15. The kind that won't preach topically and textually.
16. The kind who are constantly talking about how Baptist churches are mostly unregenerate.
17. The kind who are always talking about "restoring the gospel."
18. The kind who are always suspicious of church growth.
19. The kind who disallow young children from baptism.
20. The kind who belittle decrying pedobaptism and promote Baptists having church fellowship with pedoBaptists.
21. The kind who promote "elder rule" after the pattern of the Presbyterians.
22. The kind who enter privily into churches in an attempt to effect Ernest Reisinger's "quiet reformation."
23. The kind who decry the use of the word "decision" in connection with regeneration and the new birth.
24. The kind who decry teaching sinners to pray the sinner's prayer for salvation.
25. The kind who spend more time making converts, from Arminianism to Calvinism, than to Christ and the simple gospel.
Oh give us Calvinists as Spurgeon!
The kind we do not need, is this kind:
1. The "wine and cheese" kind, as Adrian Rogers spoke about.
2. The arrogant kind.
3. The elitist kind.
4. The brainish kind.
5. The 'know it all' kind.
6. The intolerant kind.
7. The non-evangelistic kind.
8. The kind that thinks the gospel = Calvinism.
9. The kind that is combative and feisty.
10. The kind that emphasizes conferences over evangelistic meetings.
11. The kind that makes Calvinism into a "hobby horse."
12. The kind that decries hearty evangelistic appeals.
13. The kind that promotes the "born again before faith" error.
14. The kind that is close-minded.
15. The kind that won't preach topically and textually.
16. The kind who are constantly talking about how Baptist churches are mostly unregenerate.
17. The kind who are always talking about "restoring the gospel."
18. The kind who are always suspicious of church growth.
19. The kind who disallow young children from baptism.
20. The kind who belittle decrying pedobaptism and promote Baptists having church fellowship with pedoBaptists.
21. The kind who promote "elder rule" after the pattern of the Presbyterians.
22. The kind who enter privily into churches in an attempt to effect Ernest Reisinger's "quiet reformation."
23. The kind who decry the use of the word "decision" in connection with regeneration and the new birth.
24. The kind who decry teaching sinners to pray the sinner's prayer for salvation.
25. The kind who spend more time making converts, from Arminianism to Calvinism, than to Christ and the simple gospel.
Oh give us Calvinists as Spurgeon!
More on BFM & Regeneration
The 1925 BF&M statement is that "regeneration is a work of God's free grace conditioned upon faith in Christ."
Said two writers about the change in wording from the 1925 statement to the one edited and adopted in 1963.
"Interestingly, the 1963 committee made significant changes in the statement--changes that effectively shifted the confession in a more explicitly Reformed direction. In the first place, the committee moved the article so that it precedes repentance and faith in the presentation. That said, this decision (like the decision of the New Hampshire Baptists) may not reflect any specific intention to imply an ordo salutis. But the 1963 committee made another very significant change. Regeneration, described in the 1925 statement as "conditioned upon faith in Christ" is now described as "a change of heart wrought by the Holy Spirit through the conviction of sin, to which the sinner responds in repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ."
What exactly did the committee mean by this change? Herschel H. Hobbs, chairman of the 1963 committee, clearly did not teach regeneration precedes faith. Even after the committee he chaired made the change noted above, Hobbs argued: "Regeneration is the result of conviction of sin, repentance from sin, faith in Jesus Christ, and the confession of that faith." Thus, the confession itself, as revised in 1963, defines regeneration as the event "to which the responds" in faith even as Dr. Hobbs defined regeneration as "the result" of faith. Does the Baptist Faith and Message require a specific order of salvation? Taken as a whole, the paragraphs on salvation attempt to define the doctrine of salvation by looking both backward and forward. A specific ordo salutis cannot be argued too strongly from within the text or the context of the Baptist Faith and Message. As if to make that point, the 2000 committee moved one very strategic sentence ("Regeneration and faith are inseparable experiences of grace.") to end the paragraph on regeneration, rather than to begin the next.
In the 1925 statement, repentance and faith are described as "wrought in our souls by the regenerating spirit of God." E. Y. Mullins, chairman of the 1925 committee, may have expressed this best: "In strict logic regeneration precedes both faith and repentance if we begin with the true Gospel teaching that all is due to the grace of God. Yet here again fact and apparent logic do not necessarily coincide. The correct view is that regeneration and repentance and faith are simultaneous events in the soul's life. No impenitent or unbelieving soul can be a regenerate soul, just as no penitent believer can be unregenerate."
By Douglas K. Blount, Joseph D. Wooddell
http://books.google.com/books?id=VzDwZgOUjfEC&pg=PA41&lpg=PA41&dq=faith+regeneration+ordo&source=web&ots=ch1_bT8QST&sig=4GnEirxIMNi8Qp9-jrPiPOWETo0&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=5&ct=result#PPA54,M1
Said two writers about the change in wording from the 1925 statement to the one edited and adopted in 1963.
"Interestingly, the 1963 committee made significant changes in the statement--changes that effectively shifted the confession in a more explicitly Reformed direction. In the first place, the committee moved the article so that it precedes repentance and faith in the presentation. That said, this decision (like the decision of the New Hampshire Baptists) may not reflect any specific intention to imply an ordo salutis. But the 1963 committee made another very significant change. Regeneration, described in the 1925 statement as "conditioned upon faith in Christ" is now described as "a change of heart wrought by the Holy Spirit through the conviction of sin, to which the sinner responds in repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ."
What exactly did the committee mean by this change? Herschel H. Hobbs, chairman of the 1963 committee, clearly did not teach regeneration precedes faith. Even after the committee he chaired made the change noted above, Hobbs argued: "Regeneration is the result of conviction of sin, repentance from sin, faith in Jesus Christ, and the confession of that faith." Thus, the confession itself, as revised in 1963, defines regeneration as the event "to which the responds" in faith even as Dr. Hobbs defined regeneration as "the result" of faith. Does the Baptist Faith and Message require a specific order of salvation? Taken as a whole, the paragraphs on salvation attempt to define the doctrine of salvation by looking both backward and forward. A specific ordo salutis cannot be argued too strongly from within the text or the context of the Baptist Faith and Message. As if to make that point, the 2000 committee moved one very strategic sentence ("Regeneration and faith are inseparable experiences of grace.") to end the paragraph on regeneration, rather than to begin the next.
In the 1925 statement, repentance and faith are described as "wrought in our souls by the regenerating spirit of God." E. Y. Mullins, chairman of the 1925 committee, may have expressed this best: "In strict logic regeneration precedes both faith and repentance if we begin with the true Gospel teaching that all is due to the grace of God. Yet here again fact and apparent logic do not necessarily coincide. The correct view is that regeneration and repentance and faith are simultaneous events in the soul's life. No impenitent or unbelieving soul can be a regenerate soul, just as no penitent believer can be unregenerate."
By Douglas K. Blount, Joseph D. Wooddell
http://books.google.com/books?id=VzDwZgOUjfEC&pg=PA41&lpg=PA41&dq=faith+regeneration+ordo&source=web&ots=ch1_bT8QST&sig=4GnEirxIMNi8Qp9-jrPiPOWETo0&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=5&ct=result#PPA54,M1
Oct 3, 2008
Regeneration By A. P. Williams
"Regeneration" By A. P. Williams, D.D.
"In these days of religious inquiry and discussion, much is said on almost every subject connected with Christian Theology. Every now and then I meet with something on this subject. I had supposed that it was generally very well understood, both in regard to what it is and the means by which it is produced. But it seems that in this I have been mistaken. There is no uniformity in sentiment here, even among Baptists. Some of our brethren confine the term in its meaning to the very work of the Spirit in the process of conversion, while others extend it so as to include the entire process. The former exclude instrumentality in the work, while the latter recognize the truth as the great instrument employed in effecting it. Now, why this diversity of opinion? Is it because the Bible does not afford sufficient light to clear up the question? Or, is it because we receive our notions from theologians who treat this, as well as every other, subject, as a part of their system, and interpret it to suit?"
"Hence, in his regeneration, man is made alive in every respect in which he can be said to be dead. He is made alive with respect to his heart when the love of God is shed abroad therein by the Holy Ghost. (Romans 5:5.) Hence John says, "We know that we have passed from death unto life, because we love the brethren." He is made alive in law when the sentence of condemnation is revoked. The Apostle says: "If any man be in Christ he is a new creature;" of course, then, regenerated; but "there is no condemnation to them who are in Christ." (Romans 1:8.) I do not see anything in the Scriptures that will justify us in regarding any one as regenerated who is still in his sins and under condemnation. When the work of regeneration is finished the "new man" must stand out before us, and we must be able to say of the sinner, "he was dead but is alive again." Hence I am inclined to the belief that regeneration includes all that God does for us in making us his children. If it does, then it includes more than the mere beginning of the work — more than the mere vitalizing of the affections. It includes also our deliverance from the wrath to come. The whole work is expressed in the following passages of Holy Writ..."
Cambridge, Mo., April, 1866.
http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/pillars.williams.notes.ser.htm
For a bio on Williams, see the following cite with info from Bogard.
http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/williams.a.p.by.bogard.html
"In these days of religious inquiry and discussion, much is said on almost every subject connected with Christian Theology. Every now and then I meet with something on this subject. I had supposed that it was generally very well understood, both in regard to what it is and the means by which it is produced. But it seems that in this I have been mistaken. There is no uniformity in sentiment here, even among Baptists. Some of our brethren confine the term in its meaning to the very work of the Spirit in the process of conversion, while others extend it so as to include the entire process. The former exclude instrumentality in the work, while the latter recognize the truth as the great instrument employed in effecting it. Now, why this diversity of opinion? Is it because the Bible does not afford sufficient light to clear up the question? Or, is it because we receive our notions from theologians who treat this, as well as every other, subject, as a part of their system, and interpret it to suit?"
"Hence, in his regeneration, man is made alive in every respect in which he can be said to be dead. He is made alive with respect to his heart when the love of God is shed abroad therein by the Holy Ghost. (Romans 5:5.) Hence John says, "We know that we have passed from death unto life, because we love the brethren." He is made alive in law when the sentence of condemnation is revoked. The Apostle says: "If any man be in Christ he is a new creature;" of course, then, regenerated; but "there is no condemnation to them who are in Christ." (Romans 1:8.) I do not see anything in the Scriptures that will justify us in regarding any one as regenerated who is still in his sins and under condemnation. When the work of regeneration is finished the "new man" must stand out before us, and we must be able to say of the sinner, "he was dead but is alive again." Hence I am inclined to the belief that regeneration includes all that God does for us in making us his children. If it does, then it includes more than the mere beginning of the work — more than the mere vitalizing of the affections. It includes also our deliverance from the wrath to come. The whole work is expressed in the following passages of Holy Writ..."
Cambridge, Mo., April, 1866.
http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/pillars.williams.notes.ser.htm
For a bio on Williams, see the following cite with info from Bogard.
http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/williams.a.p.by.bogard.html
Old Wine in New Bottles
As I have mentioned before, I have intentions of writing a book titled - "Old Wine in New Bottles" and show how many Christian churches have put "old wine in new bottles" by their mixing Old Covenant laws into the New Covenant.
Here are ten areas where I intend to show that this has happened.
1. Sabbath and holy days
2. Tithing laws
3. Washings
4. Circumcision
5. Dietary laws
6. Ritualism & Ceremonialism (ordered worship, religious images, etc.)
7. Professional priesthood (dress, titles, roles, etc.)
8. Temples (Cathedrals, pompous meeting houses, etc.)
9. Geneologies (apostolic succession, Landmarkism, etc.)
10. Legalism (law keeping for justification, meritorious salvation, etc.)
Some might add others, like capital punishment (I do not, however).
Here are ten areas where I intend to show that this has happened.
1. Sabbath and holy days
2. Tithing laws
3. Washings
4. Circumcision
5. Dietary laws
6. Ritualism & Ceremonialism (ordered worship, religious images, etc.)
7. Professional priesthood (dress, titles, roles, etc.)
8. Temples (Cathedrals, pompous meeting houses, etc.)
9. Geneologies (apostolic succession, Landmarkism, etc.)
10. Legalism (law keeping for justification, meritorious salvation, etc.)
Some might add others, like capital punishment (I do not, however).
Samuel Richardson
I have written much over the past year or two regarding the view that makes the "begetting" different from the "birth," about the three stage model of the new birth. I have shown how the Old Hardshells and Regular Baptists, and some among the Presbyterians, have held to this view. It seems to be an old view. Notice how Samuel Richardson, signer of the First London Confession of Faith, held this view. It does not seem to have been the view of Spilsbury, Kiffin, Knollys, and other signers, however.
Wrote Richardson: (SEE HERE)
"Also consider if thou canst, whether if thou be a babe in the womb, or borne, Heb. 5. 13. He is a babe, as a child is begotten and (Page 71) alive while it is in the womb, before it is borne; so thou may be begotten from above, and alive, before thou canst be borne. Christ must first be formed in us, before we can be new borne babes, Gal. 4. 18. 1 Pet. 2. 2. And when thou art delivered out of the state of bondage, which is a place of darkness, of fears concerning thy soul, thou art not borne and brought forth; and as the womb is a place of bondage, so here; and therefore canst not do that service others do: if thou be but new borne, there cannot that be expected from thee, as there is from a man in Christ; as there is a difference between a child and a man in nature, so there is here; learn to distinguish between the grace it self, and the exercise of it; it's not the having of grace, but the exercise of it, which attains to a holy conversation, by the operation of the Spirit; and when a soul is delivered from its enemies, as Satan, terrors, wrath, curse, it's borne, being delivered we serve, Luk. 1. 47. Deliverance is before working: the time of doubting is a barren time; men cannot fight and work at the same time." (Page 72)
"Regeneration consists in being begotten to the Lord, to have union with him, Joh. 17. 22. 23. 19. And for God to convey his power into the soul, by which it is made conformable to the will of Christ, and lives by faith in the Son of God, Gal. 2. 20, is another thing in some of the Lords: the first is, where the latter is not, at least in the degrees of it; believers are of several growths and states; as, first, babes, children; secondly, young men; thirdly, fathers, 1 Joh. 2. 12, 13. Can babes work? and yet if they die in that estate, they shall not miss of glory. 1 Job. 2. 12. It is one thing to be justified, and another to be sanctified, so it is one thing to live, another to be borne, and to work is distinct from both: there is as much difference between some of the Lords, as there is betwixt willing and doing; some are termed carnal, 1 Cor. 3. 1. others spiritual. Thou may be begotten, but not borne, (if in bondage) and then it is not the season of growing, as another season is. If thou be ignorant, or in temptation, thy understanding is clouded, and thy heart being distempered (Page 73) with fear, so as Job 23. 8, 9. and thou art not fit to judge of thy growth; is a new borne babe, 1 Pet. 2. 2. fit to judge of its growth? Also consider, it may be, thou art in Gods way, and so thou dost not use his means, or not rightly; consider Psal. 1. 3. with Song 4. 12. there thou shall grow."
I do plan to write some separate articles in the near future on this view, showing how unscriptural it is.
Wrote Richardson: (SEE HERE)
"Also consider if thou canst, whether if thou be a babe in the womb, or borne, Heb. 5. 13. He is a babe, as a child is begotten and (Page 71) alive while it is in the womb, before it is borne; so thou may be begotten from above, and alive, before thou canst be borne. Christ must first be formed in us, before we can be new borne babes, Gal. 4. 18. 1 Pet. 2. 2. And when thou art delivered out of the state of bondage, which is a place of darkness, of fears concerning thy soul, thou art not borne and brought forth; and as the womb is a place of bondage, so here; and therefore canst not do that service others do: if thou be but new borne, there cannot that be expected from thee, as there is from a man in Christ; as there is a difference between a child and a man in nature, so there is here; learn to distinguish between the grace it self, and the exercise of it; it's not the having of grace, but the exercise of it, which attains to a holy conversation, by the operation of the Spirit; and when a soul is delivered from its enemies, as Satan, terrors, wrath, curse, it's borne, being delivered we serve, Luk. 1. 47. Deliverance is before working: the time of doubting is a barren time; men cannot fight and work at the same time." (Page 72)
"Regeneration consists in being begotten to the Lord, to have union with him, Joh. 17. 22. 23. 19. And for God to convey his power into the soul, by which it is made conformable to the will of Christ, and lives by faith in the Son of God, Gal. 2. 20, is another thing in some of the Lords: the first is, where the latter is not, at least in the degrees of it; believers are of several growths and states; as, first, babes, children; secondly, young men; thirdly, fathers, 1 Joh. 2. 12, 13. Can babes work? and yet if they die in that estate, they shall not miss of glory. 1 Job. 2. 12. It is one thing to be justified, and another to be sanctified, so it is one thing to live, another to be borne, and to work is distinct from both: there is as much difference between some of the Lords, as there is betwixt willing and doing; some are termed carnal, 1 Cor. 3. 1. others spiritual. Thou may be begotten, but not borne, (if in bondage) and then it is not the season of growing, as another season is. If thou be ignorant, or in temptation, thy understanding is clouded, and thy heart being distempered (Page 73) with fear, so as Job 23. 8, 9. and thou art not fit to judge of thy growth; is a new borne babe, 1 Pet. 2. 2. fit to judge of its growth? Also consider, it may be, thou art in Gods way, and so thou dost not use his means, or not rightly; consider Psal. 1. 3. with Song 4. 12. there thou shall grow."
I do plan to write some separate articles in the near future on this view, showing how unscriptural it is.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)