Oct 2, 2008

Pendleton on Broadus & Phds.

"The Columbian College in 1843 conferred on Elder (Andrew - SG)Broaddus the degree of Doctor of Divinity. He showed his good sense in declining to accept it. With his views of ministerial parity he could not consistently receive it. His brethren had so much respect for his wishes that they never called him Doctor. Such men as Andrew Fuller, Robert Hall, and Andrew Broaddus had not need of D. D. to their names to swell them into consequence. Those who deserve the doctorate (if indeed any do) are the men who do not need it. We would be glad for the title of D.D. to be dispensed with altogether. We think of some denominations — the Methodists particularly — became a little more liberal in bestowing it, the day will come when it will be considered an evidence of literary and theological mediocrity."

("The Life and Writings of Rev. Andrew Broaddus" - Christian Repository, 1852; By Rev. James M. Pendleton Bowling Green, KY)

http://www.geocities.com/baptist_documents/broaddus.andrew.html

Lovers of Titles

Alexander Campbell wrote on this topic. A writer said this about his views (which I have read in the Christian Baptist myself over the past several months, but this is a good excerpt):

"The clergy also "hanker after titles" - the D. D. degree in particular - and when a Baptist clergy friend of his (Andrew Broaddus, I believe, or perhaps Bishop Semple - SG) turned down the honor, Campbell commented: "When the degree was conferred on him, he, like a Christian, declined it." In his "Third Epistle of Peter" -- published in The Christian Baptist in 1824 -- he excoriated the clergy to the point of appearing to be deliberately offensive. He not only charged that the clergy "fleece the flock" for money, but that they feigned to make the people think they cared for their souls while they did it."

http://www.leroygarrett.org/soldieron/number66.htm

I agree with Campbell on this. It has gotten much worse since his day! Men flaunt their titles and their accomplishments, and promote themselves, being like Diotrephes "who loved to have the preeminence among the brethren." (See III John 1:9) They do it to make money, to sell books and influence, etc. Jesus taught us not to advertise ourselves in this manner!

Was Jesus a "man of letters"? No! In fact, his not having "letters" amazed the "degree holders"! (See John 7: 15)

The greatest preachers were men who never went to a seminary. Did any of the apostles, except Paul? Were they not all, by and large, "uneducated and unlettered men"? (See Acts 4: 13)

Did John Gill attend seminary? Did Charles Spurgeon? Need I say more?

I am like the man who said - "I have a Phd., Post Hole Digging." And, as the man who said - "I have a Bsd., Back-Side of Desert" (as Moses).

Also, as far as being a language "exegete," in either Hebrew or Greek, or Aramaic, I can only say with the man who said - "I know a little Hebrew and a little Greek. The little Hebrew I know sells insurance and the little Greek runs a restaurant."

A little less "hubris" would be a great thing to see among the Christian clergy of our day. They have become too "professional."

God Wants All to be Saved?

This is the title of an article I am presently working on completing.

I promised my friend Billy (classicalarminianism.blogspot.com) that I would do so and post it here. He is presently doing some writings on the subject of election and presenting Arminian objections to the Calvinistic doctrine of eternal, personal, and unconditional election. He has raised the question of who is the "all men" of I Tim. 2:1-6? Is it "all classes" or "all kinds" of men, as some Calvinists aver? Or, does "all men" refer to every man without exception?

I take the view of Spurgeon, a five point Calvinist, who believed that the "all men" here did not mean "all kinds" or "classes" but literally "every man."

So, how can this be? If one believes God wills, in some sense, the salvation of all men, and desires that they all believe and obey the truth, and worship him correctly, then how is Spurgeon (or myself, or other Calvinists who agree with him) consistent?

I will post what Spurgeon wrote and follow up this introductory writing with some additional comments upon this seeming inconsistency.

Spurgeon said:

"You must, most of you, be acquainted with the general method in which our older Calvinistic friends deal with this text. "All men," say they, - "that is, some men": as if the Holy Ghost could not have said "some men" if he had meant some men. "All men," say they; "that is, some of all sorts of men": as if the Lord could not have said "all sorts of men" if he had meant that. The Holy Ghost by the apostle has written "all men," and unquestionably he means all men. I know how to get rid of the force of the "alls" according to that critical method which some time ago was very current, but I do not see how it can be applied here with due regard to truth. I was reading just now the exposition of a very able doctor who explains the text so as to explain it away; he applies grammatical gunpowder to it, and explodes it by way of expounding it. I thought when I read his exposition that it would have been a very capital comment upon the text if it had read, "Who will not have all men to be saved, nor come to a knowledge of the truth." Had such been the inspired language every remark of the learned doctor would have been exactly in keeping, but as it happens to say, "who will have all men to be saved," his observations are more than a little out of place. My love of consistency with my own doctrinal views is not great enough to allow me knowingly to alter a single text of Scripture. I have great respect for orthodoxy, but my reverence for inspiration is far greater. I would sooner a hundred times over appear to be inconsistent with myself than be inconsistent with the Word of God. I never thought it to be any very great crime to seem to be inconsistent with myself, for whom am I that I should everlastingly be consistent? But I do think it a great crime to be so inconsistent with the Word of God that I should want to lop away a bough or even a twig from so much as a single tree of the forest of Scripture. God forbid that I should cut or shape, even in the least degree, any divine expression. So runs the text, and so we must read it, "God our Savior; who will have all men to be saved, and to come unto the knowledge of the truth." (Metropolitan Tabernacle Pulpit, Vol. 26, Pilgrim Publications, p.50.)

What Starting Point?

Many Calvinists, in their reasonings with Arminians, want to make "Total Depravity," or the 1st of the "five points," the "starting point" in discussions about salvation, or the order and way of salvation. These are convinced that to see and understand "Total Depravity" clears the way to see and understand the other 4 points.

However, why can't we start at the end and work backward to the beginning, in our reasonings, instead of starting at the beginning and working forward to the end?

In causality, is it not important to understand the "end" in order to comprehend the "beginning"? Is not understanding "final cause" (purpose fulfilled) not integral to understanding "first cause" (purpose intended)?

Are Baptists Arminian or Calvinist? Historically, they have been a mixture of both. Therefore, being strictly one of the other is not a "Baptist distinctive."

However, universally, except for the Hyper Arminian few, they have embraced the "5th point" in Calvinism, the idea of "once saved, always saved" (or variously expressed).

Thus, for Baptists who are discussing soteriology, we ought rather to begin with the final result and work backwards to discover the reasons behind the end.

Why are believers secure? Why can they not lose their position of sonship? Why can they not be condemned and lose salvation?

To me this is a better "starting point" than "Total Depravity."

Garrett's Debate History

I am now working with two "Church of Christ" ministers on propositions for debates over the next year. I will let you know when the dates, propositions, and locations have all been finalized.

Some have asked of my past history in debates. Well, besides the ones I have moderated or attended or read, these are the ones in which I have actually been the debater.

Patrick T. Donahue & Thomas N. Thrasher in Monroe, N.C. on April 2-3, 1992. The topic was whether one is saved at the point of faith and on the purpose of water baptism.

Thomas N. Thrasher in Huntsville, AL in October, 1992 on Free Will and Predestination.

Patrick T. Donahue in Athens, AL on October 29-31, 1992 on the purpose of water baptism.

Thomas N. Thrasher in Atlanta, GA. in October of 1993 on Free Will and Predestination.

Thomas N. Thrasher & Patrick T. Donahue in Monroe, NC., August 5, 1995 on Original Sin.

John A. Welch in Indianapolis, IN., June 6-7, 9-10, 1994, on the question when a person is born again, at the point of faith or in water baptism.

Patrick Donahue in October, 2006 in Monroe, N.C. 1st topic was on "once saved always saved" and the 2nd on "unconditional election."

I am still waiting for any Hardshell to come forward and debate Hardshellism. I am also still waiting for James White or some other of the neo "Reformed" crowd who wants to debate the "born again before faith" topic.

Daily-Throgmorton Debate Excerpts

"He says that in Eph. 1:1-13, they trusted after they heard, and that they were regenerated before they heard. He quotes from the book of Suppositions. The idea of a man that doesn’t trust in Jesus Christ being regenerated, when Jesus Christ says such a man is condemned and under the wrath of God. Children of God are not under the wrath of God, they are justified."

"He said no preacher could give life to a dead sinner. Who said he could? I said God gives life. God employs the preaching of the gospel as a means in giving life. That is what I am arguing. He is setting up a straw man and amusing himself by throwing at him. I am here; throw at me."

"The "Old School" brethren argue that faith is the direct gift of God. Yet Brother Daily has been arguing that if the Spirit acts directly he cannot use the word, and yet he has the Spirit giving the faith as God’s direct gift. And this is going into the book. How will that look in the book?"

"Does the alien sinner have to become willing in order to be regenerated?" Don’t you think so? I thought you all believed that. So often have I heard your preachers quote, "My people shall be a willing people in the day of power." (In giving this quotation, Mr. Throgmorton intones the words.) I have heard that away back when I was a little boy. Yes, the sinner has to become willing."

"He says Kirkland and others went off into heresy and a year ago he said he was glad they went. He didn’t say that this time. He is glad they went after they got to be heretics."

He says he has baptized more missionaries than I have of his people. I can’t just now count up. I have baptized several of them, and I tell you this, judging by the way the two denominations grow, I wouldn’t infer that he got very many of us. Old School Baptists don’t have many converts. Their children go to our Baptist churches and to Methodist churches and under the preaching of the gospel, are converted. Then they go back and join; go back and tell what the Lord has done for them. I have known scores of cases of that kind."

"Converts among them in their meetings are few. I believe so far that more than fifty per cent whom I have known to join them went from meetings of other denominations where they were converted. Of course they told their story and were taken in and baptized; they were pronounced elect and all right, and it was believed that preaching had no more to do with saving them than had the saloon. I have heard just that kind of talk."

"He tells you that the word of God is the incorruptible seed. So do I. "Being born again, not of corruptible seed, but incorruptible by the word of God which liveth and abideth forever." "And this is the word which by the gospel is preached unto you." "Wherefore laying aside all malice, and all guile, and hypocrisies, and envies, and all evil speakings, as new born babes desire the sincere milk of the word that ye may grow thereby." 2 Peter 1:23-25 and 2:1-2). The same word all the way through." (Daily Throgmorton debate on 2nd proposition, 3rd speech of Throgmorton - 1914)

Chronological Order or Not?

"These shall make war with the Lamb, and the Lamb shall overcome them: for he is Lord of lords, and King of kings: and they that are with him are called, and chosen, and faithful." (Revelation 17: 14 KJV)

"Therefore, my brothers, be all the more eager to make your calling and election sure." (II Peter 1: 10 NIV)

These verses put calling before election, but election is elsewhere shown to precede calling. So, why do Peter and John put calling before election?

"And such were some of you: but ye are washed, but ye are sanctified, but ye are justified in the name of the Lord Jesus, and by the Spirit of our God." (I Corinthians 6: 11 KJV)

Paul puts sanctification before justification. Is that the actual order?

It is clear that when the parts of salvation are listed, they are not listed in any logical or chronological order.

Oct 1, 2008

More from Berkouwer

"Nevertheless, we cannot share Kuyper's attitude toward the words of the confession. Kuyper said that later theologians abandoned "this more or less questionable manner of speech and set regeneration in the foreground." He went on to say that the confession contained a "subjective conception." Here Kuyper's criticism of the confession suggests, I think, that he puts too much importance on the arrangement of the steps in the ordo salutis. The decisive point is the way in which faith is related to God's grace. And this was in the confession, as it was in Calvin, above reproach. It is just as unreasable to brand the formulation which we find in Calvin and the confession as subjective conceptions as it is to charge post-confessional development with shifting interest from grace to man. Faith involves a certain subjectivity, but a subjectivity which has meaning only as it is bound to the gospel."

"This is precisely the marvel of the word of the Holy Ghost -- that He is the origin of this faith. It is not the order as such that is decisive. It is how one understands God's salvation that determines whether sovereign divine grace is properly respected. To make a system of a certain order of salvation does not insure purity of doctrine. Nor does simplifying the ordo salutis guarantee a pure confession of grace.

This becomes more interesting and important when we see that it is not possible to deduce a fixed ordo from the the words of Scripture and their order. An ordo is often read from Romans 8: 30: "And whom he foreordained, them he also called: and whom he called, them he also justified: and whom he justified, them he also glorified." Other texts are also used in this regard. Consider I Corinthians 1: 30: "But of him are ye in Christ Jesus, who was made unto us wisdom from God, and righteousness, and sanctification, and redemption"; I Corinthians 6:11: "And such were some of you: But ye were washed, but ye were sanctified, but ye were justified in the name of the Lord Jesus Christ, and in the Spirit of our God"; and Titus 3: 5: "Not by words done in righteousness, which we did ourselves, but according to his mercy he saved us, through the washing of regeneration and the renewing of the Holy Spirit." The great variety which is apparent in the words Paul uses brings to mind the expression of Seeberg: "Only the richness, not the order, of the way of grace comes to expression." The text which looks most as though it presents a definite sequence is Romans 8:30, in which Paul, while discussion election, notes the phases of the way of salvation - calling, justification, glorification. Sanctification is conspicuously absent in this list; and anyone with a mind to accept Paul's list as a systematic arrangement of the course of salvation, would surely be unwilling to omit sanctification from the sequence."

What does Paul intend here? He evidently means to characterize salvation in Christ, the salvation which arises from the depths of the Father's heart and reaches out into time with an eternal blessing. The context suggests that Paul does not have a sequence in mind. He is talking about the work, and particularly the prayer, of the Holy Ghost (Rom. 8: 23, 26, 27), about hope (Rom. 8: 24, 35), about love to God (Rom. 8: 28), and about the cooperation of all things for the good of those who love Him (Rom. 8: 28). A simple biblicism, which sees a sequence here, would bring us into trouble when faced with I Corinthians 6: 11, which puts sanctification before justification."

(I do disagree with Berkouwer on this last point. I do believe Paul gives a definite order in Romans 8 SG)

"It is clear that we cannot answer the question of the ordo salutis with a compbination of scriptural terms. The determinative question is whether, in the way of salvation, we give sufficient expression to the fact that the life of the believer - from first to last - is embraced by divine salvation.

We need not be afraid that by reflecting on the relation of this divine salvation to human subjectivity we are harboring an objection to the sovereignty of grace. Salvation has everything to do with human life down to its most subjective facets. Neither need we think that the way of salvation has to do with an "application" of salvation, as though a "second salvation" - a subjective one in distinction from an objective work of Christ - had to be realized. Rather, it is concerned with the achievement of the purpose of grace. When a person sees this clearly, he will never make faith one distinct point in the way of salvation. To do such a thing with faith, says Stephen, "Robs it of its fundamental and comprehensive significance as the one unifying doctrine of evangelical Christianity. If the ordo salutis were really intended to be a straight line drawn through a sequence of causal factors it would be open to the same objections that we have against the Roman Catholic concept of the function of faith as a preparatory phase preceding justification or infused grace. Reformation theology has always protested that faith thus loses its central and total character and becomes a mere step on the way of salvation. In contrast to this devaluation of faith, the Reformation confessed sola fide, meaning thereby to emphasize the universal significance of faith. In this way faith possesses no unique functional value; it rests wholly in God's grace. Theological study of the way of salvation, or ordo salutis, must, then, always revolve about the correlation between faith and justification. It must simply cut away everything which blocks its perspective of this sola fide. Heresy always invades the ordo salutis at this point, and this is why it is so necessary to realize that the entire way of salvation is only meant to illuminate sola fide and sola gratia. For only thus can it be confessed that Christ is the way.

Theologians, in their studies on the ordo salutis, have often done injustice to Christ by making subtle distinctions and divisions between the objectivity and subjectivity of salvation. Christology, for instance, has often been reckoned with the objective while soteriology has been put in the subjective sphere. Salvation was thus practically construed as composed of two factors, one divine and one human, while the totality of salvation was to be seen in their combination. Grace and redemption were considered as the objective state of affairs. Grace and freedom of choice, grace and merit were part of human activity. But in this way the correlation between faith and justification was lost sight of. A tension arose between the work of God in Christ and the role of man."


http://books.google.com/books?id=nhKfPGVmcI0C&pg=PA30&lpg=PA30&dq=calvinism+regeneration+faith+ordo+salutis&source=web&ots=9x4c3UxlQm&sig=V8yqsRO9opHsRLSbHaOTEyZUJg8&hl=en&sa=X&oi=book_result&resnum=5&ct=result#PPA42,M1

October's Agenda

I am looking forward, the Lord willing, to completing my series "Hardshell Proof Texts" this month. Already I have looked at four major verses in the writings of John that Hardshells, and Hyper Calvinists, and some neo "Reformed" Baptists and PedoBaptists, use in an attempt to prove that one is "regenerated" or "born again" "prior to" or "before" or "antecedent to" experiencing "repentance toward God and faith in our Lord Jesus Christ," namely John 1:10-13, John 3: 3-8, I John 5: 1, and John 5:24, 25.

I was a little amazed that I did not get one comment from a Hardshell, or other Hyperist, in response to those passages. Where is Gene's rebuttal? Is James still reading? If he could take time to make a blog entry about my "search engine" skills, it seems he could take the same amount of time and write a rebuttal to my interpretation of those four passages. Maybe he saw the title of the articles had "Hardshell" in it and he thought they could not apply to him?

I am also a little surprised that I have not even gotten an "amen" comment. I have had several, over the past few months, who have asked that I write on the verses cited by the "born again before faith" crowd and show how they err. I have done that on four leading verses used by them and have, to my judgment, completely disproved their faulty reasoning and "eisogesus."

Nevertheless, hopefully what I am writing will be of benefit to not only those who are reading this book as I write it, but also to future generations, who it is presumed will continue to debate this topic.

"The Hardshell Baptist Cult" book has ever been intended to be exhaustive, as much as possible, of the Hardshell denomination, and to deal with it from both the scriptures and from history. Are they really the "Primitive" or "Original" Baptists on this important bible doctrine?

Anyway, the upcoming chapters in the series on "Hardshell Proof Texts" will deal with the "drawing" of John 6 and with the question - "is the 'drawing' equated with the new birth?" Also, what is meant by "coming to Christ"? Is this regeneration or conversion, or both?

I will also look at verses in John 8 & 10 that are used by Hardshells to uphold their false "ordo salutis." I will also look at some verses in Acts, at the conversions of the 3000 on the day of Pentecost, of Cornelius' household, of Lydia, and Paul.

I will then look at passages in the epistles that Hardshells use to uphold their Hyperism, and their attempt to prove that faith in Christ is not necessary for eternal salvation.

So, stay tuned! And, if anyone wants to comment in opposition or agreement, please feel free to do so.

I want to also say that I have other articles in draft form, apart from that which is part of the Hardshell book, and I hope they will be of interest to the Gadfly's readers.

Stephen

From an Old Hardshell Periodical

I have proven in earlier chapters in my ongoing book on "The Hardshell Baptist Cult" how most of the "founding fathers" of Hardshellism, or the "Primitive Baptist" denomination, embraced what I have called the "three stage model of the new birth." The following citations from the original "Primitive Baptist" publication, which began about the same time as the "Signs of the Times" publication, edited by Elder Gilbert Beebe, and was thus one of the first two Hardshell periodicals began immediately after the "anti-missionaries" declared "non-fellowship" for mission Baptists through the infamous "Black Rock Address" (1832). This first "Primitive Baptist" publication was published from North Carolina, sometimes from Tarborough and sometimes from Raleigh. The later more famous Hardshell periodical, also called "The Primitive Baptist," was not begun till the 1880's under Elder S. F. Cayce, and continued under the leadership of the infamous Hardshell debater, his son Elder Claud Cayce, and even now under his grandson, Elder Hartsell Cayce.

Here are then the citations I have found from the original "Primitive Baptist" periodical with the dates of the writings given. Do they not uphold the "three stage model" of the "new birth"?

"NOW IT IS BY THE WASHING of regeneration and not the act of the creature; and when the creature does receive the washing of regeneration, then and there it is that faith comes, and Jesus Christ is revealed to this soul the hope of glory, and the fairest of ten thousand, and altogether lovely. Why now? Because the time is come for faith to be revealed, or given of God to the creature…" AUTHOR: Rorer, Rudolph in The Primitve Baptist (Oct. 1843)

http://www.upbuild.org/article33.html

"IN ORDER TO SALVATION, it is necessary that we be born again; that we have faith, repent and believe in the Lord Jesus Christ; but as salvation is of the Lord, these things are as much of him as our redemption, calling or justification, for his “divine power hath given us all things that pertain unto life and godliness.” II Pet. i. 4. “He that spared not his own Son, but delivered him up for us all, how shall he not with him also freely give us all things?”" AUTHOR: Mitchell, William M.

http://www.upbuild.org/article43.html

"DEARLY BELOVED BRETHREN, who are scattered abroad throughout the wide world, and are spurned at by all your enemies, yet preserved of the Lord and blest with all spiritual blessings in heavenly places in Christ, according as he hath chosen us in him before the foundation of the world, that we should be holy and without blame before him in love, that we might glorify him in all godly conversation in this present world; being born again, not of corruptible seed, but of incorruptible, by the word of God, which liveth and abideth for ever. And without this change, or birth, it is impossible for the creature to glorify God either in word, thought, or deed. But believing all the family of Zion are of this parentage and of the same royal line, heirs of the same King, and were all in days past children of wrath even as others, but are now called of God according to his purpose, made heirs of eternal glory and joint heirs with the Lord Jesus Christ; and have not received the Spirit of bondage again to fear, but ye have received the Spirit of adoption whereby we cry, Abba, Father. Brethren, you know this change is not a mere notion, for without a pain there can be no birth. But where there is a false conception there is a false deliverance; there is brought forth nothing but wind, a few snubs and tears shed, and run up and fall down at the feet of him that is called a preacher, and him to repeat a few words of memorized prayer, is not this birth. (Is he condemning the methods of Finney? SG) But, brethren, these pains are brought on by the candle of the grace of God shining in the dark room of the heart, and quickening the dead soul; and the nearer the time of deliverance, the greater the agony and more severe the pain, yet they have it to bear until the time of deliverance comes. And when the babe is born in Zion, then clothe it with the best robe, and shoes put on its feet, and a ring on its hand; and it is not to be led into error, but into all truth. And now, brethren and sisters, does the child that is not yet born after ordinary generation, know anything of the affairs and laws and management, neither is acquainted with the light in this world? No more does the soul, until born of the Spirit, know anything of this spiritual kingdom. For that which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the spirit is spirit. So, brethren, we need not wonder at carnal professors altering the laws, rules, and customs of this spiritual kingdom, and crying, lo here, and lo there, is Christ; believe them not, because the carnal mind is enmity against God." in The Primitive Baptist (1842)
AUTHOR: Rushing, W. M.

http://www.upbuild.org/article67.html

"THE LORD JESUS CHRIST HIMSELF says: “My sheep hear my voice, and I know them, and they follow me, and I give unto them eternal life, and they shall never perish, neither shall any pluck them out of my hand.”—John x.28. When they are quickened by the lifegiving Spirit and power of God, and hear the voice of Jesus’ pardoning love, then “faith comes by hearing.” They feel personally interested in the atonement by the blood of Jesus. Christ dwells in them by faith. His righteousness is there, his redemption for them is there, his love, his wisdom and all the treasures of his grace are in their heart by faith."
"Faith Cometh By Hearing," The Gospel Messenger (Dec. 1882)AUTHOR: Mitchell, William M.

http://www.upbuild.org/article78.html